{
 "film": "Scarce or Secure",
 "cut_en": "v97",
 "cut_zh": "v100",
 "film_en_seconds": 3167.125,
 "film_zh_seconds": 3446.583,
 "build": "937999ba81ce",
 "items": [
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0000",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 0.0,
   "film_en_end": 2.05,
   "film_zh_start": 0.0,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "January 2009.",
   "who": "Hal Finney, email to the Cryptography Mailing List",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Hal Finney, \"Bitcoin v0.1 released\" thread, Cryptography Mailing List",
   "source_url": "https://satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org/emails/cryptography/threads/2/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The v8.7 check read the Nakamoto Institute archive: the Finney email is dated 11 Jan 2009, 02:22:01 UTC.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0000.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-finney",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2.57,
   "film_en_end": 15.002,
   "film_zh_start": 2.57,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Hal Finney, on a mailing list: \"As an amusing thought experiment, imagine that Bitcoin is successful... With 20 million coins, that gives each coin a value of about $10 million.\"",
   "who": "Hal Finney, email to the Cryptography Mailing List",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Hal Finney, \"Bitcoin v0.1 released\" thread, Cryptography Mailing List",
   "source_url": "https://satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org/emails/cryptography/threads/2/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Matched word for word against the Nakamoto Institute archive (11 Jan 2009, 02:22:01 UTC).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-finney.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h4",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 20.0,
   "film_en_end": 26.75,
   "film_zh_start": 20.12,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Drive Bitcoin to $10 million a coin, and make Bitcoin a 200 trillion dollar network",
   "who": "Michael Saylor",
   "role": "Executive Chairman, Strategy, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor keynote, Bitcoin 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Y8HAqAYMhE",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh02",
     2693.43,
     2700.17
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h4.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h6b",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 26.75,
   "film_en_end": 32.292,
   "film_zh_start": 26.88,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "2040, 2041, '42, could get to 100 trillion in market cap, that magical 100 trillion",
   "who": "Matthew Mežinskis",
   "role": "Creator, Porkopolis Economics, BTC Prague 2026 main stage panel, Jun 2026",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin's Most Accurate Price Model, BTC Prague 2026 main stage panel",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXJw4IfT5SU",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh24",
     1156.18,
     1161.68
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "He hedges: \"could\", and later in the same talk, \"there's a lot of assumptions\".",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h6b.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h6d",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 32.292,
   "film_en_end": 39.083,
   "film_zh_start": 32.38,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "basically the dislocation between the Bitcoin future and the fiat present, which is a one to two hundred trillion arbitrage.",
   "who": "Adam Back",
   "role": "CEO, Blockstream, BTC Sessions, Jun 2025",
   "source_title": "Adam Back, BTC Sessions: Bitcoin Treasury Companies, Scam or $200 Trillion Bombshell?",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGpznPiMMDE",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh13",
     1.5,
     8.28
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h6d.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h5",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 39.083,
   "film_en_end": 43.417,
   "film_zh_start": 39.17,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Bitcoin worth 100 trillion, 200 trillion, 300 trillion.",
   "who": "Max Keiser",
   "role": "Senior Bitcoin Advisor to President Bukele, Simply Bitcoin, Ep. 1075, 13 Sep 2024",
   "source_title": "Max Keiser, Simply Bitcoin Ep. 1075",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lnE7o9B0dhQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh10",
     149.48,
     153.78
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h5.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h6c",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 43.417,
   "film_en_end": 53.792,
   "film_zh_start": 43.5,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "testing the theory. We should have a 1 million Bitcoin in 8 years, and then 10 million Bitcoins in 20 years. Thank you.",
   "who": "Giovanni Santostasi",
   "role": "$10 million a coin: about $210 trillion for all 21 million., BTC Prague 2026, Jun 2026",
   "source_title": "Giovanni Santostasi, The Next 8 Years of Bitcoin, BTC Prague 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k24BWHjhzC8",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh23",
     1154.62,
     1165.0
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "He presents it as a prediction to be tested, not a certainty.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h6c.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h6e",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 53.792,
   "film_en_end": 59.583,
   "film_zh_start": 53.88,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "13 million. It could be, it could be a 3 million bear case, it could be a 49 million bull case.",
   "who": "Michael Saylor",
   "role": "Executive Chairman, Strategy, Bitcoin 2024 keynote, 26 Jul 2024",
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor, Bitcoin 2024 keynote",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O9KnBcWMkpw",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh04",
     1134.0,
     1139.77
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h6e.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h6f",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 59.583,
   "film_en_end": 64.792,
   "film_zh_start": 59.67,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "They'll be buying it at 10 million a coin or 20 million a coin or 50 million a coin.",
   "who": "Michael Saylor",
   "role": "Executive Chairman, Strategy, DC Blockchain Summit 2025 · The Digital Chamber, Mar 2025",
   "source_title": "DC Blockchain Summit 2025: Bitcoin as a Strategic Reserve",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gl7BmihifK0",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh06",
     1337.6,
     1342.8
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h6f.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h6",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 64.792,
   "film_en_end": 67.708,
   "film_zh_start": 64.88,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "to eventually $300, $400, $500 trillion.",
   "who": null,
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "DC Blockchain Summit 2025: Bitcoin as a Strategic Reserve",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gl7BmihifK0",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh06",
     1168.3,
     1171.2
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h6.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h7",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 67.708,
   "film_en_end": 72.917,
   "film_zh_start": 67.79,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "I expect 21 million coins at a $21 million price in 21 years.",
   "who": "Michael Saylor",
   "role": "Executive Chairman, Strategy, BTC Prague 2025, Jun 2025",
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor, The Power of 21, BTC Prague 2025 keynote",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hqoagNBtIps",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh03",
     1348.5,
     1353.69
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h7.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0078",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 78.587,
   "film_en_end": 81.827,
   "film_zh_start": 78.87,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "And that pay gets cut in half every four years.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin protocol: the subsidy halves every 210,000 blocks (nSubsidyHalvingInterval)",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/src/kernel/chainparams.cpp",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The figures registry records the 210,000-block halving interval as a protocol constant, and the security-line data records 52,560 blocks a year; 210,000 / 52,560 is 3.995 years.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2009-01-03. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0078.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0082",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 82.047,
   "film_en_end": 84.277,
   "film_zh_start": 82.46,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Hundreds of trillions of dollars.",
   "who": "Narrator, recapping the preceding speakers (Saylor, Keiser)",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor, \"The Power of 21\" keynote, BTC Prague 2025 (Bitcoin Magazine upload)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hqoagNBtIps",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The research note records the caption-verified words: Saylor says Bitcoin 'approaches hundreds of trillions of dollars'. The hook montage before this line also carries Keiser (100, 200, 300 trillion) and Saylor at Bitcoin 2026 ($200 trillion).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0082.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h11",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 96.125,
   "film_en_end": 108.792,
   "film_zh_start": 96.83,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "At what point does that present some type of existential risk to Bitcoin mining activity on the network? Yeah, I don't, there is no existential risk to it. I think that's not something to worry about.",
   "who": "Michael Saylor",
   "role": "Executive Chairman, Strategy, Naples Family Office Symposium, Nov 2025",
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor, Naples Family Office Symposium (re-upload)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X5CHFPKvW6w",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh18",
     2422.9,
     2435.52
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h11.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-o2",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 108.792,
   "film_en_end": 118.917,
   "film_zh_start": 109.46,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "No matter what the block reward goes to, the network is just getting more secure. It's a one-way ratchet exponentially up forever.",
   "who": null,
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor, Naples Family Office Symposium (re-upload)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X5CHFPKvW6w",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh18",
     2618.1,
     2628.22
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-o2.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-saylor-x",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 118.937,
   "film_en_end": 128.925,
   "film_zh_start": 119.6,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Same man, months later, in writing: \"Their subsidy halves every 210,000 blocks, so fees must carry more of the security burden.\"",
   "who": "Michael Saylor, post on X",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor, post on X",
   "source_url": "https://x.com/saylor/status/2082141015113085050",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Post read through the X oEmbed endpoint; author and wording match the film.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-saylor-x.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h15",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 131.417,
   "film_en_end": 135.75,
   "film_zh_start": 132.33,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "And so isn't this a problem? And I actually don't think it's a problem.",
   "who": "Pierre Rochard",
   "role": "CEO, The Bitcoin Bond Company · Strive board, Roundtable Network, May 2026",
   "source_title": "Roundtable Network video post, 27 May 2026",
   "source_url": "https://x.com/RTB_io/status/2059653352120819902",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh19",
     370.0,
     374.32
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h15.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h16a",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 135.75,
   "film_en_end": 144.375,
   "film_zh_start": 136.67,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "In the security budget, I'm not so worried about it because, you know, Bitcoin price has much more than doubled every 4 years, which is the halving cycle.",
   "who": "Adam Back",
   "role": "CEO, Blockstream, Bitcoin Suisse interview, Jul 2026",
   "source_title": "Adam Back, The Clock Is Ticking on Bitcoin's Biggest Threat (Bitcoin Suisse)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vO0y0E7pa_A",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh25",
     2429.0,
     2437.62
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "These are not his only reasons: in the same answer he also points to hardware, lock times and how much less secure other forms of money are.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h16a.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h16b",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 144.375,
   "film_en_end": 151.292,
   "film_zh_start": 145.29,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "A quick question, what's the appropriate level of security spend? They're like, well, I don't know. So I'm like, well, you can't call it broken if you don't know what the appropriate level should be.",
   "who": "Dan Held",
   "role": "Formerly Kraken · General Partner, Asymmetric · centre panel, Unchained podcast, 16 May 2023",
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_N8QkRLP7T0",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "_N8QkRLP7T0",
     3044.0,
     3050.9
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h16b.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h14a",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 151.292,
   "film_en_end": 169.792,
   "film_zh_start": 152.21,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "If you believe Bitcoin will have some kind of issue in the longer term, based on the security budget, please raise your hand now. So I'm gonna eyeball that at maybe 5%. Hands up if you believe there is not a long-term security budget debate. I'm eyeballing that at about 85%.",
   "who": "Moderator",
   "role": "BTC Prague 2025 debate, Jun 2025",
   "source_title": "Who Really Controls Bitcoin? BTC Prague 2025 debate",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HNz_Brpscs",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h14a.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-leclair-x",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 169.832,
   "film_en_end": 177.622,
   "film_zh_start": 170.79,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "\"Your inherent desire for human intervention at every turn is exactly what bitcoin solved, please just shut up.\"",
   "who": "Dylan LeClair, post on X",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Dylan LeClair, post on X",
   "source_url": "https://x.com/DylanLeClair/status/1655599877751988228",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Handle and wording confirmed through the X oEmbed endpoint.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-leclair-x.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-o5",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 177.708,
   "film_en_end": 189.167,
   "film_zh_start": 178.62,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "On a scale of 1 to 10. How concerned are you for that, the idea that once the subsidy is diminished, there won't be enough transaction fees to furnish Bitcoin mining? I would say an 8.",
   "who": "Colin Harper and Paul Sztorc",
   "role": "Moderator, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026; LayerTwo Labs · author of BIP-300 · founder of the eCash fork, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "The Post-Subsidy World, Bitcoin 2026 (Sztorc, Hansen, Casey, Harper)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5DzU1CkyAc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t4",
     101.17,
     102.52
    ],
    [
     "t4",
     104.7,
     112.92
    ],
    [
     "t4",
     113.62,
     115.5
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Paul Sztorc describes the problem only. He has his own proposed fix, not the one in this film.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-o5.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h20a",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 191.542,
   "film_en_end": 202.917,
   "film_zh_start": 192.5,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "And we don't know what the security budget needs to be. Like, does it need to be $50 billion a year? Does it need to be $100 billion a year? $200 billion a year? We don't know.",
   "who": "PBJ",
   "role": "Presidio Bitcoin podcast, PBJ Podcast, May 2026",
   "source_title": "PBJ Podcast, Presidio Bitcoin",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDSRdGXY6cQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t37",
     986.7,
     998.04
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "They say nobody knows how big the security budget needs to be. They do not say fees can't pay for it.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h20a.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h21",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 202.917,
   "film_en_end": 208.667,
   "film_zh_start": 203.83,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "So there clearly is a Goldilocks zone somewhere, but we really don't know where it is.",
   "who": "Hasu",
   "role": "Researcher, Value of Bitcoin talk, 2020",
   "source_title": "Hasu, Is Bitcoin secure after the block subsidy ends? (Value of Bitcoin Digital, Halving Edition)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zPYkL6L3VGw",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvv05",
     695.8,
     701.54
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h21.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h20g",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 208.667,
   "film_en_end": 214.333,
   "film_zh_start": 209.58,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "We honestly just don't know how much do we actually need to fend off all of these potential attacks.",
   "who": "Sam Wouters",
   "role": "Bitcoin research analyst, River, What Bitcoin Did, 13 Feb 2023",
   "source_title": "The Future of Bitcoin Mining and Security with Sam Wouters (What Bitcoin Did)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N_LkZlm9X1k",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t67",
     2111.87,
     2117.54
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h20g.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h20h",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 214.333,
   "film_en_end": 224.083,
   "film_zh_start": 215.29,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "We don't know how much we need sufficiently high amount daily spend that would deter that kind of attacker, we don't know.",
   "who": "The “Jordan McKinney” channel",
   "role": "“Bitcoin's Declining Security: The Security Budget Problem”, YouTube, 12 Jul 2021",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin's Declining Security: The Security Budget Problem (the Jordan McKinney channel)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ARTUfzKU8_s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t53",
     2310.85,
     2313.25
    ],
    [
     "t53",
     2332.9,
     2340.2
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h20h.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h20m",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 224.083,
   "film_en_end": 231.958,
   "film_zh_start": 225.0,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "We don't know what an appropriate level of blockchain security spend should be. We don't know if that's 1 billion, 5 billion, 10 billion, or 100 billion.",
   "who": "Dan Held",
   "role": "Formerly Kraken · General Partner, Asymmetric, Bitcoin Fundamentals podcast, 10 Mar 2021",
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ly-Gv6qNbNg",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "Ly-Gv6qNbNg",
     2495.7,
     2503.57
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h20m.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h20b",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 231.958,
   "film_en_end": 237.042,
   "film_zh_start": 232.88,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Is it four halvings from now, eight halvings from now, 15 halvings from now? We, no one really knows.",
   "who": "Jimmy Song",
   "role": "Author, Programming Bitcoin, Debate with Peter Todd, BTC Prague 2025, Jun 2025",
   "source_title": "Who Really Controls Bitcoin? BTC Prague 2025 debate",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HNz_Brpscs",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh22",
     625.18,
     630.23
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h20b.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h20d",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 237.042,
   "film_en_end": 246.042,
   "film_zh_start": 237.96,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "and this is ultimately the question no one can really answer. The only way that we can find out is by building it, by putting the functionality out.",
   "who": "Jameson Lopp",
   "role": "Co-founder and Chief Security Officer, Casa, Look Into Bitcoin, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "The Fate of Bitcoin's Future, with Jameson Lopp (Look Into Bitcoin)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6XsBbDqrNdI",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh21",
     165.5,
     174.5
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h20d.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-o1",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 246.042,
   "film_en_end": 252.125,
   "film_zh_start": 246.96,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "to $30 a transaction to $300 a transaction to $3,000 to $30,000 to $300,000.",
   "who": "Michael Saylor",
   "role": "Executive Chairman, Strategy, The Iced Coffee Hour (clip), Jun 2024",
   "source_title": "What Happens When ALL 21 Million Bitcoin Are Mined? (Michael Saylor, The Iced Coffee Hour clip)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSSemefMEfg",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh16",
     120.02,
     126.1
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-o1.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h20c",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 252.125,
   "film_en_end": 260.292,
   "film_zh_start": 253.08,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Second, the fee markets have developed in the past, at least for short periods of time. There's no reason to believe that they won't continue to develop.",
   "who": "Jimmy Song",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Who Really Controls Bitcoin? BTC Prague 2025 debate",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HNz_Brpscs",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh22",
     645.5,
     650.53
    ],
    [
     "dvh22",
     660.78,
     663.9
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h20c.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h20f",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 260.292,
   "film_en_end": 263.542,
   "film_zh_start": 261.25,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "That's why I'd call it like a flawed design, but I think it'll work out.",
   "who": "PBJ",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "PBJ Podcast, Presidio Bitcoin",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDSRdGXY6cQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t37",
     1187.43,
     1190.66
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h20f.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-e9",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 263.542,
   "film_en_end": 281.458,
   "film_zh_start": 264.5,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "If I can jump in, the problem I think is because of the halvings, it's basically we're a frog in a boiling pot of water and the temperature is going up really slowly, really slowly, really slowly, and so nobody's concerned about the fee market right now because there's a subsidy.",
   "who": "Mike Casey",
   "role": "Bitcoin security researcher · formerly MARA, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "The Post-Subsidy World, Bitcoin 2026 (Sztorc, Hansen, Casey, Harper)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5DzU1CkyAc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t4",
     754.85,
     772.75
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Words from a machine transcript and YouTube's captions; not yet checked by ear.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-e9.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-h21a",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 281.458,
   "film_en_end": 299.208,
   "film_zh_start": 282.42,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "And everybody assumes, oh, OK. Well, if the price doubles, and the Bitcoin subsidy halves, well, that's net net. Everything's even. A lot of people believe that. But I think all four of us know that that's not true. take out a piece of paper and start multiplying, and you'll see that doesn't work.",
   "who": "Paul Sztorc",
   "role": "LayerTwo Labs · author of BIP-300 · founder of the eCash fork, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "The Post-Subsidy World, Bitcoin 2026 (Sztorc, Hansen, Casey, Harper)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5DzU1CkyAc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t4",
     772.75,
     786.84
    ],
    [
     "t4",
     788.58,
     792.2
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-h21a.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0300",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 300.798,
   "film_en_end": 307.908,
   "film_zh_start": 301.72,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Pay what Bitcoin pays today, about a dollar a year on every hundred: over four trillion dollars a year.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The film's own sum, checked in the v8.7 figures and credits check ($21M a coin x 21M coins x 1%)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The v8.7 check re-worked it: 21,000,000 x $21,000,000 = $441T; 1% a year = $4.41T. Today's measured rate is 0.82% (registry figure security_spend_pct).",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0300.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0308",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 308.398,
   "film_en_end": 311.548,
   "film_zh_start": 309.33,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "The block reward by then: about a hundred billion.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The film's own sum, checked in the v8.7 figures and credits check (2046 reward at $21M a coin)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The v8.7 check re-worked it: 0.09765625 BTC x $21M x 52,560 blocks = $107.8B.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0308.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0313",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 313.768,
   "film_en_end": 315.328,
   "film_zh_start": 314.71,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Over eighty million dollars.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The film's own sum, checked in the v8.7 figures and credits check (fees needed per block in 2046)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The v8.7 check re-worked it: ($4.41T - $0.108T) / 52,560 blocks = $81.85M a block.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0313.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0317",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 317.008,
   "film_en_end": 320.978,
   "film_zh_start": 317.95,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Four bitcoin in fees alone, more than the whole reward today.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The film's own sum, checked in the v8.7 figures and credits check ($81.85M / $21M a coin)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The v8.7 check re-worked it: $81.85M / $21M = 3.90 BTC a block, against today's 3.125 BTC reward.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0317.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0321",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 321.318,
   "film_en_end": 323.948,
   "film_zh_start": 322.27,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "Over fifteen thousand dollars a transaction.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The film's own sum, checked in the v8.7 figures and credits check ($4.302T over recent transaction counts)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The v8.7 check divided the per-block fee need by recent transactions a block: $19,750 (last 1,008 blocks, 4,145 tx a block) and $17,530 (last 4,320 blocks, 4,670 tx a block).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0321.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0324",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 324.052,
   "film_en_end": 327.122,
   "film_zh_start": 325.01,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "Hook",
   "said": "They can give you a price, twenty-one years out.",
   "who": "Michael Saylor, as summarised by the narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor, \"The Power of 21\" keynote, BTC Prague 2025 (Bitcoin Magazine upload)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hqoagNBtIps&t=1346s",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The research note records the caption-verified words: 'I expect 21 million coins at a $21 million price in 21 years.'",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0324.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-ishares",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 352.258,
   "film_en_end": 356.888,
   "film_zh_start": 355.44,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "Cold open",
   "said": "The reduction in mining rewards could jeopardize the security of the Bitcoin network.",
   "who": "The narrator, reading from BlackRock's iShares Bitcoin Trust filing",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "iShares Bitcoin Trust 10-K 2026-02-27",
   "source_url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1980994/000143774926006058/bit20251231_10k.htm",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The film's words are compared below with the filing's paragraph, which is re-checked word for word at every build.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a risk factor: a required list of things that could go wrong. It does not predict that this will happen.",
    "It gives no size or date for the risk.",
    "The filer does not endorse this film or anything it proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-ishares.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-filers-50",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "count",
   "label_name": "A count we made",
   "film_en_start": 359.258,
   "film_en_end": 362.708,
   "film_zh_start": 363.46,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "Cold open",
   "said": "50 companies and funds tell the SEC the same thing.",
   "who": "The narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The Security Budget Files: every filing that names this risk",
   "source_url": "https://security-budget-files.pages.dev",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Counted from the five filing lanes' rosters at every build; the build fails if the total is not 50.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-filers-50.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0365",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 365.698,
   "film_en_end": 370.508,
   "film_zh_start": 370.83,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "Cold open",
   "said": "The pay for the machines that keep it safe is cut in half, every four years.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin protocol: the subsidy halves every 210,000 blocks (nSubsidyHalvingInterval)",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/src/kernel/chainparams.cpp",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The figures registry records the 210,000-block halving interval as a protocol constant, and the security-line data records 52,560 blocks a year; 210,000 / 52,560 is 3.995 years.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2009-01-03. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0365.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0379",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 379.278,
   "film_en_end": 384.988,
   "film_zh_start": 386.39,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "Cold open",
   "said": "In August 2025, a crypto project announced it had taken control of a cryptocurrency.",
   "who": "The narrator, summarising Qubic's announcement",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Qubic, post on X (@_Qubic_), 12 Aug 2025",
   "source_url": "https://x.com/_Qubic_/status/1955259183122530541",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The Qubic primary-source record (captured 30 Sep 2026) quotes the post: 'effectively giving it control of the network'. Blog and press release of the same day say it reached over 51% of Monero's hashrate.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0379.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0394",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 394.578,
   "film_en_end": 402.868,
   "film_zh_start": 403.91,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "Cold open",
   "said": "The project, Qubic, had offered the machines that keep Monero safe a better deal: by its own account, up to three times the pay.",
   "who": "The narrator, summarising Qubic's own blog post",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Qubic, \"Epoch 172 Recap - The Monero Experiment\"",
   "source_url": "https://qubic.org/blog-detail/epoch-172-recap-the-monero-experiment",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The Qubic primary-source record (captured 30 Sep 2026) quotes the 7 Aug post: 'up to 3x more than direct Monero mining'.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0394.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0404",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 404.678,
   "film_en_end": 410.028,
   "film_zh_start": 415.48,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "Cold open",
   "said": "With more than half of them, Qubic said, it rewrote part of Monero's recent history.",
   "who": "The narrator, summarising Qubic's announcement",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Qubic, \"Qubic Performs 51% Monero Network Takeover Demonstration\" (blog)",
   "source_url": "https://qubic.org/blog-detail/historic-takeover-complete-qubic-miners-now-secure-monero-network",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The Qubic primary-source record (captured 30 Sep 2026) quotes the blog's lede and the press release ('over 51%', blocks orphaned).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0404.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c14",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 475.578,
   "film_en_end": 481.678,
   "film_zh_start": 496.7,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "The system is as secure as the amount of computing power maintaining it right now.",
   "who": "Eric Budish",
   "role": "Economist, University of Chicago, Columbia Digital Finance Seminar, 17 Oct 2022",
   "source_title": "Columbia Digital Finance Seminar",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=70WsnIqsn5s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "70WsnIqsn5s",
     620.2,
     626.38
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c14.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0482",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 482.368,
   "film_en_end": 485.518,
   "film_zh_start": 504.47,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "But the reward is cut in half every four years.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin protocol: the subsidy halves every 210,000 blocks (nSubsidyHalvingInterval)",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/src/kernel/chainparams.cpp",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The figures registry records the 210,000-block halving interval as a protocol constant, and the security-line data records 52,560 blocks a year; 210,000 / 52,560 is 3.995 years.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2009-01-03. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0482.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0487",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 487.588,
   "film_en_end": 489.738,
   "film_zh_start": 510.45,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "The next one comes in 2028.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin protocol: next halving at block 1,050,000 (5 x 210,000)",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/src/kernel/chainparams.cpp",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry records block 1,050,000 as the 2028 halving (5 x 210,000); its countdown figure, taken 6 Oct 2026 at tip 970,119, gives about 1.5 years (79,881 blocks) to go.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2009-01-03. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0487.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0490",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 490.028,
   "film_en_end": 495.418,
   "film_zh_start": 513.25,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "It's how Bitcoin keeps its most famous promise: only 21 million, ever.",
   "who": "Harry Sudock, The Peter McCormack Show (supports the 21 million cap)",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Mining 101 with Harry Sudock, The Peter McCormack Show",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=452ykF03Taw&t=736s",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The research note records caption-verified words: 'There will never be more than 21 million Bitcoins because any rules that introduced more than 21 million would be rejected'. 22 Sep 2021 is the upload date, not the talk date.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0490.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v0f",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 513.708,
   "film_en_end": 534.583,
   "film_zh_start": 539.5,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "And then they freeze my bank account along with other prominent, you know, activists, 95% of my fiat savings, and all my fiat savings, I will see 100% of my fiat savings, 95% of my entire wealth, And you stay with the Bitcoin and the crypto. but they cannot touch about it.",
   "who": "Win Ko Ko Aung",
   "role": "Burmese human rights activist, You're The Voice with Efrat Fenigson, Jun 2026",
   "source_title": "From Burma to Freedom (You're The Voice with Efrat Fenigson)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MDsounfGwW8",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvv27",
     919.5,
     925.0
    ],
    [
     "dvv27",
     943.0,
     958.12
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v0f.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v0a",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 534.583,
   "film_en_end": 553.292,
   "film_zh_start": 560.38,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "If your truck is being used in these protests, your corporate accounts will be frozen. The insurance on your vehicle will be suspended. The consequences are real and they will bite.",
   "who": "Chrystia Freeland",
   "role": "Deputy Prime Minister of Canada, The Canadian Press, Feb 2022",
   "source_title": "Freeland says some protesters' bank accounts frozen (The Canadian Press)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_4I9Rz_g6pU",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvv20",
     91.55,
     110.0
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v0a.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-diem25-x",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 553.292,
   "film_en_end": 562.373,
   "film_zh_start": 579.08,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "Years later, a European political movement: \"URGENT: Our bank has cut us off from our own money. Our bills haven't stopped.\"",
   "who": "DiEM25, post on X",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "DiEM25, post on X",
   "source_url": "https://x.com/DiEM_25/status/2117556397575414118",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Read through scrape.js --cdp on 4 and 5 Nov 2026; wording matches the film.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-diem25-x.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v4",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 574.917,
   "film_en_end": 588.75,
   "film_zh_start": 600.71,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "It is secured by physics, by energy. And if you want to create a scarcity, if you want to create a global commodity that's a scarcity, that can be used as a capital base, you're going to want to use physics to secure it.",
   "who": "Michael Saylor",
   "role": "Executive Chairman, Strategy, BTC in DC 2025 keynote, 30 Sep 2025",
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor keynote, BTC in DC 2025",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=59vC4JxWIQU",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh09",
     1358.8,
     1372.33
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v4.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0590",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 590.15,
   "film_en_end": 592.26,
   "film_zh_start": 615.94,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "The 21 million is a rule.",
   "who": "Harry Sudock, The Peter McCormack Show (supports that nodes enforce the cap)",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Mining 101 with Harry Sudock, The Peter McCormack Show",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=452ykF03Taw&t=736s",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The research note records caption-verified words: the cap is enforced because nodes reject any rule that introduced more than 21 million. 22 Sep 2021 is the upload date.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0590.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-coinbase-2019",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 611.822,
   "film_en_end": 623.622,
   "film_zh_start": 637.61,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "Without an honest majority of miners, Coinbase wrote in 2019, a chain \"breaks several core guarantees of the Bitcoin protocol, including the irreversibility of transactions.\"",
   "who": "Coinbase blog (Mark Nesbitt)",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Ethereum Classic (ETC) is currently being 51% attacked, Coinbase blog (Wayback Machine copy)",
   "source_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20190109202614/https://blog.coinbase.com/ethereum-classic-etc-is-currently-being-51-attacked-33be13ce32de",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Read from a Wayback capture of 9 Jan 2019; the quoted sentence is word for word.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-coinbase-2019.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v9b",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 632.0,
   "film_en_end": 643.542,
   "film_zh_start": 657.79,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "During the attack, the offending miner managed to double spend $5.6 million dollars worth of ETC after spending only $200,000 to acquire the hash power. for the attack.",
   "who": "Nate Martin",
   "role": "Presenter, 99Bitcoins, This Week in Bitcoin, 99Bitcoins, 10 Aug 2020",
   "source_title": "This Week in Bitcoin, 10 Aug 2020 (99Bitcoins)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mrso-avVuFA",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvv25",
     15.62,
     26.88
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v9b.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v9a",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 645.292,
   "film_en_end": 652.0,
   "film_zh_start": 671.08,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "Kraken halted Monero deposits after this and jacked up confirmation requirements to 720 blocks.",
   "who": "Bitcoin.com host",
   "role": "Sep 2025",
   "source_title": "Blockchain Reorgs Explained (Bitcoin.com)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oO8-mOfTf14",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvv21",
     72.2,
     78.62
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v9a.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v10a",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 669.333,
   "film_en_end": 675.792,
   "film_zh_start": 695.12,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "and if the network doesn't have proof of work, then all of this blockchain stuff was just kind of a waste of time because it doesn't actually do anything.",
   "who": "Paul Sztorc",
   "role": "LayerTwo Labs · author of BIP-300 · founder of the eCash fork, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "The Post-Subsidy World, Bitcoin 2026 (Sztorc, Hansen, Casey, Harper)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5DzU1CkyAc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t4",
     155.6,
     161.8
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v10a.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v11",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 675.792,
   "film_en_end": 686.667,
   "film_zh_start": 701.58,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "And that's why many people view Bitcoin as money, but they don't view these other derivatives as money, because they have far less security, far less hash rate, far higher probability of 51% attacks occurring.",
   "who": "Lyn Alden",
   "role": "Investment strategist, The Peter McCormack Show, “Bitcoin Risk Assessment”, Sep 2021",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Risk Assessment with Lyn Alden (The Peter McCormack Show)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lyI1jTemwIQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvv06",
     2344.9,
     2355.5
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v11.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v13b",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 690.25,
   "film_en_end": 698.625,
   "film_zh_start": 716.04,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "To secure the system against a billion-dollar attack costs 1,000 times more than to secure the system against a million-dollar attack.",
   "who": "Eric Budish",
   "role": "Economist, University of Chicago, Oxford Economics Department, Apr 2022",
   "source_title": "Eric Budish, The Economics of Cryptocurrencies (Oxford Economics Department)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mYFRQGwe7rI",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvv23",
     1539.5,
     1547.58
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v13b.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v13d",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 698.625,
   "film_en_end": 717.917,
   "film_zh_start": 724.42,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "What is an appropriate level to be able to survive a state level attack? You're right, we don't know. What we do know is that in the low billions is probably too little. The US defense budget is half a trillion a year. So I think we can concretely say that like we do not have enough security spend right now to survive a state level attack.",
   "who": "Dan Held",
   "role": "Formerly Kraken · General Partner, Asymmetric, What Bitcoin Did, WBD283, recorded Nov 2020",
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMUmwBtRa1g",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "MMUmwBtRa1g",
     3777.85,
     3796.9
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v13d.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v13c",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 717.917,
   "film_en_end": 728.25,
   "film_zh_start": 743.71,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "The more expensive Bitcoin gets, the more value it has, the more attractive target it is for attack. So, it actually does not help. Number go up does not help the problem.",
   "who": "Mike Casey",
   "role": "Bitcoin security researcher · formerly MARA, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "The Post-Subsidy World, Bitcoin 2026 (Sztorc, Hansen, Casey, Harper)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5DzU1CkyAc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t4",
     810.0,
     820.05
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v13c.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v13e",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 728.25,
   "film_en_end": 744.583,
   "film_zh_start": 754.04,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "Bitcoin's security spend has historically been much lower back in time, and it wasn't 51% attacked. So technically, lower levels of security spend, in the Bitcoin network has been okay. But that doesn't necessarily mean that the same security spend number would be appropriate in the future.",
   "who": "Dan Held",
   "role": "Formerly Kraken · General Partner, Asymmetric · centre panel, Unchained podcast, 16 May 2023",
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_N8QkRLP7T0",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "_N8QkRLP7T0",
     3015.15,
     3031.2
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v13e.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-v14a",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 753.208,
   "film_en_end": 787.958,
   "film_zh_start": 779.0,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "Who should pay for the security budget? Because like if someone bought 10 years ago, self-custodied, mined their Bitcoin and haven't just hodl, don't touch it, don't use Bitcoin at all beyond that, just hodling, right? Well, they paid back then, but there's no ongoing cost to them, and yet they benefit from everyone else paying fees, because it just stacks the proof of work on top of their block, but they're not paying for it. So, it's the current transactors are paying for security for everyone.",
   "who": "PBJ",
   "role": "Presidio Bitcoin podcast, PBJ Podcast, May 2026",
   "source_title": "PBJ Podcast, Presidio Bitcoin",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDSRdGXY6cQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t37",
     593.9,
     628.4
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-v14a.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-whitepaper",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 801.748,
   "film_en_end": 809.588,
   "film_zh_start": 827.95,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "In 2008, he wrote down what would pay the machines instead: fees, the small charges people pay to send bitcoin.",
   "who": "Satoshi Nakamoto, the Bitcoin whitepaper",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, section 6, \"Incentive\"",
   "source_url": "https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-whitepaper.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-satoshi-2010",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 809.898,
   "film_en_end": 818.428,
   "film_zh_start": 836.7,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "I · The Bet",
   "said": "In 2010, he put a timeline on it: In a few decades when the reward gets too small, the transaction fee will become the main compensation.",
   "who": "Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcointalk.org",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcointalk.org forum post",
   "source_url": "https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=48.msg329#msg329",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-satoshi-2010.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0828",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 828.038,
   "film_en_end": 832.428,
   "film_zh_start": 856.19,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "II · The Champagne",
   "said": "Then, in December 2017, it looked like it was paying off.",
   "who": "The narrator, from fee data and Gregory Maxwell's email",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Fees as a share of the block reward, by UTC day (peak day 22 Dec 2017), from mempool.space block data",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/blocks/fees/all",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The fee-record data (fetched 30 Sep 2026) records 22 Dec 2017 as the peak day; Maxwell's email is dated 21 Dec 2017 22:44 UTC.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0828.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-maxwell-2017",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 838.498,
   "film_en_end": 847.308,
   "film_zh_start": 867.42,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "II · The Champagne",
   "said": "One of Bitcoin's leading engineers wrote to his colleagues to celebrate. He wrote that on the 21st of December, and said that he was pulling out the champagne.",
   "who": "Gregory Maxwell, bitcoin-dev mailing list",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Gregory Maxwell, bitcoin-dev mailing list",
   "source_url": "https://gnusha.org/pi/bitcoindev/CAAS2fgQSNdzuiPS3AZ_TjQ2OvkhYJ3ZJUBo7ovP6_O2snuwEMg@mail.gmail.com/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-maxwell-2017.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0852",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 852.178,
   "film_en_end": 854.258,
   "film_zh_start": 882.12,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "II · The Champagne",
   "said": "77 percent of the reward.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Fees as a share of the block reward, by UTC day (22 Dec 2017: 1,495.95 BTC fees / 1,937.50 BTC reward), from mempool.space block data",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/blocks/fees/all",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Computed from exact block totals for 22 Dec 2017 (blocks 500,458-500,612): 149,594,647,734 sats of fees against 193,750,000,000 sats of reward = 77.21%; the Coin Metrics cross-check gives 77.20%.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0852.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0856",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 856.608,
   "film_en_end": 862.408,
   "film_zh_start": 886.88,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "II · The Champagne",
   "said": "It happened again in 2023 and 2024, during booms in digital collectibles.",
   "who": "The narrator, from fee data",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Fees as a share of the block reward, by UTC day (peak days 8 May 2023 and 20 Apr 2024), from mempool.space block data",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/blocks/fees/all",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The fee-record data lists the two later peak days: 8 May 2023 (74.2% of the reward) and 20 Apr 2024 (halving day, 307% of the reward). The script's comment names the cause as the 2023 inscription and 2024 Runes fee spikes.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0856.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c01",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 871.818,
   "film_en_end": 884.408,
   "film_zh_start": 903.21,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "II · The Champagne",
   "said": "But the more people are seeing Bitcoin as a treasury asset, a reserve asset, something that you don't spend, it's something to save and not actually use. The fewer transaction fees are actually generated.",
   "who": "Matt Crosby",
   "role": "Research Director, LookIntoBitcoin, Milk Road Show, 18 Aug 2026",
   "source_title": "Milk Road Show",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2y1ZnkzVMFs",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "2y1ZnkzVMFs",
     1516.1,
     1528.72
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c01.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c15",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 884.678,
   "film_en_end": 896.368,
   "film_zh_start": 917.03,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "II · The Champagne",
   "said": "if you had come to me in 2017 and said, hey, guess what? You know, Bitcoin is at 84k. It's 2025. What do you think fee rates look like? I'd say, oh, yeah, they're like astronomical.",
   "who": "James O'Beirne",
   "role": "Bitcoin Core contributor, Supply Shock, Apr 2025",
   "source_title": "Supply Shock",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JITvE9BwIRQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "JITvE9BwIRQ",
     4193.44,
     4214.8
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c15.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0896",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 896.558,
   "film_en_end": 899.508,
   "film_zh_start": 929.79,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "II · The Champagne",
   "said": "It's just, you know, 300 sats per vbyte or whatever.",
   "who": "James O'Beirne, Bitcoin Core contributor",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "James O'Beirne on Supply Shock, \"What's the Problem With Bitcoin?\"",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JITvE9BwIRQ&t=4193s",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The spec records clip C15 from the t10 tape, ear-verified; the machine captions spell the unit 'V bite' and the subtitle spells it 'vbyte' by owner ruling (30 Sep 2026).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0896.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-0906",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 906.738,
   "film_en_end": 910.768,
   "film_zh_start": 940.72,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "II · The Champagne",
   "said": "Today, fees are less than one percent of what the machines earn.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "mempool.space reward stats: fees as a share of miner revenue, one-month average to 30 Sep 2026",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/reward-stats/4320",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The fee-share data records 0.6192% of what the machines earn (blocks 964,703-969,274, one-month average to 30 Sep 2026); the security-line data gives 0.6226% over 4,320 blocks.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-0906.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-jon",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 942.375,
   "film_en_end": 954.208,
   "film_zh_start": 979.0,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "And this has been the biggest question mark, what happens when the block rewards go away? And we've always pointed to the fees, but then everybody looks at fees and goes, well, they're negligible.",
   "who": "Daniel Jonsson",
   "role": "CEO, MGMT Digital Infrastructure, Xapo Bank Summit, 2026",
   "source_title": "Xapo Bank Summit (Daniel Jonsson)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yTlK4F_yJBs",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvv30",
     1129.1,
     1140.93
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-jon.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c34",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 963.352,
   "film_en_end": 970.062,
   "film_zh_start": 1000.33,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "Things seem to be working okay now. You don't hear about double spend attacks. But how do we know that they will continue to work in the future?",
   "who": "Neha Narula",
   "role": "Director, MIT Digital Currency Initiative (in 2024), MIT Bitcoin Expo, Apr 2024",
   "source_title": "MIT Bitcoin Expo",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y7YVw_1fEdQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "Y7YVw_1fEdQ",
     209.65,
     216.97
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against two independent machine transcripts",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c34.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c16",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 972.882,
   "film_en_end": 975.872,
   "film_zh_start": 1010.23,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "discussion about this, you know, in Bitcoin land.",
   "who": "Nic Carter",
   "role": "Partner, Castle Island Ventures, MIT Bitcoin Expo, Mar 2019",
   "source_title": "MIT Bitcoin Expo",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AyOyNF-bCkA",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "AyOyNF-bCkA",
     230.55,
     235.7
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c16.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c02",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 976.402,
   "film_en_end": 982.792,
   "film_zh_start": 1013.89,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "Bitcoin's game theoretic stability could break down as this block reward dwindles and goes towards zero.",
   "who": "Arvind Narayanan",
   "role": "Computer scientist, Princeton, UW Allen School Colloquium, 2018",
   "source_title": "UW Allen School Colloquium",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WY7bBWD6-Zs",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "WY7bBWD6-Zs",
     1985.23,
     1991.9
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c02.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c03",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 983.142,
   "film_en_end": 999.692,
   "film_zh_start": 1020.89,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "There's dwindling subsidy, I think, is a big one in like medium, long term. I think very few... I don't think we know what the game theory will say there.",
   "who": "Pieter Wuille",
   "role": "Bitcoin Core developer, Bitcoin Rails, 11 Feb 2026",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Rails",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QNrW4dUc_U4",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "QNrW4dUc_U4",
     5062.75,
     5079.19
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c03.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c05",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 999.942,
   "film_en_end": 1008.992,
   "film_zh_start": 1038.34,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "the assumption is, well, we'll just go to the extreme opposite, and we'll just hope it works. And no other cryptocurrency has ever actually survived this transition",
   "who": "Peter Todd",
   "role": "Former Bitcoin Core developer, Bitcoin Takeover S15 E46, 2024",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Takeover S15 E46",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kb2fK4Y2ZkA",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "Kb2fK4Y2ZkA",
     475.17,
     484.3
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "He describes the problem only. He favours a different fix (tail emission), not the one in this film.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c05.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-mck",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1009.0,
   "film_en_end": 1025.542,
   "film_zh_start": 1047.75,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "The predominant solution I heard was to just let the fees take care of it. And this is just, seems like it's possible that that could work, but it just seems like bad design, right? Because you just don't know what the fees are gonna be.",
   "who": "The “Jordan McKinney” channel",
   "role": "“Bitcoin's Declining Security: The Security Budget Problem”, YouTube, 12 Jul 2021",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin's Declining Security: The Security Budget Problem (the Jordan McKinney channel)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ARTUfzKU8_s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t53",
     2570.65,
     2587.19
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-mck.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1030",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "count",
   "label_name": "A count we made",
   "film_en_start": 1030.553,
   "film_en_end": 1033.153,
   "film_zh_start": 1070.06,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "Eleven bitcoin funds file these reports.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "What the Bitcoin ETF filings say about the halving (Part 1 of the disclosure series, latest Form 10-K Item 1A of each fund)",
   "source_url": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The count of eleven comes from the filings-series registry, and the film spec records that every number in this beat is gated against that registry.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1030.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1033",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "count",
   "label_name": "A count we made",
   "film_en_start": 1033.683,
   "film_en_end": 1034.683,
   "film_zh_start": 1073.66,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "All eleven.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "What the Bitcoin ETF filings say about the halving (Part 1 of the disclosure series, latest Form 10-K Item 1A of each fund)",
   "source_url": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry states that all eleven of the funds that have filed an annual report name the risk; the film spec gates the count against it.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1033.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1038",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "count",
   "label_name": "A count we made",
   "film_en_start": 1038.503,
   "film_en_end": 1041.293,
   "film_zh_start": 1079.2,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "Ten companies with a bitcoin reserve strategy.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "What the Bitcoin treasury companies' filings say about the halving (Part 4 of the disclosure series, latest Form 10-K risk factors)",
   "source_url": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The ten entities are the treasury lane's roster in the filings-series registry; the lane's scan notes record the ten and the universe wording.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1038.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1041",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1041.523,
   "film_en_end": 1043.613,
   "film_zh_start": 1082.68,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "One sentence, in all ten.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "What the Bitcoin treasury companies' filings say about the halving (Part 4 of the disclosure series, latest Form 10-K risk factors)",
   "source_url": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The lane's caveats file counts the shared risk-factor bullet in all ten filings (10 of 10), recounted by script over filings.json on 2026-09-25.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1041.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-cambridge",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1104.5,
   "film_en_end": 1116.85,
   "film_zh_start": 1155.12,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "At the University of Cambridge this autumn, a new report put fees at 0.67% of miner revenue. Fees replacing the subsidy, it said, has not been tested at scale.",
   "who": "The narrator, summarising a Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance report",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance: Funding Bitcoin's future, paying for security as the block subsidy fades",
   "source_url": "https://www.jbs.cam.ac.uk/faculty-research/centres/alternative-finance/publications/funding-bitcoins-future-paying-for-security-as-the-block-subsidy-fades/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-cambridge.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c06",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 1124.623,
   "film_en_end": 1140.243,
   "film_zh_start": 1177.01,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "look at the whole security budget of Bitcoin, which is, I think, the bigger question people should be talking about with all of these miners pivoting is that, you know, transaction fees were meant to compensate miners for the halving. –Right. –Well, that isn't happening.",
   "who": "Fred Thiel",
   "role": "CEO, MARA, Coin Stories, Jul 2026",
   "source_title": "Coin Stories",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FrDJ2bwvQdc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "FrDJ2bwvQdc",
     2356.45,
     2372.07
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "\"Right.\" in the middle is the host's word, not his.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c06.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c07",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1146.443,
   "film_en_end": 1158.413,
   "film_zh_start": 1199.89,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "today, power is the thing, obviously, which is why ourselves and many of our peers have pivoted because you get a lot more money per electron if you're doing it for AI than for Bitcoin mining.",
   "who": "Fred Thiel",
   "role": "CEO, MARA, Coin Stories, Jul 2026",
   "source_title": "Coin Stories",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FrDJ2bwvQdc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "FrDJ2bwvQdc",
     507.51,
     519.95
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c07.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c33",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1159.243,
   "film_en_end": 1185.623,
   "film_zh_start": 1213.32,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "They're leaving in droves. Why are they leaving? Well, on the surface, they're leaving because they have an asset, which is power. They have contracts for power and they have, they have land and they have some of the electrical infrastructure that AI wants. And AI is willing to throw a bunch of money at them, more money than they can make mining. So, they're taking it.",
   "who": "Bob Burnett",
   "role": "Founder and CEO, Barefoot Mining · OCEAN board, Bitcoin Well, 20 Aug 2026",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Well",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e2de9-7Kxho",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "e2de9-7Kxho",
     3461.38,
     3488.27
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against two independent machine transcripts",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c33.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1193",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1193.44,
   "film_en_end": 1197.28,
   "film_zh_start": 1249.18,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "Poolin, once the largest pool in the world, filed for bankruptcy.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The Block: former bitcoin miner Poolin files Chapter 11, sets $52 million floor bid for Texas operations",
   "source_url": "https://www.theblock.co/post/409587/former-bitcoin-miner-poolin-files-chapter-11-sets-52-million-floor-bid-for-texas-operations",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The overnight research pass (9 Nov 2026) rates it STRONG with three outlets (The Block, Decrypt, Cointelegraph) and gives the filing date and the Chapter 11 form; the pools_exit script records the on-screen label 'Chapter 11 - Jul 2026'.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1193.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1206",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1206.804,
   "film_en_end": 1220.144,
   "film_zh_start": 1263.25,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "And Core Scientific, IREN, Cipher, Bitfarms, TeraWulf, Hut 8, Galaxy, CleanSpark, Riot, Hive, Bitdeer and MARA are moving their power into AI.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin miners and pools that moved into AI/HPC or left mining (overnight research pass, with SEC filings and press releases per company)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The research pass rates each of the twelve names STRONG (company release or filing, or two outlets) and recommends exactly this list for the narration; the v88 build spec carries the line as spoken.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1206.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-f6-chart",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 1226.867,
   "film_en_end": 1229.097,
   "film_zh_start": 1286.68,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "The machines go where the pay is.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "mempool.space: hash rate (7-day average) and miners' pay (block reward and fees, 30-day average, in US dollars), from the hash-rate peak of 19 Oct 2025 to 15 Nov 2026",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/graphs/mining/hashrate-difficulty",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The chart rounds them to -22% and -33%. Both fell; pay fell further, so the machines followed the pay down.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-f6-chart.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-wu",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1231.292,
   "film_en_end": 1248.167,
   "film_zh_start": 1291.21,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "The competition among the Bitcoin miners has been very strong than before, much, much stronger than before, and the hash price also go to the lowest point right now in history.",
   "who": "Jihan Wu",
   "role": "Founder & CEO, Bitdeer, Bloomberg New Economy Forum, Nov 2025",
   "source_title": "Jihan Wu, Bloomberg New Economy Forum",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYVS5vMDyak",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "t36",
     508.23,
     525.1
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-wu.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1248",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1248.402,
   "film_en_end": 1252.432,
   "film_zh_start": 1308.32,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "Nick Hansen runs Luxor, one of the ten largest mining groups.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "mempool.space pools, 1-week window (Luxor 9th by blocks found), with Hansen's role as CEO of Luxor Technology from the clip credit",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/pools/1w",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Script notes record Luxor ninth by blocks over the trailing week (31 blocks, mempool.space, 2 Aug 2026) and why the rank is banded as 'one of the ten largest'; the clip credit in the film spec gives Hansen's title.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1248.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c08",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1257.532,
   "film_en_end": 1267.25,
   "film_zh_start": 1317.67,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "we need users, we need customers, people to use this thing. At the end of the day it's a service to move money around. People need to be paying to use that, and right now nobody's really doing that",
   "who": "Nick Hansen",
   "role": "CEO, Luxor Technology, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5DzU1CkyAc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "B5DzU1CkyAc",
     268.44,
     278.49
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "His 8-out-of-10 rating of the worry is not used: on the tape it was about the 2032 halving, and he ranks quantum computing first.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c08.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1267",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1267.64,
   "film_en_end": 1274.4,
   "film_zh_start": 1328.02,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "III · The Witnesses",
   "said": "Six months later, raising money for his company, he put it this way: compute markets are converging.",
   "who": "Nick Hansen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Decrypt: bitcoin mining firm Luxor raises $16 million for AI compute",
   "source_url": "https://decrypt.co/381847/bitcoin-mining-firm-luxor-raises-16-million-ai-compute",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The research pass dates Luxor's $16M preferred-equity raise to 27 Oct 2026 (Decrypt) and the clip card to April 2026, which is six months. The words 'compute markets are converging' are NOT recorded in any file I found; only the film's own ASR transcript has them.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1267.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c09",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1301.827,
   "film_en_end": 1306.627,
   "film_zh_start": 1365.0,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "we don't know how to model it. And we don't know what the security budget needs to be.",
   "who": "PBJ",
   "role": "Presidio Bitcoin podcast, PBJ Podcast, May 2026",
   "source_title": "PBJ Podcast",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDSRdGXY6cQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "YDSRdGXY6cQ",
     983.7,
     989.08
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "They say nobody knows how big the security budget needs to be. They do not say fees can't pay for it.",
    "No timetable is theirs: the 2028 date that follows in the film is the narrator's.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c09.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-alden",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1307.147,
   "film_en_end": 1315.837,
   "film_zh_start": 1371.02,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "The investment strategist Lyn Alden put an appropriate level at fifty cents to a dollar fifty a year, for every hundred dollars of bitcoin.",
   "who": "The narrator, summarising Lyn Alden",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Lyn Alden, \"Bitcoin: Fee-Based Security Modeling\"",
   "source_url": "https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-security-modeling/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-alden.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-spend-80c",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 1316.437,
   "film_en_end": 1319.307,
   "film_zh_start": 1381.53,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Today, it stands at about 80 cents.",
   "who": "The narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Recomputed from the data file at every film render by the figures gate (dv_figures_gate.py).",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-spend-80c.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1319",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 1319.807,
   "film_en_end": 1321.997,
   "film_zh_start": 1385.34,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "After 2028, about forty.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Security line card data: reward-only share after the 2028 halving (40.4 cents per $100), 40.9 cents with fees held at the 4,320-block window level",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/reward-stats/4320",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Worked out from the protocol schedule (subsidy 1.5625 BTC after the 2028 halving, 82,125 BTC a year over 20.34M coins) and, with fees held flat, from mempool.space reward stats; the film's gate accepts 35 to 45.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1319.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1326",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1326.627,
   "film_en_end": 1330.497,
   "film_zh_start": 1393.05,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "In 2023 he called about one and a half percent healthy:",
   "who": "James McAvity",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "James McAvity on The Mining Pod (t38 clip)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s5UX1HMgn9M&t=504s",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The citations file records his ear-verified words (right now around one and a half percent; stay in a healthy range there) and the spec records that the narration was cut to one reading, not a range.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1326.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c24",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1331.087,
   "film_en_end": 1350.917,
   "film_zh_start": 1398.1,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "You know, the metric that I like to look at is what is mining revenue versus the total market cap of Bitcoin. And right now it's around one and a half percent. You wanted to stay in a healthy range there. If that drops down to say 20 basis points, 10 basis points, maybe even lower, It's just a different system. It's a different protocol.",
   "who": "James McAvity",
   "role": "Chief executive, Cormint Data Systems · at the time of recording, The Mining Pod (Blockspace), 18 Oct 2023",
   "source_title": "The Mining Pod (Blockspace)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s5UX1HMgn9M",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "s5UX1HMgn9M",
     490.56,
     507.99
    ],
    [
     "s5UX1HMgn9M",
     518.65,
     520.95
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c24.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1351",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1351.517,
   "film_en_end": 1355.847,
   "film_zh_start": 1421.21,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "The Bitcoin Security Budget site calls anything above a dollar healthy.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "btcsecuritybudget.com, Explanation panel: 'a good state if ... the relative miner revenue is greater than 1%'",
   "source_url": "https://www.btcsecuritybudget.com/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The citations file quotes the site's own explanation text verbatim and states it defines its good state as relative miner revenue above 1% of market cap (verified 2026-09-12).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1351.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-hasu",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1356.257,
   "film_en_end": 1361.457,
   "film_zh_start": 1426.57,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "And in a 2020 talk, the researcher Hasu measured Bitcoin paying two dollars.",
   "who": "The narrator, summarising a talk by Hasu",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Hasu, Is Bitcoin secure after the block subsidy ends? (Value of Bitcoin Digital, Halving Edition)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zPYkL6L3VGw",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-hasu.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1364",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 1364.817,
   "film_en_end": 1370.587,
   "film_zh_start": 1436.25,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "That's a share, not a price: a dollar of every hundred, whatever one bitcoin costs.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Security spend as a share of bitcoin's value (annual miner pay / market cap; the price cancels)",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/reward-stats/4320",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The figures registry defines the measure as annual pay over market value, 165,279 / 20,090,909, in which the price cancels; the citations file gives the same definition.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1364.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1375",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 1375.337,
   "film_en_end": 1382.287,
   "film_zh_start": 1448.15,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "In 2028 the reward is cut in half again, and that drops to about forty, if fees stay where they are.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Security line card data: share after the 2028 halving (40.4 cents per $100 reward-only; 40.9 with fees held)",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/reward-stats/4320",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The halving is on the protocol schedule (est. 12 Apr 2028, block 1,050,000, subsidy 3.125 to 1.5625 BTC); the share is worked out with fees held at the window level, which is what 'if fees stay where they are' says.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1375.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1382",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 1382.377,
   "film_en_end": 1385.027,
   "film_zh_start": 1456.11,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "And after 2032, about twenty.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The Floor (sz09): share after the second halving with fee dollars held flat (0.21%, about 21 cents per $100)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The spec ties the line to the sz09 table's 2032 row (0.2095% at the 27 Sep 2026 read; 0.2089% in the current file, as of 2026-10-28), both about twenty cents per $100.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1382.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-whatif-2064",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 1402.137,
   "film_en_end": 1419.647,
   "film_zh_start": 1478.47,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Picture one bitcoin at $10 million, with the reward all but gone and fees where they are now. Miners would still earn about $12 billion a year. But it would be guarding more than $200 trillion: about half a cent in every hundred dollars.",
   "who": "The narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Figures registry entries whatif_price_2064, whatif_pay_2064, whatif_value_2064 and whatif_bsi_2064.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-whatif-2064.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-wouters",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1420.837,
   "film_en_end": 1431.767,
   "film_zh_start": 1499.62,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Gold, by one rough estimate, spends about 70 cents in every hundred a year keeping itself safe. Sam Wouters, who made that estimate, wasn't sure the comparison holds.",
   "who": "The narrator, summarising Sam Wouters",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Sam Wouters on gold's security spend, What Bitcoin Did",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N_LkZlm9X1k",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-wouters.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1442",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 1442.387,
   "film_en_end": 1446.997,
   "film_zh_start": 1523.99,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "People who wave this away point to 2140, when the reward runs out.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin's issuance schedule: last block reward 6,929,999, around 30 Jan 2140 (security timeline card data)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The security-timeline data computes the final reward block and date from the halving schedule (zero subsidy from height 6,930,000, 30 Jan 2140).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1442.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-den-intro",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1458.375,
   "film_en_end": 1467.0,
   "film_zh_start": 1541.96,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "With the guards’ pay shrinking like that, you’d expect alarm. Instead, some of Bitcoin’s best-known voices say there’s no problem at all.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The 25 voices in this section, each linked on its own page",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Each voice's words, speaker and original are listed in the section's sources file; four speakers there are still to be confirmed.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-den-intro.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-t1-mallers",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1468.958,
   "film_en_end": 1472.058,
   "film_zh_start": 1552.54,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "this is also a problem that is way out in the future.",
   "who": "Jack Mallers",
   "role": "Strike CEO · Bloomberg Technology, 2024",
   "source_title": "Bloomberg Technology, live, 2024",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=obVeKUSYgvI&t=428s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "obVeKUSYgvI",
     467.3,
     470.4
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-t1-mallers.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-09-walker",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1472.058,
   "film_en_end": 1474.558,
   "film_zh_start": 1555.64,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Bitcoin does not have a security budget problem.",
   "who": "Walker",
   "role": "THE Bitcoin Podcast · 2023",
   "source_title": "6 Sep 2023",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=owOLx0G7YzY&t=484s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "owOLx0G7YzY",
     488.0,
     490.5
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-09-walker.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-11-warren",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1474.558,
   "film_en_end": 1478.558,
   "film_zh_start": 1558.14,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "It's a made up statistic, fake news, not real,",
   "who": "Rob Warren",
   "role": "author, The Bitcoin Miners Almanac · 2024",
   "source_title": "10 Dec 2024",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9S6WAzM7Njc&t=23s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "9S6WAzM7Njc",
     39.3,
     43.3
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-11-warren.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-14-klippsten",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1478.558,
   "film_en_end": 1487.558,
   "film_zh_start": 1562.14,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "So did you share that concern at that time, and then - Not at all. That's basically altcoin miners pumping that narrative trying to do altcoin things on Bitcoin.",
   "who": "Cory Klippsten",
   "role": "Swan CEO · Unchained",
   "source_title": "Unchained (Swan clip)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvwdSVnARuk&t=370s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "xvwdSVnARuk",
     400.0,
     404.0
    ],
    [
     "xvwdSVnARuk",
     404.0,
     409.0
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-14-klippsten.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-alt-kratter2022-a",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1487.558,
   "film_en_end": 1500.158,
   "film_zh_start": 1571.14,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "In my opinion, people who say that transaction fees will not sufficiently compensate Bitcoin miners, this kind of FUD is no different from the halving FUD, and these people have been proven wrong again and again.",
   "who": "Matthew Kratter",
   "role": "Bitcoin University · 2022",
   "source_title": "same video",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_0NOJhTy4MQ&t=1665s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "_0NOJhTy4MQ",
     1666.8,
     1679.4
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-alt-kratter2022-a.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-01-rochard",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 1500.158,
   "film_en_end": 1512.558,
   "film_zh_start": 1583.74,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "I think my most controversial Bitcoin opinion is on this topic called the security budget. there's this perception that that makes Bitcoin less and less secure and that it undermines transaction finality. I don't think that's true.",
   "who": "Pierre Rochard",
   "role": "ex-Riot Platforms · Presidio Bitcoin, 2025",
   "source_title": "Presidio Bitcoin, 9 Oct 2025",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uamqkaYBWuI&t=113s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "uamqkaYBWuI",
     117.4,
     122.1
    ],
    [
     "uamqkaYBWuI",
     131.6,
     139.2
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-01-rochard.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-02-zucco",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1512.558,
   "film_en_end": 1523.158,
   "film_zh_start": 1596.14,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "there is no security budget issue That's a circular argument because if people need on-chain finality They will spend fees in order to ensure on-chain finality",
   "who": "Giacomo Zucco",
   "role": "Plan B Network · Plan B Lugano, 2026",
   "source_title": "Plan B Lugano debate, 12 Mar 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyGaOkiRxoo&t=139s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "SyGaOkiRxoo",
     142.8,
     153.3
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-02-zucco.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-07-antonopoulos",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 1523.158,
   "film_en_end": 1529.258,
   "film_zh_start": 1606.74,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Fees go up, reward goes down. I'm not worried, because it won't be a surprise.",
   "who": "Andreas Antonopoulos",
   "role": "author, Mastering Bitcoin · 2016",
   "source_title": "aantonop Q&A, 13 Oct 2016",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FffX32ENGKc&t=155s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "FffX32ENGKc",
     92.3,
     95.6
    ],
    [
     "FffX32ENGKc",
     176.7,
     179.5
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-07-antonopoulos.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-06-genoot",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1529.258,
   "film_en_end": 1536.758,
   "film_zh_start": 1612.84,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "How do you see that evolving over the next 10 to 20 years? …really hope ordinals pick up and transaction fees really go up.",
   "who": "Asher Genoot",
   "role": "Hut 8 CEO · Unchained, 2024",
   "source_title": "Unchained, 20 Feb 2024",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HChYRbpZp3E&t=2371s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "HChYRbpZp3E",
     2395.3,
     2399.2
    ],
    [
     "HChYRbpZp3E",
     2400.7,
     2404.4
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-06-genoot.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-t2-armstrong",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1536.758,
   "film_en_end": 1539.358,
   "film_zh_start": 1620.34,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "but they'll still make money from transaction fees.",
   "who": "Brian Armstrong",
   "role": "Coinbase CEO · Shawn Ryan Show, 2025",
   "source_title": "Shawn Ryan Show #222, 2025",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o5Tuj148mk4&t=5534s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "o5Tuj148mk4",
     5624.4,
     5627.0
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-t2-armstrong.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-10-svanholm",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1539.358,
   "film_en_end": 1553.758,
   "film_zh_start": 1622.94,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "the biggest flaw in the argument about security budget is thinking that Bitcoin will not double in value every four years. If it does, then the problem goes away, because the miners get paid exactly the same, like in fiat terms at least.",
   "who": "Knut Svanholm",
   "role": "author · Bitcoin Infinity Show, 2026",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Infinity Show #194, Mar 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hBvlmFgQENw&t=846s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "hBvlmFgQENw",
     861.0,
     868.4
    ],
    [
     "hBvlmFgQENw",
     868.4,
     875.4
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-10-svanholm.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-03-booth",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1553.758,
   "film_en_end": 1559.658,
   "film_zh_start": 1637.34,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "and so the problem doesn't exist. The block reward is enough all the way to 2140",
   "who": "Jeff Booth",
   "role": "Core Scientific board · Bitcoin Infinity Show, 2026",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Infinity Show #213, 27 Jul 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=alophSgvz-w&t=2048s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "alophSgvz-w",
     2049.1,
     2051.8
    ],
    [
     "alophSgvz-w",
     2052.5,
     2055.8
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-03-booth.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-05-colyer",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1559.658,
   "film_en_end": 1567.658,
   "film_zh_start": 1643.24,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "fees haven't gone up like everyone predicted we're just continuing to add more hash rate which is security for the network",
   "who": "Mike Colyer",
   "role": "Foundry CEO, largest mining pool · ARK Invest, 2024",
   "source_title": "ARK Invest “The Bitcoin Halving”, 9 May 2024",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bMomAAtSVAg&t=1192s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "bMomAAtSVAg",
     1215.7,
     1218.7
    ],
    [
     "bMomAAtSVAg",
     1253.2,
     1258.2
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-05-colyer.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-12-pompliano",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1567.658,
   "film_en_end": 1574.358,
   "film_zh_start": 1651.24,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "regardless of price being up or down hashrate continues to increase and the network continues to get more secure.",
   "who": "Anthony Pompliano",
   "role": "investor, media · 2023",
   "source_title": "his own channel, 6 May 2023",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jk05NPgYor0&t=38s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "jk05NPgYor0",
     47.9,
     54.5
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-12-pompliano.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-d1-leclair-b",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1574.358,
   "film_en_end": 1579.058,
   "film_zh_start": 1657.94,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "it's a self-correcting mechanism and yeah, I'm not too worried. / So maybe that's naive.",
   "who": "Dylan LeClair",
   "role": "analyst · Blockspace, 2023",
   "source_title": "same episode",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qFibmlk3uuc&t=860s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "qFibmlk3uuc",
     859.9,
     864.6
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-d1-leclair-b.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-den-more",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1579.167,
   "film_en_end": 1580.458,
   "film_zh_start": 1662.75,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "And there are many more.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The eight quote cards on screen during this line",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The cards' words come from each video's caption track and were not checked by ear (Batten's were, on our own download).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-den-more.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-den-saylor",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1584.875,
   "film_en_end": 1590.583,
   "film_zh_start": 1668.46,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Michael Saylor: a trillion dollars a year in transaction fees. Nothing wrong with that.",
   "who": "Michael Saylor",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor on What is Money? with Robert Breedlove, The Saylor Series, episode 4 (WiM004), WiM Media",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Ms7ql_S63A&t=3881s",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The words match the caption tracks of both the original and the re-upload; not checked by ear.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-den-saylor.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-den-batten",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1591.458,
   "film_en_end": 1594.5,
   "film_zh_start": 1675.04,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Daniel Batten: you don’t need a security budget.",
   "who": "Daniel Batten",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Daniel Batten, interview with CriptoNoticias",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TM37SrhLjRY&t=818s",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Checked by ear on our own download of the interview.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-den-batten.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-n2-burnett",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1595.458,
   "film_en_end": 1604.058,
   "film_zh_start": 1679.04,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "it's not that miners provide security for Bitcoin, it's that miners introduce, you know, a level of transaction finality.",
   "who": "Joe Burnett",
   "role": "then Blockware · Stephan Livera Podcast, 2022",
   "source_title": "Stephan Livera Podcast SLP442, Dec 2022",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EcFbDC9Jzuo&t=303s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "EcFbDC9Jzuo",
     303.2,
     311.8
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-n2-burnett.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-n1-svanholm-prague",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1604.058,
   "film_en_end": 1611.958,
   "film_zh_start": 1687.64,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "The core mistake lies here. Bitcoin is for the users, not for the miners. It's the users who set the rules.",
   "who": "Knut Svanholm",
   "role": "author · BTC Prague, 2025",
   "source_title": "BTC Prague 2025, the security-budget debate (opening statement)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HNz_Brpscs&t=935s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "4HNz_Brpscs",
     934.9,
     942.9
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-n1-svanholm-prague.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-h1-saifedean-vays",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1611.958,
   "film_en_end": 1617.658,
   "film_zh_start": 1695.54,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "there's no supermarket where you just walk in, give them money and walk out with 51% of the hash power.",
   "who": "Saifedean Ammous",
   "role": "author, The Bitcoin Standard · 2019",
   "source_title": "Tone Vays show, 8 Jan 2019",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8_JO6j9s24&t=2232s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "m8_JO6j9s24",
     2240.1,
     2244.7
    ],
    [
     "m8_JO6j9s24",
     2245.7,
     2246.8
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-h1-saifedean-vays.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-g1-roberts-wim",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1617.658,
   "film_en_end": 1625.158,
   "film_zh_start": 1701.24,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "51 percent attacks, they don't work like it's never going to happen, what are you actually achieving by attacking the network? Nothing.",
   "who": "Dan Roberts",
   "role": "co-CEO, IREN (listed miner) · What is Money?, 2022",
   "source_title": "What is Money? Show #194 with Robert Breedlove, 27 Jul 2022",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-pighSOJ6y4&t=1586s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "-pighSOJ6y4",
     1589.5,
     1592.0
    ],
    [
     "-pighSOJ6y4",
     1598.2,
     1598.9
    ],
    [
     "-pighSOJ6y4",
     1651.3,
     1655.5
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-g1-roberts-wim.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-g5-gagnon",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1625.158,
   "film_en_end": 1631.958,
   "film_zh_start": 1708.74,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Let's say I want to do a 51% attack. It's a very short-sighted economic incentive because I can pull this off once",
   "who": "Ben Gagnon",
   "role": "Bitfarms · Bitcoin Asia panel, 2024",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Asia 2024 panel (Paul Sztorc also on the panel)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACWXDvJuAis&t=1288s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "ACWXDvJuAis",
     1287.6,
     1294.4
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-g5-gagnon.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-g6-breedlove-chichi",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1631.958,
   "film_en_end": 1634.058,
   "film_zh_start": 1715.54,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "you're still incentivized to basically be honest",
   "who": "Robert Breedlove or Radu Chichi",
   "role": "What is Money? · 2026",
   "source_title": "What is Money? clip, 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhQpps1fvdY&t=160s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "lhQpps1fvdY",
     175.6,
     177.7
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-g6-breedlove-chichi.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-g7-lindner",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1634.058,
   "film_en_end": 1638.758,
   "film_zh_start": 1717.64,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "A nation state attack or a short seller attack. Those aren't real.",
   "who": "Ansel Lindner",
   "role": "Bitcoin & Markets · 2023",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin & Markets E371, 6 Sep 2023",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PAQtN15JN30&t=796s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "PAQtN15JN30",
     804.1,
     808.8
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-g7-lindner.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-f3-ianmajor",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1638.758,
   "film_en_end": 1646.758,
   "film_zh_start": 1722.34,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Do you really think that all the hardcore Bitcoiners that are out there that have stored their life force in Bitcoin are just going to go down without a fight?",
   "who": "Ian Major",
   "role": "All Things Bitcoin · 2023",
   "source_title": "All Things Bitcoin, 2023",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GihUmRiQB70&t=1071s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "GihUmRiQB70",
     1094.5,
     1102.5
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-f3-ianmajor.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-g3-heart",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1646.758,
   "film_en_end": 1652.558,
   "film_zh_start": 1730.34,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "No one does 51% attacks because they're not profitable It's never gonna happen because it doesn't make financial f***ing sense",
   "who": "Richard Heart",
   "role": "HEX / PulseChain founder · 2018",
   "source_title": "his own stream, 2018",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=roEtgsJn-_c",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "roEtgsJn-_c",
     0.0,
     2.9
    ],
    [
     "roEtgsJn-_c",
     159.8,
     162.8
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-g3-heart.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "d-n3-mechanic",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1652.558,
   "film_en_end": 1655.358,
   "film_zh_start": 1736.14,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "the security budget is not a real problem, guys.",
   "who": "Bitcoin Mechanic",
   "role": "OCEAN mining pool · Bitcoin Infinity Show, 2026",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Infinity Show #206, 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GtuLmqa9Ai8&t=2477s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "GtuLmqa9Ai8",
     2477.6,
     2480.3
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against the original, in the section's clip review (clip-review.html)",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/d-n3-mechanic.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-den-held",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1655.708,
   "film_en_end": 1662.083,
   "film_zh_start": 1739.29,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Dan Held: hash rate hasn’t materially dropped, and sounds like you don’t understand basic game theory.",
   "who": "Dan Held",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Dan Held (@danheld) on X, a reply to @natssats, @grok and @choirzooh",
   "source_url": "https://x.com/danheld/status/2119789817252942266",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The card shows the post word for word (the @-mentions cropped); the narrator reads it without the insult.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-den-held.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-den-machines",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1662.708,
   "film_en_end": 1677.792,
   "film_zh_start": 1746.29,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "But hash rate counts machines, not money. Machines get better every year, so hash rate can keep climbing while miners are paid less. An attacker buys the same better machines. What he has to outspend is what miners are paid.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The film's own reasoning; a clip a few seconds later (Jordan McKinney, 28:28) makes the same point: “It’s all about the amount the miners are spending”",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "This is the film's argument, not a quoted source: an attack must outspend what miners are paid, and hash rate also rises as machines improve.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-den-machines.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-den-pay",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 1678.917,
   "film_en_end": 1691.092,
   "film_zh_start": 1762.5,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "As of 14 November, miners’ pay is 70% of what it was at the record. The same machines, paid nearly a third less. And every four years, the halving cuts it again.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "blockchain.com, Miners Revenue (block reward plus fees, US dollars a day): the 30-day average to 13 Nov 2026 against the 30-day average to 29 Oct 2025, the day of the difficulty record",
   "source_url": "https://www.blockchain.com/explorer/charts/miners-revenue",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "69.5% rounds to 70%, so the pay is 30.5% lower: nearly a third. Through 14 Nov the same sum gives 68.8%. To be re-checked before the film locks.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-den-pay.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-den-label",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1692.708,
   "film_en_end": 1696.175,
   "film_zh_start": 1776.29,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Question the narrative and you might be labelled retarded.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Dan Held's post, quoted above in the film",
   "source_url": "https://x.com/danheld/status/2119789817252942266",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The word is the post's own.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-den-label.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-hansen",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1699.208,
   "film_en_end": 1708.083,
   "film_zh_start": 1782.79,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "My concern level was like an eight or ten back in 2024, mostly because I'm kind of thinking about the halving of probably 2032.",
   "who": "Nick Hansen",
   "role": "CEO, Luxor Technology, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5DzU1CkyAc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "B5DzU1CkyAc",
     253.05,
     261.93
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-hansen.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c29",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1708.172,
   "film_en_end": 1726.862,
   "film_zh_start": 1791.76,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "And some people will say like, Oh, if hash power keeps going up, the system is more secure. And that's not strictly true. So, you shouldn't, it's not strictly about like the hash power itself. It's all about the amount the miners are spending, right?",
   "who": "The \"Jordan McKinney\" channel",
   "role": "\"Bitcoin's Declining Security: The Security Budget Problem\", YouTube, 12 Jul 2021",
   "source_title": "YouTube",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ARTUfzKU8_s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "ARTUfzKU8_s",
     2238.62,
     2248.35
    ],
    [
     "ARTUfzKU8_s",
     2271.7,
     2280.14
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c29.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c37",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1727.489,
   "film_en_end": 1735.389,
   "film_zh_start": 1811.07,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "It goes down very, very rapidly, and it just kind of barely survives until the end. So it's going to be a concern long before the year 2140.",
   "who": "Paul Sztorc",
   "role": "LayerTwo Labs, author of BIP-300, founder of the eCash fork, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5DzU1CkyAc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "B5DzU1CkyAc",
     129.28,
     137.64
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against two independent machine transcripts",
   "does_not_say": [
    "He describes the problem only. He has his own proposed fix, not the one in this film.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c37.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c31",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1735.832,
   "film_en_end": 1761.212,
   "film_zh_start": 1819.42,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "If the block reward falls by a lot, some computers are gonna turn off. If it falls by enough that you wouldn't wanna pay even if the computer were free, you wouldn't wanna pay the electricity cost, some computers are gonna get shut off. So if enough capital is mothballed for a long enough period of time, this would seem like it could raise vectors for attack where an attacker could get their hands on a lot of cheap chips.",
   "who": "Eric Budish",
   "role": "Economist, University of Chicago, Columbia Digital Finance Seminar, 17 Oct 2022",
   "source_title": "Columbia Digital Finance Seminar",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=70WsnIqsn5s",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "70WsnIqsn5s",
     3583.07,
     3588.3
    ],
    [
     "70WsnIqsn5s",
     3591.43,
     3611.3
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against two independent machine transcripts",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c31.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1513",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1764.032,
   "film_en_end": 1768.262,
   "film_zh_start": 1848.99,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "Its vice president, Liang Wang, on mining after 2028:",
   "who": "Liang Wang",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The Blockspace Podcast, Liang Wang, vice-president of Canaan (t51 tape)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7rTCMXgmtQ&t=3079s",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The clip card gives his title, venue and date, ear-verified against the tape (2026-09-07 for the wall card); the quote he speaks concerns the economics of mining after 2028.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1513.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c39",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1768.762,
   "film_en_end": 1782.832,
   "film_zh_start": 1853.95,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "I don't know the answer to that question because it is not the AI HPC that's taking away the attention. It is the economics of mining itself that is going worse by time",
   "who": "Liang Wang",
   "role": "VP, Canaan (mining-machine maker), The Blockspace Podcast, 10 Mar 2026",
   "source_title": "The Blockspace Podcast",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7rTCMXgmtQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "b7rTCMXgmtQ",
     2936.01,
     2950.17
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "He is talking about the economics of mining, not about Bitcoin's security budget as such.",
    "Canaan sells mining machines. The film's caption for him says so.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c39.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c10",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 1783.102,
   "film_en_end": 1793.802,
   "film_zh_start": 1868.98,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "IV · The Clock",
   "said": "We still think this is very important, but we don't, we don't think the monetary benefits will be a key driver after 2028. I hope I'm wrong.",
   "who": "Liang Wang",
   "role": "VP, Canaan (mining-machine maker), The Blockspace Podcast, 10 Mar 2026",
   "source_title": "The Blockspace Podcast",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7rTCMXgmtQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "b7rTCMXgmtQ",
     3075.47,
     3086.17
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "He is talking about the economics of mining, not about Bitcoin's security budget as such.",
    "Canaan sells mining machines. The film's caption for him says so.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c10.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-hen",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1819.042,
   "film_en_end": 1841.042,
   "film_zh_start": 1906.67,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "It doesn't matter if we have two gigabyte blocks. How much money are people making? If you look at the blocks, they earn 0.2 BSV, which is $6. Imagine if you told a BTC miner you could mine a two gigabyte block and earn six bucks, they would tell you to get out of here. Rightfully so, because they were getting a one megabyte block, yet they were earning $360,000.",
   "who": "Joshua Henslee",
   "role": "BSV developer, Learner Tank Podcast, May 2023",
   "source_title": "Learner Tank Podcast (Joshua Henslee)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMA9QwmSyjo",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvv29",
     697.12,
     706.2
    ],
    [
     "dvv29",
     709.5,
     722.4
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-hen.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c44",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1871.692,
   "film_en_end": 1882.812,
   "film_zh_start": 1961.96,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "demurrage is a mechanism to go fund a particular thing that is a public good in the context of Bitcoin. That's what I'm talking about and that's what I'm making an argument for.",
   "who": "Peter Todd",
   "role": "Former Bitcoin Core developer, bitcoin++ Toronto · \"Tail Emissions and Demurrage\", Jul 2026",
   "source_title": "bitcoin++ Toronto · \"Tail Emissions and Demurrage\"",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmAAeEm1nIE",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "OmAAeEm1nIE",
     1438.25,
     1449.75
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against two independent machine transcripts",
   "does_not_say": [
    "He describes the problem only. He favours a different fix (tail emission), not the one in this film.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c44.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1636",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 1886.412,
   "film_en_end": 1891.202,
   "film_zh_start": 1977.95,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "It would tax everyone who holds bitcoin, for every ten minutes they hold it.",
   "who": "Narrator, summarising Peter Todd's demurrage proposal",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Peter Todd, \"Tail Emissions and Demurrage\", bitcoin++ Toronto",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmAAeEm1nIE",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The research file records Todd's talk and his demurrage design; the spec notes the owner-ruled wording \"for every ten minutes\" (a charge accruing per block).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1636.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c17",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 1903.362,
   "film_en_end": 1915.375,
   "film_zh_start": 1996.37,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "I don't think a tail emission is something that's part of the contract people signed up for when they bought Bitcoin. Everybody was sold on a 21 million hard cap, you know, forever. That's the entire premise of it.",
   "who": "Mike Casey",
   "role": "Bitcoin security researcher · formerly MARA, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5DzU1CkyAc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "B5DzU1CkyAc",
     1531.45,
     1543.47
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c17.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-c15",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1915.375,
   "film_en_end": 1933.458,
   "film_zh_start": 2009.42,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "I ask them, what is an appropriate level of security budget? No one knows. No one knows how much is necessary. And so to say that it's flawed and Bitcoin's gonna have to change its 21 million hard cap to keep the subsidy going because the security will fall so low. I find that incredibly dishonest.",
   "who": "Dan Held",
   "role": "Formerly Kraken · General Partner, Asymmetric, Epicenter podcast, 21 Oct 2024",
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=90VB3hcZcDg",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-c15.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c11",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1941.069,
   "film_en_end": 1955.649,
   "film_zh_start": 2035.33,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "if you look at Monero, Monero, they have a tail emission and they put a lot of work into that tail emission and they're still regularly 51% attacked right now. Monero.",
   "who": "Mike Casey",
   "role": "Bitcoin security researcher · formerly MARA, Bitcoin 2026, Apr 2026",
   "source_title": "Bitcoin 2026",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5DzU1CkyAc",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "B5DzU1CkyAc",
     209.14,
     221.97
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against two independent machine transcripts",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c11.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c13",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 1994.439,
   "film_en_end": 2022.679,
   "film_zh_start": 2093.05,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "Under an extremely grave situation, it would be possible for participants in the network to say, we want to change our proof of work function. What would that do to an attacker? Every machine that they had bought, all of the electricity that they'd put into attacking the Bitcoin network would instantly be worth nothing. That's a nuclear option, which would be very contentious because people, you know, that's a fundamental building block of Bitcoin.",
   "who": "Vijay Boyapati",
   "role": "Author, The Bullish Case for Bitcoin, Unchained Ep. 272, 14 Sep 2021",
   "source_title": "Unchained Ep. 272",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IxahxTZK370",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "IxahxTZK370",
     2008.73,
     2029.64
    ],
    [
     "IxahxTZK370",
     2045.39,
     2052.37
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c13.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1778",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2028.829,
   "film_en_end": 2031.479,
   "film_zh_start": 2130.24,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "Ethereum did exactly that in 2022.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Ethereum's Merge: last proof-of-work block 15,537,393, first proof-of-stake block 15,537,394 (Etherscan)",
   "source_url": "https://etherscan.io/block/15537394",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The research file records the Merge date and the two block numbers, and ethereum.org's statement that mining no longer produces valid blocks.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1778.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c35",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 2060.609,
   "film_en_end": 2078.529,
   "film_zh_start": 2164.61,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "I think Bitcoin will survive if there's sufficient usage and demand, which creates a certain security budget, which just happens to be enough. And so it's not, that's why I'd call it like a flawed design, but I think it'll work out.",
   "who": "PBJ",
   "role": "Presidio Bitcoin podcast, PBJ Podcast, May 2026",
   "source_title": "PBJ Podcast",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDSRdGXY6cQ",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "YDSRdGXY6cQ",
     1172.88,
     1190.8
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against two independent machine transcripts",
   "does_not_say": [
    "No timetable is theirs: any date the film gives is the narrator's.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c35.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1829",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2079.349,
   "film_en_end": 2087.959,
   "film_zh_start": 2184.88,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "Even if fees ran forever at their best month on record, January 2018, this gap would open again after 2028.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT sizing registry, sz09 \"The Floor\", row \"Jan 2018 26.2%\" (fee dollars held flat while the subsidy halves)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry row records that the Jan 2018 fee share alone meets the 1% target today and leaves a $4.60B a year shortfall after the 2028 halving.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1829.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c38",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 2088.219,
   "film_en_end": 2110.519,
   "film_zh_start": 2194.47,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "And again, the potential for a 51% attack by a nefarious nation state or something. So I'm not saying that this is definitely going to happen, but I think people arguing about NFTs on Bitcoin, or arguing about whatever it may be, are really missing the larger picture of Bitcoin needing a better mechanism to secure itself decades into the future.",
   "who": "Matt Crosby",
   "role": "Research Director, LookIntoBitcoin, Milk Road Show, 18 Aug 2026",
   "source_title": "Milk Road Show",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2y1ZnkzVMFs",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "2y1ZnkzVMFs",
     1587.55,
     1609.95
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c38.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-back-x",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2119.272,
   "film_en_end": 2129.959,
   "film_zh_start": 2227.72,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "bitcoin price has gone up far more than 2x every 4 years, budget is probably higher than needed Could the price just double at every halving, forever?",
   "who": "Adam Back, post on X",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Adam Back, post on X",
   "source_url": "https://x.com/adam3us/status/1966813696048451639",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Read through the X oEmbed endpoint. The post itself says \"farm\" for \"far\"; the film's script marks it [sic].",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-back-x.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-doublings-2052",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2130.729,
   "film_en_end": 2138.639,
   "film_zh_start": 2239.78,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "V · The Trap",
   "said": "Seven more doublings, by 2052, and bitcoin would be worth more than everything the world produces in a year today.",
   "who": "The narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Figures registry entry btc_cap_doubled_2052.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-doublings-2052.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-redirect-2025",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2164.869,
   "film_en_end": 2172.279,
   "film_zh_start": 2278.74,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Since February 2025, every new NAT has gone to Bitcoin's miners, along with each block's reward.",
   "who": "The narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Figures registry entry nat_redirect_block.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2025-02-01. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-redirect-2025.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1920",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2174.389,
   "film_en_end": 2176.739,
   "film_zh_start": 2289.6,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "The 21 million doesn't change.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT FAQ (nat-faq), on Bitcoin's consensus rules being untouched; checked against the film's checklist",
   "source_url": "https://nat-faq.pages.dev/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The checklist verification marks 'Preserve 21M' VERIFIED against the FAQ, which says Bitcoin's consensus rules are untouched.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1920.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1968",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2222.679,
   "film_en_end": 2227.889,
   "film_zh_start": 2344.69,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Today it adds tens of dollars to each block, next to hundreds of thousands in bitcoin.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Film figures registry: bitcoin pay per block, with the spec's NAT-per-block check",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/reward-stats/4320",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry records bitcoin's pay per block as $264,000; the spec comments record NAT per block at about $30 to $40.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1968.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-1991",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2245.929,
   "film_en_end": 2255.509,
   "film_zh_start": 2371.22,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Every Bitcoin block, back to the very first one in January 2009, carries a number called bits, part of how Bitcoin sets its difficulty.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin genesis block header (block 0), bits field 0x1d00ffff",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/block/000000000019d6689c085ae165831e934ff763ae46a2a6c172b3f1b60a8ce26f",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry records that the genesis header was proven by sha256d equalling its block id, and that 3 Jan 2009 is the genesis timestamp.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2009-01-03. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-1991.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c18",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2266.989,
   "film_en_end": 2270.029,
   "film_zh_start": 2395.25,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Today we're dropping Digital Matter Theory.",
   "who": "The Block Runner",
   "role": "DMT launch, 21 Nov 2023 · courtesy of the show, The Block Runner, 21 Nov 2023",
   "source_title": "The Block Runner",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dmt_launch_blockrunner_2023-11-21",
     8.22,
     11.52
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "The Block Runner's hosts made NAT. This is its makers describing their own project.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c18.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c19",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 2270.659,
   "film_en_end": 2276.069,
   "film_zh_start": 2399.44,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "And so that's why we chose the field we did, which is the element, I think is the 11th field, which is bits.",
   "who": "The Block Runner",
   "role": "DMT launch, 21 Nov 2023 · courtesy of the show, The Block Runner, 21 Nov 2023",
   "source_title": "The Block Runner",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dmt_launch_blockrunner_2023-11-21",
     2703.43,
     2709.02
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "The Block Runner's hosts made NAT. This is its makers describing their own project.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c19.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c41",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2276.969,
   "film_en_end": 2282.069,
   "film_zh_start": 2406.64,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "And because the number gets smaller, as hash power goes up, the emissions of NAT goes down.",
   "who": "The Block Runner",
   "role": "Episode 331 · NAT's makers · courtesy of the show, The Block Runner, 12 Sep 2026",
   "source_title": "The Block Runner",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKpv2Ntx3OI",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "NKpv2Ntx3OI",
     3043.18,
     3048.43
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against two independent machine transcripts",
   "does_not_say": [
    "The Block Runner's hosts made NAT. This is its makers describing their own project.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c41.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c40",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2282.469,
   "film_en_end": 2289.969,
   "film_zh_start": 2412.91,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "At the time it was just an experiment. It was, there's, there's no association with like security budget issues. It was nothing like that.",
   "who": "The Block Runner",
   "role": "Episode 331 · NAT's makers · courtesy of the show, The Block Runner, 12 Sep 2026",
   "source_title": "The Block Runner",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKpv2Ntx3OI",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "NKpv2Ntx3OI",
     2944.05,
     2951.65
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against two independent machine transcripts",
   "does_not_say": [
    "The Block Runner's hosts made NAT. This is its makers describing their own project.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c40.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2036",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2290.559,
   "film_en_end": 2294.259,
   "film_zh_start": 2422.14,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "It launched in November 2023 as an open mint.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NATpaper (natgmi.com), launch details: Date November 20, 2023; start block 817,709",
   "source_url": "https://natgmi.com",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The mint-card data records the launch date from the NATpaper and cross-checks block 817,709 as mined on 2023-11-20.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2036.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2048",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2302.729,
   "film_en_end": 2306.079,
   "film_zh_start": 2436.03,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "More than twenty thousand people minted it in its first week.",
   "who": "Narrator, citing the NATpaper",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NATpaper (natgmi.com): Participation, 'Over 20,000 people joined, minting all available blocks in 7 days'",
   "source_url": "https://natgmi.com",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The mint-card data quotes the NATpaper line and flags it as the issuer's own account.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2048.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-holders-45k",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2306.229,
   "film_en_end": 2313.289,
   "film_zh_start": 2440.02,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Today more than forty-five thousand addresses hold some, on Bitcoin, Ethereum and BNB Chain.",
   "who": "The narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Figures registry entry nat_holders (a floor: 'more than').",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-10-05. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-holders-45k.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c28",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2328.849,
   "film_en_end": 2342.659,
   "film_zh_start": 2465.83,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "So it was not an engineered thing. Oh, let's do it like this, like this, and we have a long reaching plan, you know, to help NAT or not. It was simply just stop the bots from minting it.",
   "who": "Markus Bopp (\"Benny\")",
   "role": "Founder, CEO and CTO, Trac Systems\nbuilds the TAP Protocol that NAT is built on, Clean Slate Podcast, Ep. 2, 20 May 2026",
   "source_title": "Clean Slate Podcast, Ep. 2",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pRMYTMkj6Ic",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "pRMYTMkj6Ic",
     1024.4,
     1038.36
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Trac Systems, his company, builds the protocol NAT runs on.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c28.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2092",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2346.399,
   "film_en_end": 2348.349,
   "film_zh_start": 2485.85,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Satoshi wrote it down in 2010.",
   "who": "Narrator, citing Satoshi Nakamoto's bitcointalk post",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcointalk.org forum post",
   "source_url": "https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=48.msg329#msg329",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The clip plan lists the post and its URL; the script quotes its sentence about fees becoming the main compensation.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2092.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2095",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2349.619,
   "film_en_end": 2357.269,
   "film_zh_start": 2489.52,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Mining groups take it because it costs them nothing: AntPool, F2Pool, SpiderPool, ViaBTC and Luxor.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT adoption ledger: dated adoption per mining pool",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The ledger lists all five pools; four have dated claims, Luxor is marked low confidence. The mechanism (credited from coinbase outputs, miners run nothing new) is in the mint data and the spec.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2095.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2103",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2357.909,
   "film_en_end": 2370.929,
   "film_zh_start": 2498.98,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "In August, a proposal called BIP-110 tried a temporary change to Bitcoin's rules, one that would have limited how much non-payment data, like images and tokens, a transaction can carry.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "bit.com knowledge hub on BIP-110, with Jameson Lopp's 'A layman's guide to BIP-110'",
   "source_url": "https://www.bit.com/knowledge-hub/bip-110",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Only the spec's own comment records the explanation sources and their wording; the August date is in the open-exit sources note.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2103.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2116",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2371.099,
   "film_en_end": 2374.739,
   "film_zh_start": 2514.03,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "When its vote opened, two and a half percent of miners backed it.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "BIP-110 mandatory signalling window: 51 of 2,016 blocks signalling (block 961,632, 8 Aug 2026)",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/blocks/961631",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry records 51 of 2,016 blocks (2.53%) counted by block version bit 4 and matched to CoinDesk 7 Aug 2026.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-10-05. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2116.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2120",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2374.819,
   "film_en_end": 2376.029,
   "film_zh_start": 2518.28,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "It needed fifty-five.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "BIP-110 activation threshold, as reported by CoinDesk and Cointelegraph (recorded in the open-exit sources note)",
   "source_url": "https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2026/08/07/frame-bitcoin-s-bip-110-enters-mandatory-signaling-with-less-than-3-miner-support",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The open-exit sources note records the threshold as agreed across several outlets: 55% of blocks over a two-week window, about 1,109 of 2,016.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2120.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2128",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2382.139,
   "film_en_end": 2390.199,
   "film_zh_start": 2526.63,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "NAT is taken by pools that find fifty-seven percent of Bitcoin's blocks, including three that never backed BIP-110.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "mempool.space pools, 7-day window 24 Sep - 1 Oct 2026: 595 of 1,040 blocks by the five adopting pools",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/pools/1w",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The pool-adoption data records 595 of 1,040 blocks (57.2%) for the five ledger pools; the open-exit note lists the four pools that never signalled BIP-110 (AntPool, ViaBTC and F2Pool are among the five).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2128.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2139",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2393.319,
   "film_en_end": 2398.729,
   "film_zh_start": 2539.38,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Two of them, F2Pool and SpiderPool, pass it on to the miners who work with them.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT adoption ledger: downstream distribution (F2Pool help page; KuCoin post on SpiderPool's NAT mining mechanism)",
   "source_url": "https://www.kucoin.com/blog/NAT-Mining-Mechanism-Launched",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The ledger records downstream distribution for exactly these two pools, both from 27 Apr 2026, with the F2Pool help page and KuCoin post as sources.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2139.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2151",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2405.968,
   "film_en_end": 2407.488,
   "film_zh_start": 2553.73,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Only two pass it on.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT adoption ledger and the 4 Nov 2026 recheck: no third pool found passing NAT on",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The recheck reports the ledger records downstream distribution for F2Pool and SpiderPool only, and fresh searches found no third pool.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2151.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2154",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2408.128,
   "film_en_end": 2417.188,
   "film_zh_start": 2556.13,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "About half of all the NAT ever credited to miners hasn't been touched, and Foundry alone has over nine trillion sitting unclaimed.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT credited to miners by pool, counted from block 885,588 to block 974,519 (G53 method, rerun 4 Nov 2026)",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/blocks/974519",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The recheck recounted NAT per block (the bits value) credited to the ledger's five pools versus all other pools: 47.65% untouched, Foundry 9.88T.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2154.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2177",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2431.154,
   "film_en_end": 2441.424,
   "film_zh_start": 2581.61,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "In September 2025, seven months after NAT started paying miners, the creator of Ordinals went through every project built on Bitcoin, on a podcast.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Casey Rodarmor, \"Every Bitcoin Metaprotocol & L2\", Hell Money Podcast",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4sdHUzlzBRE&t=2028s",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The clip plan and the spec record the episode, host show and date; 'seven months' is from the redirect block 885,588 (mined 27 Feb 2025) to 24 Sep 2025.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2177.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c42",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2448.884,
   "film_en_end": 2458.664,
   "film_zh_start": 2601.09,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Look, I'm going to issue a token, and one unit of that token is going to exist every time there's a 69 inside of a block hash in a Bitcoin block. –Fuck yeah.",
   "who": "Casey Rodarmor",
   "role": "Creator of Ordinals, Hell Money Podcast, 24 Sep 2025",
   "source_title": "Hell Money Podcast",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4sdHUzlzBRE",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "4sdHUzlzBRE",
     2028.12,
     2037.75
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c42.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c43",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "view",
   "label_name": "Speaker's opinion",
   "film_en_start": 2458.814,
   "film_en_end": 2463.634,
   "film_zh_start": 2612.0,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "I think of all of these, this is like, this one's asking the right questions.",
   "who": "Erin",
   "role": "Hell Money Podcast, 24 Sep 2025",
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4sdHUzlzBRE",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "4sdHUzlzBRE",
     2134.5,
     2139.35
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c43.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2240",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2494.276,
   "film_en_end": 2497.665,
   "film_zh_start": 2653.84,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "And that pay is cut in half every four years.",
   "who": "Vera",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin protocol: the block subsidy halves every 210,000 blocks (about four years)",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/src/kernel/chainparams.cpp",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry records the 210,000-block halving interval as a protocol constant; at 52,560 blocks a year that is four years.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2009-01-03. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2240.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-sul",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2497.833,
   "film_en_end": 2512.625,
   "film_zh_start": 2658.42,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "The expectation is that when block reward gets cut in half, difficulty drops, or how hard it is to find a block. In this previous halving, difficulty did not really fall off. And so mining revenue did get cut almost nearly in half in April, in a single day.",
   "who": "Adam Sullivan",
   "role": "CEO, Core Scientific, Bloomberg Businessweek, Sep 2024",
   "source_title": "Adam Sullivan, Bloomberg Businessweek",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZKhmwlBTmwM",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-sul.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2299",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2554.077,
   "film_en_end": 2555.427,
   "film_zh_start": 2728.04,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Take that one-dollar floor.",
   "who": "Vera",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT sizing registry: target_pct 1.0 (Lyn Alden's band 0.5-1.5% of bitcoin's value a year)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The sizing registry's constants record the target as 1.0 percent of bitcoin's value a year, inside the Alden band.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2299.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-gap-3b",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2558.157,
   "film_en_end": 2565.287,
   "film_zh_start": 2733.0,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "The gap, about 20 cents on every hundred dollars of bitcoin, comes to about $3 billion a year.",
   "who": "The narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Figures registry entry; the screen figure moves with the price (rechecked 4 Nov 2026 at $2.81B).",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-gap-3b.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2316",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2570.497,
   "film_en_end": 2573.207,
   "film_zh_start": 2748.01,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "In 2028, the gap is about 60 cents.",
   "who": "Vera",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT sizing registry sz09 (fee dollars held flat, subsidy halved once) and the Vera explainer design table",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry row for today's fees gives bitcoin's pay as 0.4133% of its value after the 2028 halving, which is a 58.7 cent gap to the 1% floor; the design table records 58.6 or 59.6 cents under its two conventions.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2316.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2319",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2573.457,
   "film_en_end": 2575.927,
   "film_zh_start": 2751.61,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "In 2032, about eighty.",
   "who": "Vera",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT sizing registry sz09 (fee dollars held flat, subsidy halved twice) and the Vera explainer design table",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry row gives bitcoin's pay as 0.2089% of its value after 2032, a 79.1 cent gap; the design table records 79.1 or 80.1 cents.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2319.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2322",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2576.357,
   "film_en_end": 2578.627,
   "film_zh_start": 2755.14,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "In 2036, ninety.",
   "who": "Vera",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Vera explainer design, table 2.6 (same formula as NAT sizing registry sz09, extended to 2036)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The design table records the 2036 gap as 89.3 or 90.2 cents under its two conventions, by the same formula as the registry rows for 2028 and 2032.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2322.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2324",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2579.017,
   "film_en_end": 2582.207,
   "film_zh_start": 2758.37,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "After that, almost the whole dollar is missing.",
   "who": "Vera",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Vera explainer design, table 2.6: gap for 2044, 2048 and 2052",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The design table gives the gap past 2036 as about $16B to $17B a year of a $17B whole dollar (94.4 cents for 2040).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2324.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2328",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2582.797,
   "film_en_end": 2586.807,
   "film_zh_start": 2762.97,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "At today's price, that's more than $15 billion a year.",
   "who": "Vera",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "1% of bitcoin's market value at the 4 Nov 2026 price ($78,546 x 20,107,878 BTC = $1.579T)",
   "source_url": "https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/bitcoin",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The recheck records the market cap at $1.579T, so the whole 1% floor is about $15.8B a year; the design table gives about $17B at the earlier $84k price.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2328.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2335",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2592.28,
   "film_en_end": 2595.69,
   "film_zh_start": 2774.15,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "The guard is being paid about eight hundred a year to secure it.",
   "who": "Vera",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Miner pay as a share of bitcoin's value: 165,279 BTC a year over 20,090,909 BTC supply (the price cancels)",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/reward-stats/4320",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The 4 Nov recheck recomputed the rate as 0.8218% over the last 1,008 blocks, which is $822 on $100,000.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2335.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2339",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2595.97,
   "film_en_end": 2598.55,
   "film_zh_start": 2778.85,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "By 2036, about a hundred.",
   "who": "Vera",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Miner pay per $100,000 of bitcoin after three more halvings, fees held flat (4 Nov 2026 recheck, C3)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The recheck computes $107 by the film's method and $103 using 2036 supply, and calls both 'about a hundred'.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2339.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-nat-50b",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2602.507,
   "film_en_end": 2607.777,
   "film_zh_start": 2787.17,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "For NAT to pay even today's gap, it would have to be worth more than $50 billion.",
   "who": "The narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": null,
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Figures registry entry; rechecked 4 Nov 2026 at $53.9B to $55.3B.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-nat-50b.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2352",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2609.072,
   "film_en_end": 2610.782,
   "film_zh_start": 2794.49,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "About 3 percent of Bitcoin.",
   "who": "Vera",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT market value needed to close today's gap, as a share of bitcoin's market value (recheck L5)",
   "source_url": "https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/dmt-nat",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The recheck computes $2.81B / 5.09% to 5.23% = $55.3B to $53.9B, which is 3.50% or 3.41% of bitcoin's market value.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2352.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2367",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2626.097,
   "film_en_end": 2632.407,
   "film_zh_start": 2813.45,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "At Saylor's price, the gap in Bitcoin's security budget is over four trillion dollars a year.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Film arithmetic: 1% of 21,000,000 coins at $21,000,000 each, less the 2046 block reward (v8.7 figures check)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The v8.7 figures check recomputed the sum on 4 Nov 2026: a $441T network value gives a $4.41T budget and a $4.30T gap after the 2046 reward, which it marks as holding only at the $1-per-hundred floor.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2367.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2388",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2647.314,
   "film_en_end": 2652.824,
   "film_zh_start": 2838.11,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "New bitcoin forever, a tail emission: the 21 million is gone.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "CCAF and Fii, Funding Bitcoin's Future: Paying for Security as the Block Subsidy Fades",
   "source_url": "https://www.jbs.cam.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ccaf-2026-funding-bitcoins-future.pdf",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The Cambridge thread notes record, quote checked character for character against the PDF, that tail emission 'requires a hard fork' and that the 21M cap is 'constitutive, not merely descriptive' (pp. 41 and 48).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2388.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2418",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2677.124,
   "film_en_end": 2681.674,
   "film_zh_start": 2876.5,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "They'd have to be about 37 times what they are today, and stay there.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Film sizing: fee AMOUNT needed to cover the gap, as a multiple of today's fee dollars (owner answer A2.3, v6.4)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The v6.4 answers sheet records the working: (today's $82.6M in fees + the $2.98B gap) / $82.6M = about 37x.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2418.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2423",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2682.434,
   "film_en_end": 2685.974,
   "film_zh_start": 2883.33,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "After 2028, about 120 times.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Film sizing: fee AMOUNT needed after the 2028 halving, as a multiple of today's fee dollars (owner answer A2.3, v6.4)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The v6.4 answers sheet records about 122x after 2028 under the 'same fee dollars held forever' reading; the film says 'about 120'.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2423.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2446",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2705.893,
   "film_en_end": 2708.033,
   "film_zh_start": 2912.89,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Namecoin has done it since 2011.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The NAT FAQ comparison table, row 'Namecoin, RSK since 2011' (merged mining)",
   "source_url": "https://nat-faq.pages.dev/",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Marked 'checked' in the 4 Nov line review; the audit and the FAQ table both list Namecoin as merged mining since 2011.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2446.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2456",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2715.339,
   "film_en_end": 2722.197,
   "film_zh_start": 2924.05,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Its new report says income like that could supplement mining revenue without requiring changes to Bitcoin itself.",
   "who": "Narrator, summarising a Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance report",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "CCAF and Fii, Funding Bitcoin's Future: Paying for Security as the Block Subsidy Fades (page 42)",
   "source_url": "https://www.jbs.cam.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ccaf-2026-funding-bitcoins-future.pdf",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The Cambridge thread notes quote page 42 as 'This could supplement mining revenue without requiring changes to Bitcoin itself.', each quote checked character for character against the PDF.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2456.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2463",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2722.28,
   "film_en_end": 2725.517,
   "film_zh_start": 2932.21,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "For now, chains like these bring in less than 1%.",
   "who": "Narrator, summarising a Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance report",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "CCAF and Fii, Funding Bitcoin's Future: Paying for Security as the Block Subsidy Fades (page 42)",
   "source_url": "https://www.jbs.cam.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ccaf-2026-funding-bitcoins-future.pdf",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The Cambridge thread notes quote page 42: auxiliary chains 'collectively contribute less than 1% of miner revenue', checked against the PDF.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2463.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "r-c1a",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2725.75,
   "film_en_end": 2733.375,
   "film_zh_start": 2936.29,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "that actually the most of the current L2 stuff is in the wrong direction, and only the stuff that pays the miners has a future.",
   "who": "Paul Sztorc",
   "role": "LayerTwo Labs · author of BIP-300 · founder of the eCash fork, Bitcoin Asia 2024, The Bitcoin Conference, May 2024",
   "source_title": "Paul Sztorc, Mining Incentives and Network Security, Bitcoin Asia 2024",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACWXDvJuAis",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "dvh27",
     1065.76,
     1073.36
    ]
   ],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/r-c1a.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2503",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2762.189,
   "film_en_end": 2771.059,
   "film_zh_start": 2977.46,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Bitcoin's funds, its miners and the companies with a bitcoin reserve strategy all name the halving as a risk, in their own filings.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "The Security Budget Files: every filing that names this risk",
   "source_url": "https://security-budget-files.pages.dev",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The disclosure series registry records, per lane, that all eleven ETFs, all nineteen filing miners and all ten treasury companies carry the halving risk; each is quoted verbatim and linked to EDGAR on the lane pages.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2503.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2567",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2826.13,
   "film_en_end": 2833.75,
   "film_zh_start": 3056.24,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "The formula follows Bitcoin's difficulty, so the amount moves, but gently: by about a hundredth of a percent since March 2025.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin block headers (bits field), retarget blocks 887,040 (9 Mar 2025) to 969,696 (3 Oct 2026), mempool.space Esplora API",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The spec records bits 386,040,449 at block 887,040 falling to 386,014,960 at block 969,696: -0.0066% net over 41 retargets, range 0.012%. The headers file holds both values.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2567.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2578",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2837.9,
   "film_en_end": 2841.17,
   "film_zh_start": 3070.55,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "In 2028 the bitcoin in every block halves.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin protocol: the subsidy halves every 210,000 blocks (next halving at block 1,050,000)",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/src/kernel/chainparams.cpp",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry holds the 2028 halving at block 1,050,000 (5 x 210,000); the spec notes halvings so far in 2012, 2016, 2020, 2024, the fifth in 2028; the countdown recorded 79,881 blocks (1.5 years) to go from the tip on 6 Oct 2026.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2009-01-03. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2578.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2599",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "count",
   "label_name": "A count we made",
   "film_en_start": 2858.502,
   "film_en_end": 2860.312,
   "film_zh_start": 3093.5,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Nearly four thousand of them.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin block 975,007 (Foundry USA, 8 Nov 2026), transaction count 3,938, mempool.space",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/block/000000000000000000006a327f6671c17ae52a6d7a798aec6d902912aa9e35c7",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The block-cube graphic's source sets TX = 3,938 for block 975,007, read from mempool.space on 8 Nov 2026 (coinbase included in the count of voxels).",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2599.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2607",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2866.092,
   "film_en_end": 2871.192,
   "film_zh_start": 3101.09,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Together, all those transactions paid less than 1% of what the subsidy paid.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin block 975,007 (Foundry USA, 8 Nov 2026): fees 0.01929918 BTC against a 3.125 BTC subsidy, mempool.space",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/block/000000000000000000006a327f6671c17ae52a6d7a798aec6d902912aa9e35c7",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The cube graphic's source records fees of 0.01929918 BTC paid by all 3,938 transactions against the 3.125 BTC subsidy: 0.6% of the subsidy.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2607.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c22",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2882.977,
   "film_en_end": 2892.367,
   "film_zh_start": 3117.98,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "And so the idea here is that with the NAT token being sent to the miners, they'll have at least a second subsidy to sell to continue paying the bills.",
   "who": "The Block Runner",
   "role": "NAT's first birthday · courtesy of the show, The Block Runner, Nov 2024 · before miners were paid",
   "source_title": "The Block Runner",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fwyh4xh1bNY",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "Fwyh4xh1bNY",
     1008.25,
     1017.64
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "Against two independent machine transcripts",
   "does_not_say": [
    "The Block Runner's hosts made NAT. This is its makers describing their own project.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c22.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c25",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2905.167,
   "film_en_end": 2912.677,
   "film_zh_start": 3142.1,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "It is connected to Bitcoin. When a Bitcoin block propagates, the NAT system awards a subsidy.",
   "who": "Joe Spencer · @CincoDoggos",
   "role": "Bitcoin miner, host of Mid-Week Mining\nbuilding an app for $NAT (IllumiNAT, not yet released), Mid-Week Mining, 17 Sep 2026",
   "source_title": "Mid-Week Mining, X broadcast by @CincoDoggos (Joe Spencer), 17 Sep 2026",
   "source_url": "https://x.com/i/broadcasts/1YxNrbXgvwpxw",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "1YxNrbXgvwpxw",
     2725.72,
     2729.14
    ],
    [
     "1YxNrbXgvwpxw",
     2737.59,
     2745.2
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "He is a miner building an app for NAT.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c25.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "s-c26",
   "kind": "clip",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 2913.017,
   "film_en_end": 2925.537,
   "film_zh_start": 3150.64,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "That's the whole point is it's there as a secondary layer. So that way Bitcoin miners do not have to spend their Bitcoin to pay the bills for their mining, right?",
   "who": "Joe Spencer · @CincoDoggos",
   "role": "Bitcoin miner, host of Mid-Week Mining\nbuilding an app for $NAT (IllumiNAT, not yet released), Mid-Week Mining, 17 Sep 2026",
   "source_title": "Mid-Week Mining, X broadcast by @CincoDoggos (Joe Spencer), 17 Sep 2026",
   "source_url": "https://x.com/i/broadcasts/1YxNrbXgvwpxw",
   "tape_windows": [
    [
     "1YxNrbXgvwpxw",
     2898.72,
     2911.24
    ]
   ],
   "checked": "By ear against the original recording",
   "does_not_say": [
    "He is a miner building an app for NAT.",
    "Being quoted doesn't mean they agree with, or know about, any fix the film proposes."
   ],
   "page": "item/s-c26.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2688",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2947.229,
   "film_en_end": 2952.199,
   "film_zh_start": 3190.23,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Every dollar of bitcoin sends less than one cent a year to the miners who guard it.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Film sizing registry: security spend 0.82% of bitcoin's value a year (subsidy + fees, price cancels)",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/reward-stats/4320",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The sizing registry gives btc_security_per_dollar = $0.0082 (0.82% of market cap reaches miners per year); the v8.7 check re-measured 0.8218% on 4 Nov 2026.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2688.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2693",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2952.519,
   "film_en_end": 2955.109,
   "film_zh_start": 3196.21,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Every dollar of NAT sends about five.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Film sizing registry: NAT emission 5.2% of its own value a year, credited to the block's miner",
   "source_url": "https://natgmi.com",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The sizing registry gives nat_security_per_dollar = $0.052 ($1 of NAT market cap pays $0.052 to miners per year, by construction); the v8.7 check recomputed 5.09% to 5.23% on 4 Nov 2026.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2693.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2699",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2958.919,
   "film_en_end": 2963.089,
   "film_zh_start": 3203.45,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Bitcoin adds less than one percent a year, and halves it.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Film sizing registry: security spend 0.82% of bitcoin's value a year",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/reward-stats/4320",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The spec notes record 'Bitcoin adds less than one percent a year' as the subsidy's 0.82%; the v8.7 check measured the subsidy alone near 0.82% (0.8168% by its C3 working).",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2699.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2705",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": 2964.385,
   "film_en_end": 2967.875,
   "film_zh_start": 3209.72,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "NAT adds about five today, and never halves.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Film sizing registry: NAT emission 5.2% of its own value a year; NAT per block = the block's bits value (no halving)",
   "source_url": "https://natgmi.com",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The sizing registry and the v8.7 check give about five today (5.09% to 5.23%); the facts registry records NAT emission as following difficulty with no halving and no cap.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2705.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2711",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 2970.204,
   "film_en_end": 2973.924,
   "film_zh_start": 3217.92,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "The 21 million is Bitcoin's promise, not NAT's.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "NAT facts registry: emission is bits-derived, declines about 1.3% a year, no halving, no cap",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The facts registry records NAT as having no cap and no halving; the bits-origin data records NAT per block as the block's bits value.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2711.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2752",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 3011.874,
   "film_en_end": 3018.224,
   "film_zh_start": 3270.2,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "The chance I mean is narrower: a second answer to the bet Satoshi made in 2010.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcointalk.org forum post",
   "source_url": "https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=48.msg329#msg329",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Only that the project's clip plan lists this post as the 2010 source; the wording of the post is not quoted in any file I found.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2752.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2823",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 3082.933,
   "film_en_end": 3088.3,
   "film_zh_start": 3356.02,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "We don't know how much we need We don't know if that's 1 billion, 5 billion, 10 billion, or 100 billion.",
   "who": "Dan Held (second sentence); Jordan McKinney (first sentence, by text match)",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin Super-Cycle w/ Dan Held, Bitcoin Fundamentals (BTC016), The Investor's Podcast Network",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ly-Gv6qNbNg&t=2495s",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The Held audio search checked the quote against two independent transcripts (YouTube en-orig captions and our ASR); both agree on every quoted word. The speaker call rests on what is said, not a voice check.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2823.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2840",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "exact",
   "label_name": "Exact words",
   "film_en_start": 3099.563,
   "film_en_end": 3101.673,
   "film_zh_start": 3372.65,
   "film_zh_exact": true,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "to $3,000, to $30,000, to $300,000.",
   "who": "Michael Saylor",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Michael Saylor on The Iced Coffee Hour (clip: \"$300,000 a transaction\"; full episode linked from the clip)",
   "source_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRlnHVHE18k",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The v8.7 check read the clip's description, followed its link to the full episode (uploaded 2 Jun 2024) and found the clip's \"$300,000 a transaction\" passage word for word in the full episode's captions. The 2 Jun 2024 date is the publication date; no recording date was found.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2840.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2865",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "para",
   "label_name": "Narration paraphrases",
   "film_en_start": 3124.924,
   "film_en_end": 3129.734,
   "film_zh_start": 3399.64,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "In 2010, Satoshi bet that fees would one day pay Bitcoin's guards.",
   "who": "Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcointalk.org",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcointalk.org forum post",
   "source_url": "https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=48.msg329#msg329",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The clip plan lists the Feb 2010 bitcointalk post as the film's 2010 source; the spec carries the quote the film reads from it ('In a few decades when the reward gets too small, the transaction fee will become the main compensation.').",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2865.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2870",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "count",
   "label_name": "A count we made",
   "film_en_start": 3129.864,
   "film_en_end": 3132.464,
   "film_zh_start": 3405.13,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "Four halvings later, they still don't.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "CCAF and Fii, Funding Bitcoin's Future: Paying for Security as the Block Subsidy Fades (fees 0.67% of miner revenue over 90 days)",
   "source_url": "https://www.jbs.cam.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/ccaf-2026-funding-bitcoins-future.pdf",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "Count: the spec lists the halvings so far as 2012, 2016, 2020 and 2024 (four). The Cambridge thread notes (checked against the PDF) give fees at 0.67% of miner revenue over 90 days to 4 Oct 2026.",
   "does_not_say": [],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2870.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "n-tbc-2873",
   "kind": "narration",
   "label": "count",
   "label_name": "A count we made",
   "film_en_start": 3132.544,
   "film_en_end": 3134.534,
   "film_zh_start": 3408.11,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": "VI · A Different Answer",
   "said": "The fifth comes in 2028.",
   "who": "Narrator",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin protocol: the subsidy halves every 210,000 blocks (next halving at block 1,050,000)",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/src/kernel/chainparams.cpp",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": "The registry holds the next halving at block 1,050,000 (5 x 210,000); the spec notes the four halvings so far (2012, 2016, 2020, 2024) and the fifth in 2028.",
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2009-01-03. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/n-tbc-2873.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-bip110-block",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "961,632",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "the first block of BIP-110's mandatory signalling window",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/block/961632",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-10-05. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-bip110-block.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-bits-block-250000",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "250,000 / 426,957,810 / 3 Aug 2013",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "the block header (mempool.space, fetched 30 Sep 2026; each header checked against its hash), data/dv-bits-origin.json",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/block/250000",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-bits-block-250000.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-bits-block-500000",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "500,000 / 402,691,653 / 18 Dec 2017",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "the block header (mempool.space, fetched 30 Sep 2026; each header checked against its hash), data/dv-bits-origin.json",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/block/500000",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-bits-block-500000.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-bits-block-700000",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "700,000 / 386,877,668 / 11 Sep 2021",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "the block header (mempool.space, fetched 30 Sep 2026; each header checked against its hash), data/dv-bits-origin.json",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/block/700000",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-bits-block-700000.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-bits-block-969274",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "969,274 / 386,014,917 / 30 Sep 2026",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "the block header (mempool.space, fetched 30 Sep 2026; each header checked against its hash), data/dv-bits-origin.json",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/block/969274",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-bits-block-969274.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-blackrock-10k-filed",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "27 FEB 2026",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "SEC EDGAR, iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF Form 10-K, filed 2026-02-27 (clip-plan.md 12a; the etf-risk-factor page)",
   "source_url": "https://www.sec.gov/cgi-bin/browse-edgar?action=getcompany&company=ishares+bitcoin+trust&type=10-K",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-02-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-blackrock-10k-filed.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-btc-price-sizing",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "$84,046",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "CoinGecko spot, 27 Sep 2026 (data/sizing-figures.json btc_price)",
   "source_url": "https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/bitcoin",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-btc-price-sizing.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-fee-record-day",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "22 DEC 2017",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "mempool.space daily avgFees (data/dv-fee-record.json, fetched 2026-09-30); share = fees / (fees + subsidy)",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/blocks/fees/all",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-fee-record-day.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-retarget-period-blocks",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "2,016",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "Bitcoin protocol: difficulty retargets every 2,016 blocks",
   "source_url": "https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/src/kernel/chainparams.cpp",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2009-01-03. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-retarget-period-blocks.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-sizing-shortfall-pct",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "0.18%",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "sizing registry (data/sizing-figures.json, 27 Sep 2026): 1% target - 0.8233%",
   "source_url": "https://mempool.space/api/v1/mining/reward-stats/4320",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-sizing-shortfall-pct.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-sizing-target-usd-yr",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "$17B",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "sizing registry (data/sizing-figures.json, 27 Sep 2026): 1% x CoinGecko market cap",
   "source_url": "https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/bitcoin",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-27. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-sizing-target-usd-yr.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-v83-hdr-footer-date",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "30 Sep 2026",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "the v8.2 header card footer: block headers fetched from mempool.space the day of block 969,274 (NAT/data/dv-bits-origin.json)",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-09-30. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-v83-hdr-footer-date.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-v83-sky-genesis",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "486,604,799 / 3 Jan 2009",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "block headers, mempool.space Esplora API, fetched 2026-10-09 (each header proven sha256d == id; 23 sampled vs btcscan.org), NAT/video/_lookdev/2026-09-30/animatic/v70prep/v83cand/c1/data/bits_retargets.json",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-10-09. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-v83-sky-genesis.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-v83-sky-last-retarget",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "969,696",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "block headers, mempool.space Esplora API, fetched 2026-10-09 (each header proven sha256d == id; 23 sampled vs btcscan.org), NAT/video/_lookdev/2026-09-30/animatic/v70prep/v83cand/c1/data/bits_retargets.json",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-10-09. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-v83-sky-last-retarget.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-v83-sky-tip",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "970,578 / 386,014,960 / 9 Oct 2026",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "block headers, mempool.space Esplora API, fetched 2026-10-09 (each header proven sha256d == id; 23 sampled vs btcscan.org), NAT/video/_lookdev/2026-09-30/animatic/v70prep/v83cand/c1/data/bits_retargets.json",
   "source_url": null,
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-10-09. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-v83-sky-tip.html"
  },
  {
   "id": "f-world-gdp-2025",
   "kind": "figure",
   "label": "calc",
   "label_name": "Our calculation",
   "film_en_start": null,
   "film_en_end": null,
   "film_zh_start": null,
   "film_zh_exact": false,
   "chapter": null,
   "said": "$118T",
   "who": "On screen",
   "role": null,
   "source_title": "World Bank WDI, NY.GDP.MKTP.CD, World, 2025 ($118.35T); IMF WEO Apr 2026 gives $118.18T",
   "source_url": "https://api.worldbank.org/v2/country/WLD/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.CD?format=json&date=2022:2025",
   "tape_windows": [],
   "checked": null,
   "does_not_say": [
    "It is a snapshot of the data on 2026-10-05. It moves as the data moves."
   ],
   "page": "item/f-world-gdp-2025.html"
  }
 ],
 "filers": [
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "IBIT",
   "issuer": "BlackRock",
   "name": "iShares Bitcoin Trust",
   "para": 268,
   "hl": "thereby jeopardizing the security of the Bitcoin network",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001980994",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-27",
   "accession": "0001437749-26-006058",
   "file": "bit20251231_10k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1980994/000143774926006058/bit20251231_10k.htm",
   "sha256": "dac350e7c2dd22174543f575825af57a88bd4a698dfd8ac795d48591eb4ff36f",
   "n_paragraphs": 928,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "FBTC",
   "issuer": "Fidelity",
   "name": "Fidelity Wise Origin Bitcoin Fund",
   "para": 302,
   "hl": "If the award does not exceed the costs of mining in the long-term, miners may have to cease operations entirely",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001852317",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-25",
   "accession": "0001193125-26-071484",
   "file": "ck0001852317-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1852317/000119312526071484/ck0001852317-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "4f2d4669269e62fae14ecb03b2d2138fec48ab99c5c1487535a85fe823ca90a3",
   "n_paragraphs": 846,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "GBTC",
   "issuer": "Grayscale",
   "name": "Grayscale Bitcoin Trust ETF",
   "para": 545,
   "hl": "miners may cease expending processing power to mine blocks",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001588489",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-25",
   "accession": "0001193125-26-071956",
   "file": "gbtc-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1588489/000119312526071956/gbtc-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "2a73bd77a773740e05533998d2b34444ab90fac6d778bc3d6effc7f9600abd42",
   "n_paragraphs": 1428,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BTC",
   "issuer": "Grayscale",
   "name": "Grayscale Bitcoin Mini Trust ETF",
   "para": 555,
   "hl": "miners may cease expending processing power to mine blocks",
   "primary": "GBTC",
   "cik": "0002015034",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-25",
   "accession": "0001193125-26-071952",
   "file": "btc-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2015034/000119312526071952/btc-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "e37278cf390c24a6a99d3bb0ce8f22ca85e9bdeb8d4d1e53727dd470c9c4e45a",
   "n_paragraphs": 1400,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "ARKB",
   "issuer": "ARK 21Shares",
   "name": "Ark 21Shares Bitcoin ETF",
   "para": 304,
   "hl": "miners may operate at a loss, transition to other networks, or cease operations altogether",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001869699",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-02",
   "accession": "0001213900-26-021831",
   "file": "ea0276464-10k_ark21share.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1869699/000121390026021831/ea0276464-10k_ark21share.htm",
   "sha256": "25916f9878c2f7f8196b749e94478956c4d76710ee13556b3abba80745e06a14",
   "n_paragraphs": 840,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BITB",
   "issuer": "Bitwise",
   "name": "Bitwise Bitcoin ETF",
   "para": 340,
   "hl": "the mining incentive structure may transition to a higher reliance on transaction confirmation fees",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001763415",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-02",
   "accession": "0001193125-26-085335",
   "file": "bitb-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1763415/000119312526085335/bitb-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "4bf42bf82259a2f4beff97d1c1acfe08e4c67ea0042be88f3ab3555f7d364ab0",
   "n_paragraphs": 1113,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "HODL",
   "issuer": "VanEck",
   "name": "VanEck Bitcoin Trust",
   "para": 260,
   "hl": "transaction fees for recording transactions are not sufficiently high to exceed the costs of mining",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001838028",
   "form": "10-K/A",
   "date": "2026-03-27",
   "accession": "0000930413-26-000927",
   "file": "c115591_10ka-ixbrl.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1838028/000093041326000927/c115591_10ka-ixbrl.htm",
   "sha256": "59ea42af394d92050c10f96e71d6fbae82ab947464573c108f0a69cea0f67814",
   "n_paragraphs": 846,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BTCO",
   "issuer": "Invesco",
   "name": "Invesco Galaxy Bitcoin ETF",
   "para": 130,
   "hl": "could increase the likelihood of a malicious actor or botnet obtaining control",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001855781",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-02",
   "accession": "0001193125-26-083572",
   "file": "btco-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1855781/000119312526083572/btco-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "50339edb70e73654c2f8ee7b1eef4d1d77d0dc89b52b8f8aef1a429d83496cec",
   "n_paragraphs": 690,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BRRR",
   "issuer": "CoinShares",
   "name": "CoinShares Bitcoin ETF",
   "para": 243,
   "hl": "increase the network’s vulnerability to attacks, including the risk that a malicious actor could obtain sufficient control to manipulate the blockchain",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001841175",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-10",
   "accession": "0001999371-26-005527",
   "file": "brrr_10k-123125.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1841175/000199937126005527/brrr_10k-123125.htm",
   "sha256": "6619be875013cc7095e923600637365d8223b4f7fc68f64865be56f1b34afb2b",
   "n_paragraphs": 870,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BTCW",
   "issuer": "WisdomTree",
   "name": "WisdomTree Bitcoin Fund",
   "para": 426,
   "hl": "could be inadequate to incentivize miners to continue to perform mining activities",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001850391",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-27",
   "accession": "0001214659-26-003899",
   "file": "wtb32026010k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1850391/000121465926003899/wtb32026010k.htm",
   "sha256": "b08a1cd6659227c4dd3c0d6dd3d7ab94f4c81c8a9c43fedfcb68a1607a689143",
   "n_paragraphs": 930,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "etf",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin funds",
   "lane_page": "https://etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "EZBC",
   "issuer": "Franklin Templeton",
   "name": "Franklin Bitcoin ETF",
   "para": 213,
   "hl": "miners may cease expanding processing power or demand high transaction fees",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001992870",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-06-29",
   "accession": "0001140361-26-026744",
   "file": "ef20070486_10k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1992870/000114036126026744/ef20070486_10k.htm",
   "sha256": "61cdd05efcf3381111b6165842b451cbf47ae592c017ddcf159fb1d7d6f743ea",
   "n_paragraphs": 1114,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "MARA",
   "issuer": "MARA Holdings",
   "name": "MARA Holdings, Inc.",
   "para": 270,
   "hl": "may decrease our revenue and could force us to cease mining operations",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001507605",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-02",
   "accession": "0001507605-26-000007",
   "file": "mara-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1507605/000150760526000007/mara-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "57e485abf150197569e00a0b128ce09e59c7c65ca1ed072a89b59a0ffc78b090",
   "n_paragraphs": 1328,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "RIOT",
   "issuer": "Riot Platforms",
   "name": "Riot Platforms, Inc.",
   "para": 230,
   "hl": "we cannot predict whether such fees will increase, or remain at levels, sufficient to offset the decline in block rewards over time",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001167419",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-02",
   "accession": "0001104659-26-022322",
   "file": "riot-20251231x10k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1167419/000110465926022322/riot-20251231x10k.htm",
   "sha256": "f452387f7c3f17f6197816b5003a8ed8b0ac13bed6786ddeeb1cd4d355837e92",
   "n_paragraphs": 1576,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "CORZ",
   "issuer": "Core Scientific",
   "name": "Core Scientific, Inc.",
   "para": 628,
   "hl": "our customers may not have an adequate incentive to continue mining and customers may cease mining operations altogether",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001839341",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-02",
   "accession": "0001628280-26-013305",
   "file": "core-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1839341/000162828026013305/core-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "6e82a29fd6e902f7a0ee6e7132f35630175ff065aae0773e5260fdff2613f386",
   "n_paragraphs": 1769,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "CIFR",
   "issuer": "Cipher Digital",
   "name": "Cipher Digital Inc.",
   "para": 298,
   "hl": "materially reduces mining revenue and profitability",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001819989",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-24",
   "accession": "0001819989-26-000009",
   "file": "cifr-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1819989/000181998926000009/cifr-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "8116bbe1eaa8c2ef7732cb277688e108f7ee0e43fc114435d4e17b6842d8c760",
   "n_paragraphs": 1447,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BITF",
   "issuer": "Bitfarms",
   "name": "Bitfarms Ltd.",
   "para": 372,
   "hl": "could render our Mining operations unprofitable for sustained periods",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001812477",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-31",
   "accession": "0001213900-26-037514",
   "file": "ea0282809-10k_bitfarms.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1812477/000121390026037514/ea0282809-10k_bitfarms.htm",
   "sha256": "a301d38091cdd75376d44faded9fe1c5077c0376f2ba89864bae5a43f98d3dc3",
   "n_paragraphs": 2567,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "CLSK",
   "issuer": "CleanSpark",
   "name": "CleanSpark, Inc.",
   "para": 229,
   "hl": "we may not have an adequate incentive to continue mining and may cease mining operations altogether",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0000827876",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2025-11-25",
   "accession": "0001193125-25-297510",
   "file": "clsk-20250930.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/827876/000119312525297510/clsk-20250930.htm",
   "sha256": "3b6f0719c319f0f566c45732df2c105c770c25e1ffbfdc8278579918c4b0ae9e",
   "n_paragraphs": 1539,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "HUT",
   "issuer": "Hut 8",
   "name": "Hut 8 Corp.",
   "para": 348,
   "hl": "we and American Bitcoin may not have an adequate incentive to continue mining and may decrease or cease our ASIC compute operations",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001964789",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-25",
   "accession": "0001104659-26-019392",
   "file": "hut-20251231x10k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1964789/000110465926019392/hut-20251231x10k.htm",
   "sha256": "54cb25e6bd319da158b2febda92da5f31a73fc20e3b1aa14cb7b6431d8f8fd79",
   "n_paragraphs": 1781,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "ABTC",
   "issuer": "American Bitcoin",
   "name": "American Bitcoin Corp.",
   "para": 183,
   "hl": "our ability to achieve profitability becomes more difficult",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001755953",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-27",
   "accession": "0001193125-26-127278",
   "file": "abtc-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1755953/000119312526127278/abtc-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "7541a04edb53ebfb61f91a9f908898dee5d8cd26f329e5aef13a126ffe8bb649",
   "n_paragraphs": 1171,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "SLNH",
   "issuer": "Soluna",
   "name": "Soluna Holdings, Inc.",
   "para": 355,
   "hl": "halvings may reduce our mining revenue and profitability",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0000064463",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-30",
   "accession": "0001628280-26-021847",
   "file": "slnh-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/64463/000162828026021847/slnh-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "a77c6ca0c4fed4cafc29e7c451fd9c3ac7f274594c067e18f473bccbff3bd1e7",
   "n_paragraphs": 1889,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "HIVE",
   "issuer": "HIVE Digital",
   "name": "HIVE Digital Technologies Ltd.",
   "para": 366,
   "hl": "a future halving event may render the Company unprofitable and unable to continue as a going concern",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001720424",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-06-02",
   "accession": "0001062993-26-002973",
   "file": "form10k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1720424/000106299326002973/form10k.htm",
   "sha256": "a38b24d030854b3db94008adc14e3bf53c951052f205548daaed9d27a655d13f",
   "n_paragraphs": 1805,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "DGXX",
   "issuer": "Digi Power X",
   "name": "Digi Power X Inc.",
   "para": 242,
   "hl": "a future halving event may render the Corporation’s bitcoin mining operations to be unprofitable",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001854368",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-31",
   "accession": "0001213900-26-037677",
   "file": "ea0283764-10k_digipower.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1854368/000121390026037677/ea0283764-10k_digipower.htm",
   "sha256": "c41589e3c4e86fbc73d0eb29b575f1f0fd441e7a666a19f06579b61ce7127fd6",
   "n_paragraphs": 1283,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "VIP",
   "issuer": "Greenidge",
   "name": "Greenidge Generation Holdings Inc.",
   "para": 414,
   "hl": "Each successive halving reduces our revenue per block solved",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001844971",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-31",
   "accession": "0001844971-26-000011",
   "file": "gree-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1844971/000184497126000011/gree-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "78302fd0266dbccf35205a826267b95669c089395700e2769790bc88c44b027c",
   "n_paragraphs": 1287,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BGDE",
   "issuer": "Mawson",
   "name": "Mawson Infrastructure Group Inc.",
   "para": 241,
   "hl": "As block rewards decline over time, mining economics are expected to become increasingly dependent on transaction fees",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001218683",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-31",
   "accession": "0001213900-26-037417",
   "file": "ea0281617-10k_mawson.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1218683/000121390026037417/ea0281617-10k_mawson.htm",
   "sha256": "e10a6c865d1d042c62cdaaac0c2471a8cee7a9cb77838f6dc6e33286049e9c28",
   "n_paragraphs": 1123,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "PWCM",
   "issuer": "LM Funding",
   "name": "LM Funding America, Inc.",
   "para": 295,
   "hl": "we may not have an adequate incentive to continue mining and may cease mining operations altogether",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001640384",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-31",
   "accession": "0001193125-26-133333",
   "file": "lmfa-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1640384/000119312526133333/lmfa-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "c5f8a6114f3f5d8e9f13e8555895af4c908194cc977d9c8fd5b4b3f363c7bce9",
   "n_paragraphs": 1290,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "DRK",
   "issuer": "Sphere 3D",
   "name": "Sphere 3D Corp.",
   "para": 205,
   "hl": "the revenue we earn from our Bitcoin mining operations would see a decrease",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001591956",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-27",
   "accession": "0001591956-26-000004",
   "file": "any-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1591956/000159195626000004/any-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "83b10cb5f7a2902d5466482a1ba869ce4aed1f92f0f4b1142424eb0d4e1c2aea",
   "n_paragraphs": 687,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "INVU",
   "issuer": "Investview",
   "name": "Investview, Inc.",
   "para": 170,
   "hl": "our revenue would decrease substantially upon the next Halving",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0000862651",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-31",
   "accession": "0001493152-26-014042",
   "file": "form10-k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/862651/000149315226014042/form10-k.htm",
   "sha256": "1f0baf3024175fb06bbccf5a15db106a827fb7326c91e8b98484b3739a3109d5",
   "n_paragraphs": 965,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "OLB",
   "issuer": "OLB Group",
   "name": "The OLB Group, Inc.",
   "para": 277,
   "hl": "the Bitcoin protocol halves mining rewards approximately every four years, reducing the potential earnings for miners",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001314196",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-04-01",
   "accession": "0001213900-26-037906",
   "file": "ea0282959-10k_olbgroup.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1314196/000121390026037906/ea0282959-10k_olbgroup.htm",
   "sha256": "89614b31436f121014278b4b59775137810fa9a31a03b9a817bb4042f71dae00",
   "n_paragraphs": 1022,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "MGTI",
   "issuer": "MGT Capital",
   "name": "MGT Capital Investments, Inc.",
   "para": 72,
   "hl": "the revenue we earn from our mining operations will see a corresponding decrease",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001001601",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-17",
   "accession": "0001493152-26-010453",
   "file": "form10-k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1001601/000149315226010453/form10-k.htm",
   "sha256": "db87d1c1d00369a3f37e58e8c8404b05cf1407e824c1c6fafa1fffff72e5fcbd",
   "n_paragraphs": 542,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "miners",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin miners",
   "lane_page": "https://miner-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "WULF",
   "issuer": "TeraWulf",
   "name": "TeraWulf Inc.",
   "para": 223,
   "hl": "there is no guarantee that the price change will be favorable or would compensate for the reduction in mining rewards",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001083301",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-27",
   "accession": "0001083301-26-000031",
   "file": "wulf-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1083301/000108330126000031/wulf-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "2d688783463cb00e0d9530c053fbe04427a676a17731814a7f909b0a6ba0026a",
   "n_paragraphs": 1263,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/miner-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "treasuries",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin treasury companies",
   "lane_page": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "MSTR",
   "issuer": "Strategy",
   "name": "Strategy Inc",
   "para": 274,
   "hl": "further reductions in mining rewards of bitcoin, including due to block reward halving events, which are programmed events that occur approximately every four years (the most recent of which occurred in April 2024) that reduce the block reward earned by “miners” who validate bitcoin transactions, or increases in the costs associated with bitcoin mining, including increases in electricity costs and hardware and software used in mining, or new or enhanced regulation or taxation of bitcoin mining, which could further increase the costs associated with bitcoin mining, any of which may cause a decline in support for the Bitcoin network",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001050446",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-19",
   "accession": "0001050446-26-000020",
   "file": "mstr-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1050446/000105044626000020/mstr-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "f8bdfc4540033f3cbf68917e01350290901081dd0fd3d62444af86b938f6345c",
   "n_paragraphs": 1715,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/treasury-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "treasuries",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin treasury companies",
   "lane_page": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "DJT",
   "issuer": "Trump Media & Technology Group",
   "name": "Trump Media & Technology Group Corp.",
   "para": 536,
   "hl": "further reductions in mining rewards of bitcoin, including due to block reward halving events, which are programmed events that occur approximately every four years (the most recent of which occurred in April 2024) that reduce the block reward earned by “miners” who validate bitcoin transactions, or increases in the costs associated with bitcoin mining, including increases in electricity costs and hardware and software used in mining, or new or enhanced regulation or taxation of bitcoin mining, which could further increase the costs associated with bitcoin mining, any of which may cause a decline in support for the Bitcoin network",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001849635",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-27",
   "accession": "0001140361-26-007174",
   "file": "ef20062365_10k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1849635/000114036126007174/ef20062365_10k.htm",
   "sha256": "8a3ec79aae275f214b670b5f430fa7f73682e03ef9ebea98ff67c374acc9b8c8",
   "n_paragraphs": 1685,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/treasury-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "treasuries",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin treasury companies",
   "lane_page": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "XXI",
   "issuer": "Twenty One Capital",
   "name": "Twenty One Capital, Inc.",
   "para": 423,
   "hl": "further reductions in mining rewards of Bitcoin, including due to block reward halving events, which are events that occur after a specific period of time (the most recent of which occurred in April 2024) that reduce the block reward earned by “miners” who validate Bitcoin transactions, or increases in the costs associated with Bitcoin mining, including increases in electricity costs and hardware and software used in mining, or new or enhanced regulation or taxation of Bitcoin mining, which could further increase the costs associated with Bitcoin mining, any of which may cause a decline in support for the Bitcoin network",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0002070457",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-31",
   "accession": "0001213900-26-037460",
   "file": "ea0280065-10k_twenty.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2070457/000121390026037460/ea0280065-10k_twenty.htm",
   "sha256": "510368fe1793b8e2b470231c4837ae24e904fa7ec7a36eb1ddab6c7ea0098e1b",
   "n_paragraphs": 1410,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/treasury-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "treasuries",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin treasury companies",
   "lane_page": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "ASST",
   "issuer": "Strive",
   "name": "Strive, Inc.",
   "para": 203,
   "hl": "further reductions in mining rewards of bitcoin, including due to block reward \"halving\" events, which are events that occur after a specific period of time (the most recent of which occurred in April 2024) that either reduce the block reward earned by “miners” who validate bitcoin transactions, or increase the costs associated with bitcoin mining, including increases in electricity costs and hardware and software used in mining, or new or enhanced regulation or taxation of bitcoin mining, which could further increase the costs associated with bitcoin mining, any of which may cause a decline in support for the bitcoin network",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001920406",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-19",
   "accession": "0001628280-26-019879",
   "file": "asst-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1920406/000162828026019879/asst-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "6790ea3df369356518e9f1369a6dac520464dcf24b7edbd515f5e646add801e2",
   "n_paragraphs": 1378,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/treasury-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "treasuries",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin treasury companies",
   "lane_page": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "NAKA",
   "issuer": "Nakamoto",
   "name": "Nakamoto Inc.",
   "para": 230,
   "hl": "further reductions in mining rewards of Bitcoin, including reductions due to block reward halving events, which are events that occur after a specific period of time that reduce the block reward earned by “miners” who validate Bitcoin transactions (the most recent reduction in mining rewards occurred in April 2024), which may cause a decline in support for the Bitcoin network",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001946573",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-30",
   "accession": "0001493152-26-013601",
   "file": "form10-k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1946573/000149315226013601/form10-k.htm",
   "sha256": "7f8b99cbbcd1ad21c43bf1f2d3de39775dac5acd8f0f79e9bc578c0e3f6be3ec",
   "n_paragraphs": 1598,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/treasury-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "treasuries",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin treasury companies",
   "lane_page": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BRR",
   "issuer": "ProCap Financial",
   "name": "ProCap Financial, Inc.",
   "para": 296,
   "hl": "further reductions in mining rewards of Bitcoin, including due to block reward halving events, which are events that occur after a specific period of time that reduce the block reward earned by “miners” who validate Bitcoin transactions, or increases in the costs associated with Bitcoin mining, including increases in electricity costs and hardware and software used in mining, or new or enhanced regulation or taxation of Bitcoin mining, which could further increase the costs associated with Bitcoin mining, any of which may cause a decline in support for the Bitcoin network",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0002076163",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-18",
   "accession": "0001493152-26-007352",
   "file": "form10-k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2076163/000149315226007352/form10-k.htm",
   "sha256": "b01bbacaa89652e34027ff48bfe13072153a34205d995f9e5c4fb2aedfb386a5",
   "n_paragraphs": 1139,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/treasury-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "treasuries",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin treasury companies",
   "lane_page": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "ANGX",
   "issuer": "Angel Studios",
   "name": "Angel Studios, Inc.",
   "para": 331,
   "hl": "further reductions in mining rewards of bitcoin, including due to block reward halving events, which are events that occur after a specific period of time (the most recent of which occurred in April 2024) that reduce the block reward earned by “miners” who validate bitcoin transactions, or increases in the costs associated with bitcoin mining, including increases in electricity costs and hardware and software used in mining, or new or enhanced regulation or taxation of bitcoin mining, which could further increase the costs associated with bitcoin mining, any of which may cause a decline in support for the bitcoin network",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001865200",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-12",
   "accession": "0001865200-26-000020",
   "file": "angx-20251231x10k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1865200/000186520026000020/angx-20251231x10k.htm",
   "sha256": "1f33b6a047b49078949353dc63d1c44394de5b545fa56d02a5dca1c90305cf68",
   "n_paragraphs": 1148,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/treasury-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "treasuries",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin treasury companies",
   "lane_page": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "LVO",
   "issuer": "LiveOne",
   "name": "LiveOne, Inc.",
   "para": 756,
   "hl": "further reductions in mining rewards of bitcoin, including block reward halving events, which are events that occur after a specific period of time that reduce the block reward earned by “miners” who validate bitcoin transactions, or increases in the costs associated with bitcoin mining, including increases in electricity costs and hardware and software used in mining, that may cause a decline in support for the bitcoin network",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001491419",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-06-29",
   "accession": "0001437749-26-021987",
   "file": "lvo20260331_10k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1491419/000143774926021987/lvo20260331_10k.htm",
   "sha256": "add66cf22109b950cf442ea4c0c171f6f3fcc7e21629bcae17264c825b4edcee",
   "n_paragraphs": 1570,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/treasury-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "treasuries",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin treasury companies",
   "lane_page": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "ATHR",
   "issuer": "Aether Holdings",
   "name": "Aether Holdings, Inc.",
   "para": 399,
   "hl": "further reductions in mining rewards of bitcoin, including block reward halving events, which are events that occur after a specific period of time that reduce the block reward earned by “miners” who validate bitcoin transactions, or increases in the costs associated with bitcoin mining, including increases in electricity costs and hardware and software used in mining, that may cause a decline in support for the Bitcoin network",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0002026353",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2025-12-17",
   "accession": "0001493152-25-028195",
   "file": "form10-k.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2026353/000149315225028195/form10-k.htm",
   "sha256": "c73c37713e5ec2a8068bd73c8016a466027b924f747acc1212abe7918bc390f0",
   "n_paragraphs": 1107,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/treasury-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "treasuries",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin treasury companies",
   "lane_page": "https://treasury-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "SILO",
   "issuer": "Silo Pharma",
   "name": "Silo Pharma, Inc.",
   "para": 436,
   "hl": "further reductions in mining rewards of digital assets, including block reward halving events, which are events that occur after a specific period of time that reduce the block reward earned by “miners” who validate digital assets transactions, or increases in the costs associated with Bitcoin mining, including increases in electricity costs and hardware and software used in mining, that may cause a decline in support for the Digital Asset networks",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001514183",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-27",
   "accession": "0001213900-26-035576",
   "file": "ea0282804-10k_silo.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1514183/000121390026035576/ea0282804-10k_silo.htm",
   "sha256": "7238aa30418db0b5d944ebafbaa3486622fbf444eb51d23731c2b33bcc8c9bb3",
   "n_paragraphs": 1288,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/treasury-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "exchanges",
   "shelf": "Exchanges and custodians",
   "lane_page": "https://exchange-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "EXOD",
   "issuer": "Exodus",
   "name": "Exodus Movement, Inc.",
   "para": 593,
   "hl": "In approximately 2140, new Bitcoin tokens will no longer be awarded for adding a new block and miners will only have transaction fees to incentivize them",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001821534",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-11",
   "accession": "0001821534-26-000009",
   "file": "exod-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1821534/000182153426000009/exod-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "da3b370b4d2ee8d6a2f03358a8b7b410500523b15fdee285e677590ea4d2e2d5",
   "n_paragraphs": 1574,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/exchange-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "exchanges",
   "shelf": "Exchanges and custodians",
   "lane_page": "https://exchange-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "COIN",
   "issuer": "Coinbase",
   "name": "Coinbase Global, Inc.",
   "para": 284,
   "hl": "a crypto network’s security and speed may be adversely affected, increasing the likelihood of a malicious attack",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001679788",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-02-12",
   "accession": "0001679788-26-000015",
   "file": "coin-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1679788/000167978826000015/coin-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "cbe1e2c73bf6e9609afded3e95c338bcb1b92d0ea055fe3da5906e0c4c3805c9",
   "n_paragraphs": 1734,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/exchange-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "exchanges",
   "shelf": "Exchanges and custodians",
   "lane_page": "https://exchange-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "GEMI",
   "issuer": "Gemini",
   "name": "Gemini Space Station, Inc.",
   "para": 227,
   "hl": "a digital asset’s network’s security and speed may be adversely affected, increasing the likelihood of a malicious attack",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0002055592",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-31",
   "accession": "0002055592-26-000026",
   "file": "gemi-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2055592/000205559226000026/gemi-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "813e8c1392c2f9cef0e6d69195daf95404b5ca594840ae930fd08780372012c5",
   "n_paragraphs": 2247,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/exchange-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "exchanges",
   "shelf": "Exchanges and custodians",
   "lane_page": "https://exchange-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "FIGR",
   "issuer": "Figure",
   "name": "Figure Technology Solutions, Inc.",
   "para": 272,
   "hl": "a digital asset network’s security and speed may be adversely affected, increasing the likelihood of a malicious attack",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0002064124",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-16",
   "accession": "0002064124-26-000009",
   "file": "figr-20251231.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2064124/000206412426000009/figr-20251231.htm",
   "sha256": "e9dc563dcf00ec1b2d53e0cabc63365e08c879292e31133a69e8d49083ce3d06",
   "n_paragraphs": 2329,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/exchange-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "exchanges",
   "shelf": "Exchanges and custodians",
   "lane_page": "https://exchange-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BTGO",
   "issuer": "BitGo",
   "name": "BitGo Holdings, Inc.",
   "para": 295,
   "hl": "a digital asset network’s security and speed may be adversely affected, increasing the likelihood of a malicious attack",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001740604",
   "form": "10-K",
   "date": "2026-03-27",
   "accession": "0001740604-26-000020",
   "file": "btgo-form10xk.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1740604/000174060426000020/btgo-form10xk.htm",
   "sha256": "08cface640b9a465a98b49257270030728d9765cab6a382b51aa09fb412de382",
   "n_paragraphs": 2156,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/exchange-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "futures-etfs",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin futures funds",
   "lane_page": "https://futures-etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BITO",
   "issuer": "ProShares",
   "name": "ProShares Bitcoin ETF",
   "para": 12367,
   "hl": "If this compensation is not sufficient to incentivize miners to process transactions, the confirmation process for transactions may slow and the Bitcoin Network may become more vulnerable to malicious actors",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001174610",
   "form": "485BPOS",
   "date": "2025-09-23",
   "accession": "0001193125-25-213457",
   "file": "f42758d1.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1174610/000119312525213457/f42758d1.htm",
   "sha256": "4d61683ae8c919c3821ae445065a77ccb125cad893b143a9fe0b4120cd9ad9b1",
   "n_paragraphs": 17853,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/futures-etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "futures-etfs",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin futures funds",
   "lane_page": "https://futures-etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BITI",
   "issuer": "ProShares",
   "name": "ProShares Short Bitcoin ETF",
   "para": 11784,
   "hl": "If this compensation is not sufficient to incentivize miners to process transactions, the confirmation process for transactions may slow and the Bitcoin Network may become more vulnerable to malicious actors",
   "primary": "BITO",
   "cik": "0001174610",
   "form": "485BPOS",
   "date": "2025-09-23",
   "accession": "0001193125-25-213457",
   "file": "f42758d1.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1174610/000119312525213457/f42758d1.htm",
   "sha256": "4d61683ae8c919c3821ae445065a77ccb125cad893b143a9fe0b4120cd9ad9b1",
   "n_paragraphs": 17853,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/futures-etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "futures-etfs",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin futures funds",
   "lane_page": "https://futures-etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BTCFX",
   "issuer": "ProFunds",
   "name": "Bitcoin ProFund",
   "para": 7574,
   "hl": "If this compensation is not sufficient to incentivize miners to process transactions, the confirmation process for transactions may slow and the Bitcoin Network may become more vulnerable to malicious actors",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001039803",
   "form": "485BPOS",
   "date": "2025-11-25",
   "accession": "0001193125-25-297644",
   "file": "f43283d1.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1039803/000119312525297644/f43283d1.htm",
   "sha256": "481bc823101970cb818e0005e35ecaa5ba2d0afed25622ccb7fab2d439720692",
   "n_paragraphs": 9878,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/futures-etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "futures-etfs",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin futures funds",
   "lane_page": "https://futures-etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BITIX",
   "issuer": "ProFunds",
   "name": "Short Bitcoin ProFund",
   "para": 7574,
   "hl": "If this compensation is not sufficient to incentivize miners to process transactions, the confirmation process for transactions may slow and the Bitcoin Network may become more vulnerable to malicious actors",
   "primary": "BTCFX",
   "cik": "0001039803",
   "form": "485BPOS",
   "date": "2025-11-25",
   "accession": "0001193125-25-297644",
   "file": "f43283d1.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1039803/000119312525297644/f43283d1.htm",
   "sha256": "481bc823101970cb818e0005e35ecaa5ba2d0afed25622ccb7fab2d439720692",
   "n_paragraphs": 9878,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/futures-etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  },
  {
   "lane": "futures-etfs",
   "shelf": "Bitcoin futures funds",
   "lane_page": "https://futures-etf-risk-factor.pages.dev",
   "tk": "BITX",
   "issuer": "Volatility Shares",
   "name": "2x Bitcoin ETF",
   "para": 91,
   "hl": "Miners may cease expanding processing power to create blocks and verify transactions if they are not adequately compensated",
   "primary": null,
   "cik": "0001884021",
   "form": "485BPOS",
   "date": "2026-06-26",
   "accession": "0001213900-26-072183",
   "file": "ea0295205-01_485bpos.htm",
   "url": "https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1884021/000121390026072183/ea0295205-01_485bpos.htm",
   "sha256": "83fe3254b292d4f42e1192034987deaab201a391d89b0089601b9230d2615348",
   "n_paragraphs": 2456,
   "src_from": "Crypto/NAT/research/futures-etf-risk-factors/page.json + filings.json"
  }
 ]
}
