The film isn't published yet, so this page shows a still from each moment. Times refer to the English cut (v97).Mandarin times are for the Mandarin cut (v100), mapped from its edit timeline; ~ marks a time that is approximate.
0:00Hook40 with a receipt · 54 lines5:36Cold open6 with a receipt · 23 linesI7:18The Bet21 with a receipt · 63 linesII13:40The Champagne8 with a receipt · 21 linesIII15:32The Witnesses22 with a receipt · 53 linesIV21:28The Clock54 with a receipt · 75 linesV29:52The Trap13 with a receipt · 48 linesVI35:44A Different Answer64 with a receipt · 221 lines
Pick a chapter to jump there. Click any line to show that moment. Underlined lines have a receipt; click the label under them to open it.
Hook
0:00 to 5:36 · 54 lines
0:00 to 5:36 · 54 lines
0:00 · zh 0:00
0:03 · zh 0:03
Narrator
Hal Finney, on a mailing list: "As an amusing thought experiment, imagine that Bitcoin is successful...
Exact words · Hal Finney, "Bitcoin v0.1 released" thread, Cryptography Mailing List0:10 · zh 0:10
Narrator
With 20 million coins, that gives each coin a value of about $10 million."
Exact words · Hal Finney, "Bitcoin v0.1 released" thread, Cryptography Mailing List0:15 · zh ~0:15
Narrator
An amusing thought experiment, he called it.
0:18 · zh ~0:18
Narrator
Now it's a keynote.
0:20 · zh 0:20
Michael Saylor
Drive Bitcoin to $10 million a coin, and make Bitcoin a 200 trillion dollar network
Their exact words · the original at 44:530:27 · zh 0:27
Matthew Mežinskis
2040, 2041, '42, could get to 100 trillion in market cap, that magical 100 trillion
Their exact words · the original at 19:160:32 · zh 0:32
Adam Back
basically the dislocation between the Bitcoin future and the fiat present, which is a one to two hundred trillion arbitrage.
Their exact words · the original at 0:020:39 · zh 0:39
Max Keiser
Bitcoin worth 100 trillion, 200 trillion, 300 trillion.
Their exact words · the original at 2:290:43 · zh 0:44
Giovanni Santostasi
testing the theory. We should have a 1 million Bitcoin in 8 years, and then 10 million Bitcoins in 20 years. Thank you.
Their exact words · the original at 19:150:54 · zh 0:54
Michael Saylor
13 million. It could be, it could be a 3 million bear case, it could be a 49 million bull case.
Their exact words · the original at 18:541:00 · zh 1:00
Michael Saylor
They'll be buying it at 10 million a coin or 20 million a coin or 50 million a coin.
Their exact words · the original at 22:181:05 · zh 1:05
to eventually $300, $400, $500 trillion.
Their exact words · the original at 19:281:08 · zh 1:08
Michael Saylor
I expect 21 million coins at a $21 million price in 21 years.
Their view · the original at 22:281:14 · zh ~1:14
Narrator
Bitcoin is kept safe by machines.
1:17 · zh ~1:17
Narrator
The machines get paid.
1:19 · zh ~1:19
1:22 · zh ~1:22
Narrator
Hundreds of trillions of dollars.
Narration paraphrases · Michael Saylor, "The Power of 21" keynote, BTC Prague 2025 (Bitcoin Ma…1:25 · zh ~1:25
Narrator
So who pays to secure it?
1:29 · zh 1:30
Narrator
Hardly anyone asks them.
1:31 · zh 1:32
Narrator
In Naples, someone did: if bitcoin is only a store of value...
1:36 · zh 1:37
Michael Saylor
At what point does that present some type of existential risk to Bitcoin mining activity on the network? Yeah, I don't, there is no existential risk to it. I think that's not something to worry about.
Their view · the original at 40:231:49 · zh 1:49
No matter what the block reward goes to, the network is just getting more secure. It's a one-way ratchet exponentially up forever.
Their exact words · the original at 43:381:59 · zh ~2:00
Narrator
Same man, months later, in writing: "Their subsidy halves every 210,000 blocks, so fees must carry more of the security burden."
Exact words · Michael Saylor, post on X2:09 · zh 2:10
Narrator
Others wave it away.
2:11 · zh 2:12
Pierre Rochard
And so isn't this a problem? And I actually don't think it's a problem.
Their exact words · who said it and where2:16 · zh 2:17
Adam Back
In the security budget, I'm not so worried about it because, you know, Bitcoin price has much more than doubled every 4 years, which is the halving cycle.
Their view · the original at 40:292:24 · zh 2:25
Dan Held
A quick question, what's the appropriate level of security spend? They're like, well, I don't know. So I'm like, well, you can't call it broken if you don't know what the appropriate level should be.
Their exact words · the original at 50:442:31 · zh 2:32
Moderator
If you believe Bitcoin will have some kind of issue in the longer term, based on the security budget, please raise your hand now. So I'm gonna eyeball that at maybe 5%. Hands up if you believe there is not a long-term security budget debate. I'm eyeballing that at about 85%.
Their exact words · who said it and where2:50 · zh 2:51
Narrator
"Your inherent desire for human intervention at every turn is exactly what bitcoin solved, please just shut up."
Exact words · Dylan LeClair, post on X2:58 · zh 2:59
Colin Harper and Paul Sztorc
On a scale of 1 to 10. How concerned are you for that, the idea that once the subsidy is diminished, there won't be enough transaction fees to furnish Bitcoin mining? I would say an 8.
Their view · the original at 1:413:09 · zh 3:10
Narrator
Press a little harder.
3:12 · zh 3:12
PBJ
And we don't know what the security budget needs to be. Like, does it need to be $50 billion a year? Does it need to be $100 billion a year? $200 billion a year? We don't know.
Their exact words · the original at 16:273:23 · zh 3:24
Hasu
So there clearly is a Goldilocks zone somewhere, but we really don't know where it is.
Their exact words · the original at 11:363:29 · zh 3:30
Sam Wouters
We honestly just don't know how much do we actually need to fend off all of these potential attacks.
Their exact words · the original at 35:123:34 · zh 3:35
The “Jordan McKinney” channel
We don't know how much we need sufficiently high amount daily spend that would deter that kind of attacker, we don't know.
Their exact words · the original at 38:313:44 · zh 3:45
Dan Held
We don't know what an appropriate level of blockchain security spend should be. We don't know if that's 1 billion, 5 billion, 10 billion, or 100 billion.
Their exact words · the original at 41:363:52 · zh 3:53
Jimmy Song
Is it four halvings from now, eight halvings from now, 15 halvings from now? We, no one really knows.
Their exact words · the original at 10:253:57 · zh 3:58
Jameson Lopp
and this is ultimately the question no one can really answer. The only way that we can find out is by building it, by putting the functionality out.
Their exact words · the original at 2:464:06 · zh 4:07
Michael Saylor
to $30 a transaction to $300 a transaction to $3,000 to $30,000 to $300,000.
Their exact words · the original at 2:004:12 · zh 4:13
Jimmy Song
Second, the fee markets have developed in the past, at least for short periods of time. There's no reason to believe that they won't continue to develop.
Their exact words · the original at 10:464:20 · zh 4:21
PBJ
That's why I'd call it like a flawed design, but I think it'll work out.
Their view · the original at 19:474:24 · zh 4:24
Mike Casey
If I can jump in, the problem I think is because of the halvings, it's basically we're a frog in a boiling pot of water and the temperature is going up really slowly, really slowly, really slowly, and so nobody's concerned about the fee market right now because there's a subsidy.
Their view · the original at 12:354:41 · zh 4:42
Paul Sztorc
And everybody assumes, oh, OK. Well, if the price doubles, and the Bitcoin subsidy halves, well, that's net net. Everything's even. A lot of people believe that. But I think all four of us know that that's not true. take out a piece of paper and start multiplying, and you'll see that doesn't work.
Their view · the original at 12:534:59 · zh 5:00
Narrator
Saylor's price.
5:01 · zh 5:02
Narrator
Pay what Bitcoin pays today, about a dollar a year on every hundred: over four trillion dollars a year.
Our calculation · the data and the math5:08 · zh 5:09
5:12 · zh 5:13
Narrator
The rest comes from fees.
5:14 · zh 5:15
5:16 · zh 5:17
Narrator
Every block.
5:17 · zh 5:18
Narrator
Four bitcoin in fees alone, more than the whole reward today.
Our calculation · the data and the math5:21 · zh 5:22
5:24 · zh 5:25
Narrator
They can give you a price, twenty-one years out.
Narration paraphrases · Michael Saylor, "The Power of 21" keynote, BTC Prague 2025 (Bitcoin Ma…5:28 · zh 5:28
Narrator
Ask what pays to keep it safe, and you get a shrug, a hope, or a fee almost nobody could pay.
Cold open
5:36 to 7:18 · 23 lines
5:36 to 7:18 · 23 lines
5:47 · zh ~5:49
Narrator
In the warnings it files with regulators, the world's biggest Bitcoin fund says this.
5:52 · zh ~5:55
Narrator
The reduction in mining rewards could jeopardize the security of the Bitcoin network.
Narration paraphrases · BlackRock's 10-K, paragraph 2685:58 · zh ~6:02
Narrator
It isn't alone.
5:59 · zh ~6:03
6:03 · zh ~6:08
Narrator
The reason is written into Bitcoin itself.
6:06 · zh ~6:11
Narrator
The pay for the machines that keep it safe is cut in half, every four years.
Our calculation · the data and the math6:11 · zh ~6:17
Narrator
What happens when someone can pay a network's guards more than the network does?
6:17 · zh ~6:24
Narrator
It has already happened.
6:19 · zh ~6:26
Narrator
In August 2025, a crypto project announced it had taken control of a cryptocurrency.
Narration paraphrases · Qubic, post on X (@_Qubic_), 12 Aug 20256:26 · zh ~6:34
Narrator
It hadn't hacked anything.
6:27 · zh ~6:36
Narrator
It had paid.
6:29 · zh ~6:37
Narrator
The currency was Monero.
6:31 · zh ~6:40
Narrator
Arguably the most famous privacy coin in existence.
6:35 · zh ~6:44
Narrator
The project, Qubic, had offered the machines that keep Monero safe a better deal: by its own account, up to three times the pay.
Narration paraphrases · Qubic, "Epoch 172 Recap - The Monero Experiment"6:43 · zh ~6:54
Narrator
The machines came.
6:45 · zh ~6:55
Narrator
With more than half of them, Qubic said, it rewrote part of Monero's recent history.
Narration paraphrases · Qubic, "Qubic Performs 51% Monero Network Takeover Demonstration" (blo…6:51 · zh ~7:02
Narrator
Kraken, one of the biggest crypto exchanges, stopped accepting Monero deposits until it could trust the network again.
6:58 · zh ~7:11
Narrator
Nobody broke the code.
7:00 · zh ~7:13
Narrator
Someone simply paid the guards more than the network did.
7:04 · zh ~7:18
Narrator
Bitcoin pays guards like those.
7:07 · zh ~7:21
Narrator
Millions of people's savings, public companies, Wall Street funds, even governments now count on them.
7:14 · zh ~7:29
Narrator
Most of that pay is scheduled to run out.
7:16 · zh ~7:32
Narrator
What replaces it was never settled.
I · The Bet
7:18 to 13:40 · 63 lines
7:18 to 13:40 · 63 lines
7:24 · zh ~7:40
Narrator
Bitcoin is a record of who owns what.
7:27 · zh ~7:44
Narrator
No bank keeps it.
7:29 · zh ~7:46
Narrator
Instead, machines all over the world compete to add each new page, called a block.
7:35 · zh ~7:53
Narrator
The people who run them are called miners, and each winner is paid a reward: brand-new bitcoin.
7:42 · zh ~8:01
Narrator
To cheat, to rewrite the record, you'd need more machines than everyone else combined.
7:47 · zh ~8:07
Narrator
The more Bitcoin pays, the more machines there are, and the more cheating costs.
7:53 · zh ~8:13
Narrator
That pay is Bitcoin's security budget.
7:56 · zh ~8:17
Eric Budish
The system is as secure as the amount of computing power maintaining it right now.
Their exact words · the original at 10:208:02 · zh ~8:24
8:06 · zh ~8:28
Narrator
It's called the halving.
8:08 · zh ~8:30
8:10 · zh ~8:33
Narrator
It's how Bitcoin keeps its most famous promise: only 21 million, ever.
Narration paraphrases · Bitcoin Mining 101 with Harry Sudock, The Peter McCormack Show8:16 · zh ~8:40
Narrator
So Bitcoin makes two promises.
8:18 · zh ~8:42
Narrator
It will be scarce, and it will be safe: secure enough that nobody can rewrite it.
8:24 · zh ~8:49
Narrator
The halving keeps the first, by cutting the pay for the second.
8:28 · zh 8:54
Narrator
Everyone remembers the first promise.
8:30 · zh 8:56
Narrator
But it's the second that gives the first its value.
8:34 · zh 9:00
Win Ko Ko Aung
And then they freeze my bank account along with other prominent, you know, activists, 95% of my fiat savings, and all my fiat savings, I will see 100% of my fiat savings, 95% of my entire wealth, And you stay with the Bitcoin and the crypto. but they cannot touch about it.
Their exact words · the original at 15:208:55 · zh 9:20
Chrystia Freeland
If your truck is being used in these protests, your corporate accounts will be frozen. The insurance on your vehicle will be suspended. The consequences are real and they will bite.
Their exact words · the original at 1:329:13 · zh 9:39
Narrator
Years later, a European political movement: "URGENT: Our bank has cut us off from our own money.
Exact words · DiEM25, post on X9:21 · zh 9:47
9:23 · zh 9:48
Narrator
Money someone else can switch off.
9:25 · zh 9:51
Narrator
Why would anyone pay for a number on a screen?
9:29 · zh 9:54
Narrator
Because nobody can make more.
9:31 · zh 9:57
Narrator
Nobody can block your payment.
9:33 · zh 9:59
Narrator
Nobody can take it back.
9:35 · zh 10:01
Michael Saylor
It is secured by physics, by energy. And if you want to create a scarcity, if you want to create a global commodity that's a scarcity, that can be used as a capital base, you're going to want to use physics to secure it.
Their exact words · the original at 22:399:49 · zh 10:15
Narrator
Be careful here.
9:50 · zh 10:16
Narrator
The 21 million is a rule.
Narration paraphrases · Bitcoin Mining 101 with Harry Sudock, The Peter McCormack Show9:53 · zh 10:18
Narrator
Every computer checking the record, called a node, rejects a block that breaks it.
9:58 · zh 10:24
Narrator
No attacker can print past the cap, or move your coins without your keys.
10:03 · zh 10:29
Narrator
What the machines' work protects is the record.
10:06 · zh 10:32
Narrator
Get enough of them, and you can take back your own payments, and choose whose payments get in.
10:12 · zh 10:38
Narrator
Without an honest majority of miners, Coinbase wrote in 2019, a chain "breaks several core guarantees of the Bitcoin protocol, including the irreversibility of transactions."
Exact words · Ethereum Classic (ETC) is currently being 51% attacked, Coinbase blog …10:24 · zh 10:50
Narrator
The cap still holds.
10:26 · zh 10:51
Narrator
The trust doesn't.
10:27 · zh 10:53
Narrator
It happened to Ethereum Classic: exchanges froze deposits.
10:32 · zh 10:58
Nate Martin
During the attack, the offending miner managed to double spend $5.6 million dollars worth of ETC after spending only $200,000 to acquire the hash power. for the attack.
Their exact words · the original at 0:1610:44 · zh 11:09
Narrator
Then Monero.
10:45 · zh 11:11
Bitcoin.com host
Kraken halted Monero deposits after this and jacked up confirmation requirements to 720 blocks.
Their exact words · the original at 1:1210:52 · zh 11:18
Narrator
Coins you can't deposit are coins you can't sell.
10:56 · zh 11:22
Narrator
Those small coins survived a bad week.
10:59 · zh 11:25
Narrator
They weren't holding the world's savings.
11:01 · zh 11:27
Narrator
Nobody moves a trillion dollars onto a record that can be rewritten.
11:05 · zh 11:31
Narrator
A cap on a record nobody trusts is just a number.
11:09 · zh 11:35
Paul Sztorc
and if the network doesn't have proof of work, then all of this blockchain stuff was just kind of a waste of time because it doesn't actually do anything.
Their exact words · the original at 2:3611:16 · zh 11:42
Lyn Alden
And that's why many people view Bitcoin as money, but they don't view these other derivatives as money, because they have far less security, far less hash rate, far higher probability of 51% attacks occurring.
Their exact words · the original at 39:0511:27 · zh 11:52
Narrator
So the guarantee has to keep up with what it guards.
11:30 · zh 11:56
Eric Budish
To secure the system against a billion-dollar attack costs 1,000 times more than to secure the system against a million-dollar attack.
Their exact words · the original at 25:4011:39 · zh 12:04
Dan Held
What is an appropriate level to be able to survive a state level attack? You're right, we don't know. What we do know is that in the low billions is probably too little. The US defense budget is half a trillion a year. So I think we can concretely say that like we do not have enough security spend right now to survive a state level attack.
Their view · the original at 1:02:5811:58 · zh 12:24
Mike Casey
The more expensive Bitcoin gets, the more value it has, the more attractive target it is for attack. So, it actually does not help. Number go up does not help the problem.
Their exact words · the original at 13:3012:08 · zh 12:34
Dan Held
Bitcoin's security spend has historically been much lower back in time, and it wasn't 51% attacked. So technically, lower levels of security spend, in the Bitcoin network has been okay. But that doesn't necessarily mean that the same security spend number would be appropriate in the future.
Their exact words · the original at 50:1512:25 · zh 12:50
Narrator
Censorship-resistant money.
12:27 · zh 12:53
Narrator
True scarcity.
12:29 · zh 12:54
Narrator
Both need a Bitcoin secured enough, in proportion to what it holds.
12:33 · zh 12:59
PBJ
Who should pay for the security budget? Because like if someone bought 10 years ago, self-custodied, mined their Bitcoin and haven't just hodl, don't touch it, don't use Bitcoin at all beyond that, just hodling, right? Well, they paid back then, but there's no ongoing cost to them, and yet they benefit from everyone else paying fees, because it just stacks the proof of work on top of their block, but they're not paying for it. So, it's the current transactors are paying for security for everyone.
Their exact words · the original at 9:5413:08 · zh 13:34
Narrator
No security, no value.
13:11 · zh 13:36
Narrator
So security is worth paying for.
13:14 · zh 13:39
Narrator
And the halving keeps cutting that pay.
13:17 · zh ~13:43
Narrator
Bitcoin's creator, known only as Satoshi Nakamoto, saw this coming.
13:22 · zh ~13:48
Narrator
In 2008, he wrote down what would pay the machines instead: fees, the small charges people pay to send bitcoin.
Narration paraphrases · Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, section 6, "Incentive"13:30 · zh ~13:57
Narrator
In 2010, he put a timeline on it: In a few decades when the reward gets too small, the transaction fee will become the main compensation.
Exact words · Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcointalk.org forum post13:39 · zh ~14:07
Narrator
That was the bet.
II · The Champagne
13:40 to 15:32 · 21 lines
13:40 to 15:32 · 21 lines
13:45 · zh ~14:13
Narrator
For years, nobody could test the bet.
13:48 · zh ~14:16
Narrator
Then, in December 2017, it looked like it was paying off.
Narration paraphrases · Fees as a share of the block reward, by UTC day (peak day 22 Dec 2017)…13:53 · zh ~14:21
Narrator
Bitcoin was so busy that, for a few days, fees nearly matched the reward itself.
13:58 · zh ~14:27
Narrator
One of Bitcoin's leading engineers wrote to his colleagues to celebrate.
Narration paraphrases · Gregory Maxwell, bitcoin-dev mailing list14:02 · zh ~14:32
Narrator
He wrote that on the 21st of December, and said that he was pulling out the champagne.
Narration paraphrases · Gregory Maxwell, bitcoin-dev mailing list14:10 · zh ~14:40
Narrator
Fees peaked the next day.
14:12 · zh ~14:42
14:14 · zh ~14:44
Narrator
Then gone.
14:17 · zh ~14:47
Narrator
It happened again in 2023 and 2024, during booms in digital collectibles.
Narration paraphrases · Fees as a share of the block reward, by UTC day (peak days 8 May 2023 …14:23 · zh ~14:53
Narrator
Each time, the fees faded with the boom.
14:26 · zh ~14:57
Narrator
Matt Crosby, research director at LookIntoBitcoin, on why the fees don't come back:
14:32 · zh ~15:03
Matt Crosby
But the more people are seeing Bitcoin as a treasury asset, a reserve asset, something that you don't spend, it's something to save and not actually use. The fewer transaction fees are actually generated.
Their exact words · the original at 25:1614:45 · zh ~15:17
James O'Beirne
if you had come to me in 2017 and said, hey, guess what? You know, Bitcoin is at 84k. It's 2025. What do you think fee rates look like? I'd say, oh, yeah, they're like astronomical.
Their exact words · the original at 1:09:5314:57 · zh ~15:30
Narrator
It's just, you know, 300 sats per vbyte or whatever.
Exact words · James O'Beirne on Supply Shock, "What's the Problem With Bitcoin?"15:00 · zh ~15:34
Narrator
And we're really on our way to having a replacement for the security budget that isn't the block subsidy.
15:07 · zh ~15:41
Narrator
Today, fees are less than one percent of what the machines earn.
Our calculation · the data and the math15:12 · zh ~15:46
Narrator
Satoshi expected fees to become the main way the machines get paid.
15:15 · zh ~15:50
Narrator
But when fees do climb, many Bitcoiners don't celebrate.
15:19 · zh ~15:54
Narrator
They call the transactions spam, and complain that Bitcoin costs too much to use.
15:25 · zh ~16:01
Narrator
Bitcoin needs fees high enough to pay its guards.
15:28 · zh ~16:04
Narrator
The people using it want them low.
III · The Witnesses
15:32 to 21:28 · 53 lines
15:32 to 21:28 · 53 lines
15:38 · zh ~16:14
Narrator
So the reward keeps shrinking, and the fees have not replaced it.
15:42 · zh 16:19
Daniel Jonsson
And this has been the biggest question mark, what happens when the block rewards go away? And we've always pointed to the fees, but then everybody looks at fees and goes, well, they're negligible.
Their exact words · the original at 18:4915:54 · zh ~16:31
Narrator
And a lot now depends on those guards: millions of people's savings, public companies, Wall Street funds, even governments.
16:03 · zh ~16:40
Neha Narula
Things seem to be working okay now. You don't hear about double spend attacks. But how do we know that they will continue to work in the future?
Their exact words · the original at 3:3016:11 · zh ~16:48
Narrator
Again, I think there's been maybe insufficient
16:13 · zh ~16:50
16:16 · zh ~16:54
Arvind Narayanan
Bitcoin's game theoretic stability could break down as this block reward dwindles and goes towards zero.
Their exact words · the original at 33:0516:23 · zh ~17:01
Pieter Wuille
There's dwindling subsidy, I think, is a big one in like medium, long term. I think very few... I don't think we know what the game theory will say there.
Their view · the original at 1:24:2316:40 · zh ~17:18
Peter Todd
the assumption is, well, we'll just go to the extreme opposite, and we'll just hope it works. And no other cryptocurrency has ever actually survived this transition
Their exact words · the original at 7:5516:49 · zh 17:28
The “Jordan McKinney” channel
The predominant solution I heard was to just let the fees take care of it. And this is just, seems like it's possible that that could work, but it just seems like bad design, right? Because you just don't know what the fees are gonna be.
Their exact words · the original at 42:5117:06 · zh ~17:45
Narrator
Remember BlackRock's warning?
17:08 · zh ~17:47
Narrator
It isn't the only one.
17:11 · zh ~17:50
17:14 · zh ~17:54
17:15 · zh ~17:55
Narrator
Nineteen publicly traded miners.
17:17 · zh ~17:58
Narrator
All nineteen.
17:19 · zh ~17:59
17:22 · zh ~18:03
Narrator
One sentence, in all ten.
Narration paraphrases · What the Bitcoin treasury companies' filings say about the halving (Pa…17:24 · zh ~18:06
17:27 · zh ~18:09
17:34 · zh ~18:17
Narrator
It isn't only the companies.
17:36 · zh ~18:20
Narrator
Economists and central-bank researchers have been asking the same question for a decade.
17:42 · zh ~18:26
Narrator
The Bank for International Settlements, the bank for the world's central banks, published a paper by one of its economists.
17:49 · zh ~18:35
Narrator
He concluded that fees alone can't pay miners enough to keep Bitcoin secure.
17:55 · zh ~18:41
Narrator
At Princeton, researchers showed that once only fees are left, it pays miners to rewrite each other's blocks and grab the fees, instead of protecting the chain.
18:06 · zh ~18:53
Narrator
At the University of Chicago, the economist Eric Budish argued that miners' pay has to stay large compared with what an attacker could gain.
18:15 · zh ~19:04
Narrator
Different authors, different methods.
18:17 · zh ~19:07
Narrator
The same question: who pays for security when the reward runs out?
18:24 · zh ~19:15
Narrator
At the University of Cambridge this autumn, a new report put fees at 0.67% of miner revenue.
Narration paraphrases · Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance: Funding Bitcoin's future, pa…18:32 · zh ~19:23
Narrator
Fees replacing the subsidy, it said, has not been tested at scale.
Narration paraphrases · Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance: Funding Bitcoin's future, pa…18:38 · zh ~19:30
Narrator
MARA is one of those nineteen miners, and one of the largest.
18:42 · zh ~19:34
Narrator
Its chief executive, Fred Thiel:
18:45 · zh ~19:37
Fred Thiel
look at the whole security budget of Bitcoin, which is, I think, the bigger question people should be talking about with all of these miners pivoting is that, you know, transaction fees were meant to compensate miners for the halving. –Right. –Well, that isn't happening.
Their view · the original at 39:1619:01 · zh ~19:54
Narrator
His own company has been moving its power into AI.
19:05 · zh ~19:58
Narrator
In his words:
19:06 · zh ~20:00
Fred Thiel
today, power is the thing, obviously, which is why ourselves and many of our peers have pivoted because you get a lot more money per electron if you're doing it for AI than for Bitcoin mining.
Their exact words · the original at 8:2819:19 · zh ~20:13
Bob Burnett
They're leaving in droves. Why are they leaving? Well, on the surface, they're leaving because they have an asset, which is power. They have contracts for power and they have, they have land and they have some of the electrical infrastructure that AI wants. And AI is willing to throw a bunch of money at them, more money than they can make mining. So, they're taking it.
Their exact words · the original at 57:4119:47 · zh ~20:42
Narrator
Since the last halving, the list keeps growing.
19:50 · zh ~20:46
Narrator
SBI Crypto closed its mining pool.
19:53 · zh ~20:49
Narrator
Poolin, once the largest pool in the world, filed for bankruptcy.
Narration paraphrases · The Block: former bitcoin miner Poolin files Chapter 11, sets $52 mill…19:58 · zh ~20:54
Narrator
So did the miner Rhodium.
20:00 · zh ~20:56
Narrator
Binance is closing its pool.
20:02 · zh ~20:58
Narrator
Bitfury, Bit Digital and Northern Data have stepped away from mining.
20:07 · zh ~21:03
Narrator
And Core Scientific, IREN, Cipher, Bitfarms, TeraWulf, Hut 8, Galaxy, CleanSpark, Riot, Hive, Bitdeer and MARA are moving their power into AI.
Narration paraphrases · Bitcoin miners and pools that moved into AI/HPC or left mining (overni…20:23 · zh ~21:23
Narrator
It's the same lesson as Monero, in slow motion.
20:27 · zh ~21:27
20:31 · zh 21:31
Jihan Wu
The competition among the Bitcoin miners has been very strong than before, much, much stronger than before, and the hash price also go to the lowest point right now in history.
Their exact words · the original at 8:2820:48 · zh ~21:48
Narrator
Nick Hansen runs Luxor, one of the ten largest mining groups.
Narration paraphrases · mempool.space pools, 1-week window (Luxor 9th by blocks found), with H…20:53 · zh ~21:53
Narrator
What fixes this, he says, is people actually using Bitcoin:
20:58 · zh ~21:58
Nick Hansen
we need users, we need customers, people to use this thing. At the end of the day it's a service to move money around. People need to be paying to use that, and right now nobody's really doing that
Their exact words · the original at 4:2821:08 · zh ~22:08
Narrator
Six months later, raising money for his company, he put it this way: compute markets are converging.
Narration paraphrases · Decrypt: bitcoin mining firm Luxor raises $16 million for AI compute21:15 · zh ~22:15
Narrator
The same miners, power sites and capital that served digital mining are now powering AI.
21:22 · zh ~22:22
Narrator
Later in this film, you'll meet a miner who ignored one of the proposed answers, until he took a second look.
IV · The Clock
21:28 to 29:52 · 75 lines
21:28 to 29:52 · 75 lines
21:35 · zh ~22:37
Narrator
How much should Bitcoin spend on its guards?
21:38 · zh ~22:41
Narrator
Even Bitcoin's own podcasters don't know:
21:42 · zh ~22:45
PBJ
we don't know how to model it. And we don't know what the security budget needs to be.
Their exact words · the original at 16:2421:47 · zh ~22:51
Narrator
The investment strategist Lyn Alden put an appropriate level at fifty cents to a dollar fifty a year, for every hundred dollars of bitcoin.
Narration paraphrases · Lyn Alden, "Bitcoin: Fee-Based Security Modeling"21:56 · zh ~23:02
22:00 · zh ~23:05
22:02 · zh ~23:08
Narrator
James McAvity, who ran a mining company, watches the same number.
22:07 · zh ~23:13
Narrator
In 2023 he called about one and a half percent healthy:
Narration paraphrases · James McAvity on The Mining Pod (t38 clip)22:11 · zh ~23:18
James McAvity
You know, the metric that I like to look at is what is mining revenue versus the total market cap of Bitcoin. And right now it's around one and a half percent. You wanted to stay in a healthy range there. If that drops down to say 20 basis points, 10 basis points, maybe even lower, It's just a different system. It's a different protocol.
Their exact words · the original at 8:1122:32 · zh ~23:41
Narrator
The Bitcoin Security Budget site calls anything above a dollar healthy.
Narration paraphrases · btcsecuritybudget.com, Explanation panel: 'a good state if ... the rel…22:36 · zh ~23:47
Narrator
And in a 2020 talk, the researcher Hasu measured Bitcoin paying two dollars.
Narration paraphrases · Hasu, Is Bitcoin secure after the block subsidy ends? (Value of Bitcoi…22:42 · zh ~23:53
Narrator
Call the floor a dollar.
22:43 · zh ~23:54
Narrator
One percent.
22:45 · zh ~23:56
Narrator
That's a share, not a price: a dollar of every hundred, whatever one bitcoin costs.
Our calculation · the data and the math22:51 · zh ~24:04
Narrator
Today, Bitcoin spends about 80 cents, already under it.
Our calculation · the data and the math22:55 · zh ~24:08
Narrator
In 2028 the reward is cut in half again, and that drops to about forty, if fees stay where they are.
Our calculation · the data and the math23:02 · zh ~24:16
23:05 · zh ~24:20
Narrator
Under even Alden's range.
Narration paraphrases · Lyn Alden, "Bitcoin: Fee-Based Security Modeling"23:08 · zh ~24:22
Narrator
And a higher price won't lift it.
23:10 · zh ~24:25
Narrator
It raises the reward and the value it guards by the same amount, so on this measure the price cancels out.
23:22 · zh ~24:38
Narrator
Picture one bitcoin at $10 million, with the reward all but gone and fees where they are now.
Our calculation · the data and the math23:29 · zh ~24:47
23:33 · zh ~24:50
Narrator
It sounds like a lot.
23:34 · zh ~24:52
Narrator
But it would be guarding more than $200 trillion: about half a cent in every hundred dollars.
Our calculation · the data and the math23:41 · zh ~25:00
Narrator
Gold, by one rough estimate, spends about 70 cents in every hundred a year keeping itself safe.
Narration paraphrases · Sam Wouters on gold's security spend, What Bitcoin Did23:48 · zh ~25:07
Narrator
Sam Wouters, who made that estimate, wasn't sure the comparison holds.
Narration paraphrases · Sam Wouters on gold's security spend, What Bitcoin Did23:52 · zh ~25:12
Narrator
But a digital gold that spends a sliver of what gold does would be a hard comparison to keep.
23:58 · zh ~25:19
Narrator
Inside Bitcoin, only fees can move this line up.
24:02 · zh ~25:24
Narrator
People who wave this away point to 2140, when the reward runs out.
Our calculation · the data and the math24:07 · zh ~25:29
Narrator
It doesn't need to run out.
24:09 · zh ~25:31
Narrator
It only needs to get too small.
24:18 · zh 25:42
Narrator
With the guards’ pay shrinking like that, you’d expect alarm. Instead, some of Bitcoin’s best-known voices say there’s no problem at all.
Narration paraphrases · The 25 voices in this section, each linked on its own page24:29 · zh 25:53
Jack Mallers
this is also a problem that is way out in the future.
Their exact words · the original at 7:4724:32 · zh 25:56
24:35 · zh 25:58
24:39 · zh 26:02
Cory Klippsten
So did you share that concern at that time, and then - Not at all. That's basically altcoin miners pumping that narrative trying to do altcoin things on Bitcoin.
Their exact words · the original at 6:4024:48 · zh 26:11
Matthew Kratter
In my opinion, people who say that transaction fees will not sufficiently compensate Bitcoin miners, this kind of FUD is no different from the halving FUD, and these people have been proven wrong again and again.
Their exact words · the original at 27:4725:00 · zh 26:24
Pierre Rochard
I think my most controversial Bitcoin opinion is on this topic called the security budget. there's this perception that that makes Bitcoin less and less secure and that it undermines transaction finality. I don't think that's true.
Their view · the original at 1:5725:13 · zh 26:36
Giacomo Zucco
there is no security budget issue That's a circular argument because if people need on-chain finality They will spend fees in order to ensure on-chain finality
Their exact words · the original at 2:2325:23 · zh 26:47
Andreas Antonopoulos
Fees go up, reward goes down. I'm not worried, because it won't be a surprise.
Their view · the original at 1:3225:29 · zh 26:53
Asher Genoot
How do you see that evolving over the next 10 to 20 years? …really hope ordinals pick up and transaction fees really go up.
Their exact words · the original at 39:5525:37 · zh 27:00
Brian Armstrong
but they'll still make money from transaction fees.
Their exact words · the original at 1:33:4425:39 · zh 27:03
Knut Svanholm
the biggest flaw in the argument about security budget is thinking that Bitcoin will not double in value every four years. If it does, then the problem goes away, because the miners get paid exactly the same, like in fiat terms at least.
Their exact words · the original at 14:2125:54 · zh 27:17
Jeff Booth
and so the problem doesn't exist. The block reward is enough all the way to 2140
Their exact words · the original at 34:0926:00 · zh 27:23
Mike Colyer
fees haven't gone up like everyone predicted we're just continuing to add more hash rate which is security for the network
Their exact words · the original at 20:1626:08 · zh 27:31
Anthony Pompliano
regardless of price being up or down hashrate continues to increase and the network continues to get more secure.
Their exact words · the original at 0:4826:14 · zh 27:38
Dylan LeClair
it's a self-correcting mechanism and yeah, I'm not too worried. / So maybe that's naive.
Their exact words · the original at 14:2026:19 · zh 27:43
Narrator
And there are many more.
Narration paraphrases · The eight quote cards on screen during this line26:25 · zh 27:48
Narrator
Michael Saylor: a trillion dollars a year in transaction fees. Nothing wrong with that.
Exact words · Michael Saylor on What is Money? with Robert Breedlove, The Saylor Ser…26:31 · zh 27:55
Narrator
Daniel Batten: you don’t need a security budget.
Exact words · Daniel Batten, interview with CriptoNoticias26:35 · zh 27:59
Joe Burnett
it's not that miners provide security for Bitcoin, it's that miners introduce, you know, a level of transaction finality.
Their exact words · the original at 5:0326:44 · zh 28:08
Knut Svanholm
The core mistake lies here. Bitcoin is for the users, not for the miners. It's the users who set the rules.
Their exact words · the original at 15:3526:52 · zh 28:16
Saifedean Ammous
there's no supermarket where you just walk in, give them money and walk out with 51% of the hash power.
Their exact words · the original at 37:2026:58 · zh 28:21
Dan Roberts
51 percent attacks, they don't work like it's never going to happen, what are you actually achieving by attacking the network? Nothing.
Their exact words · the original at 26:3027:05 · zh 28:29
Ben Gagnon
Let's say I want to do a 51% attack. It's a very short-sighted economic incentive because I can pull this off once
Their exact words · the original at 21:2827:12 · zh 28:36
Robert Breedlove or Radu Chichi
you're still incentivized to basically be honest
Their exact words · the original at 2:5627:14 · zh 28:38
Ansel Lindner
A nation state attack or a short seller attack. Those aren't real.
Their exact words · the original at 13:2427:19 · zh 28:42
Ian Major
Do you really think that all the hardcore Bitcoiners that are out there that have stored their life force in Bitcoin are just going to go down without a fight?
Their exact words · the original at 18:1427:27 · zh 28:50
Richard Heart
No one does 51% attacks because they're not profitable It's never gonna happen because it doesn't make financial f***ing sense
Their exact words · the original at 0:0027:33 · zh 28:56
Bitcoin Mechanic
the security budget is not a real problem, guys.
Their exact words · the original at 41:1827:36 · zh 28:59
Narrator
Dan Held: hash rate hasn’t materially dropped, and sounds like you don’t understand basic game theory.
Exact words · Dan Held (@danheld) on X, a reply to @natssats, @grok and @choirzooh27:43 · zh 29:06
Narrator
But hash rate counts machines, not money.
Narration paraphrases · The film's own reasoning; a clip a few seconds later (Jordan McKinney,…27:46 · zh 29:09
Narrator
Machines get better every year, so hash rate can keep climbing while miners are paid less.
Narration paraphrases · The film's own reasoning; a clip a few seconds later (Jordan McKinney,…27:52 · zh 29:15
Narrator
An attacker buys the same better machines.
Narration paraphrases · The film's own reasoning; a clip a few seconds later (Jordan McKinney,…27:54 · zh 29:18
Narrator
What he has to outspend is what miners are paid.
Narration paraphrases · The film's own reasoning; a clip a few seconds later (Jordan McKinney,…27:59 · zh 29:22
Narrator
As of 14 November, miners’ pay is 70% of what it was at the record. The same machines, paid nearly a third less. And every four years, the halving cuts it again.
Our calculation · the data and the math28:13 · zh 29:36
Narrator
Question the narrative and you might be labelled retarded.
Narration paraphrases · Dan Held's post, quoted above in the film28:19 · zh 29:43
Nick Hansen
My concern level was like an eight or ten back in 2024, mostly because I'm kind of thinking about the halving of probably 2032.
Their exact words · the original at 4:1328:28 · zh 29:52
The "Jordan McKinney" channel
And some people will say like, Oh, if hash power keeps going up, the system is more secure. And that's not strictly true. So, you shouldn't, it's not strictly about like the hash power itself. It's all about the amount the miners are spending, right?
Their exact words · the original at 37:1928:47 · zh 30:11
Paul Sztorc
It goes down very, very rapidly, and it just kind of barely survives until the end. So it's going to be a concern long before the year 2140.
Their exact words · the original at 2:0928:56 · zh ~30:19
Eric Budish
If the block reward falls by a lot, some computers are gonna turn off. If it falls by enough that you wouldn't wanna pay even if the computer were free, you wouldn't wanna pay the electricity cost, some computers are gonna get shut off. So if enough capital is mothballed for a long enough period of time, this would seem like it could raise vectors for attack where an attacker could get their hands on a lot of cheap chips.
Their exact words · the original at 59:4329:22 · zh ~30:47
Narrator
Canaan makes mining machines.
29:24 · zh ~30:49
Narrator
Its vice president, Liang Wang, on mining after 2028:
Narration paraphrases · The Blockspace Podcast, Liang Wang, vice-president of Canaan (t51 tape…29:29 · zh ~30:54
Liang Wang
I don't know the answer to that question because it is not the AI HPC that's taking away the attention. It is the economics of mining itself that is going worse by time
Their exact words · the original at 48:5629:43 · zh ~31:09
Liang Wang
We still think this is very important, but we don't, we don't think the monetary benefits will be a key driver after 2028. I hope I'm wrong.
Their view · the original at 51:15V · The Trap
29:52 to 35:44 · 48 lines
29:52 to 35:44 · 48 lines
29:59 · zh ~31:25
Narrator
So why not just fix it?
30:01 · zh ~31:27
Narrator
Every fix on the table breaks a promise.
30:04 · zh ~31:31
Narrator
Make the blocks bigger, so more fees fit in each one.
30:07 · zh ~31:34
Narrator
But space isn't demand: with room to spare, fees fall toward zero.
30:13 · zh ~31:40
Narrator
Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin SV both tried it, and today their fees pay their miners almost nothing.
30:19 · zh 31:47
Joshua Henslee
It doesn't matter if we have two gigabyte blocks. How much money are people making? If you look at the blocks, they earn 0.2 BSV, which is $6. Imagine if you told a BTC miner you could mine a two gigabyte block and earn six bucks, they would tell you to get out of here. Rightfully so, because they were getting a one megabyte block, yet they were earning $360,000.
Their exact words · the original at 11:3730:41 · zh ~32:09
Narrator
And the bigger the blocks, the fewer people can check the record for themselves.
30:46 · zh ~32:14
Narrator
Have a government pay the miners: then the guards answer to that government.
30:50 · zh ~32:19
Narrator
A government that pays the miners can tell them which payments to block.
30:54 · zh ~32:23
Narrator
That's censorship, exactly what Bitcoin was built to resist.
31:00 · zh ~32:29
Narrator
Or charge coins for sitting still, what's called demurrage: the longer your coins sit, the more it costs to move them, and the charge goes to the miners.
31:09 · zh ~32:39
Narrator
Peter Todd has argued for it:
31:12 · zh ~32:42
Peter Todd
demurrage is a mechanism to go fund a particular thing that is a public good in the context of Bitcoin. That's what I'm talking about and that's what I'm making an argument for.
Their exact words · the original at 23:5831:23 · zh ~32:55
Narrator
He calls it a tax on holding a coin.
31:26 · zh ~32:58
Narrator
It would tax everyone who holds bitcoin, for every ten minutes they hold it.
Narration paraphrases · Peter Todd, "Tail Emissions and Demurrage", bitcoin++ Toronto31:31 · zh ~33:03
Narrator
The next fix: print new bitcoin forever, what's called a tail emission, and it stops being scarce.
31:39 · zh ~33:11
Narrator
Mike Casey came out of MARA, and now researches Bitcoin's security:
31:43 · zh ~33:16
Mike Casey
I don't think a tail emission is something that's part of the contract people signed up for when they bought Bitcoin. Everybody was sold on a 21 million hard cap, you know, forever. That's the entire premise of it.
Their view · the original at 25:3131:55 · zh 33:29
Dan Held
I ask them, what is an appropriate level of security budget? No one knows. No one knows how much is necessary. And so to say that it's flawed and Bitcoin's gonna have to change its 21 million hard cap to keep the subsidy going because the security will fall so low. I find that incredibly dishonest.
Their exact words · who said it and where32:14 · zh ~33:48
Narrator
And printing forever may not even keep it safe.
32:18 · zh ~33:49
Narrator
Look at a coin that does print forever.
32:21 · zh ~33:55
Mike Casey
if you look at Monero, Monero, they have a tail emission and they put a lot of work into that tail emission and they're still regularly 51% attacked right now. Monero.
Their exact words · the original at 3:2932:36 · zh ~34:11
Narrator
The one from the start of this film.
32:38 · zh ~34:14
Narrator
It pays its guards forever.
32:40 · zh ~34:16
Narrator
But forever isn't the same as enough.
32:43 · zh ~34:19
Narrator
Its pay was small enough that an outside project could offer the machines more.
32:48 · zh ~34:24
Narrator
So printing forever, put to the test, still came up short.
32:56 · zh ~34:33
Narrator
Back to the board.
32:57 · zh ~34:35
Narrator
Another suggestion has been to change the proof of work that made Bitcoin famous: a new puzzle for the machines, or something like proof of stake, which Ethereum uses.
33:08 · zh ~34:46
Narrator
Vijay Boyapati is one of the strongest believers that the fees will be fine.
33:13 · zh ~34:51
Narrator
Asked what happens if they aren't:
33:14 · zh ~34:53
Vijay Boyapati
Under an extremely grave situation, it would be possible for participants in the network to say, we want to change our proof of work function. What would that do to an attacker? Every machine that they had bought, all of the electricity that they'd put into attacking the Bitcoin network would instantly be worth nothing. That's a nuclear option, which would be very contentious because people, you know, that's a fundamental building block of Bitcoin.
Their exact words · the original at 33:2933:43 · zh ~35:24
Narrator
It wouldn't pay the guards.
33:45 · zh ~35:26
Narrator
It would fire all of them, the honest ones too.
33:49 · zh ~35:30
Narrator
Ethereum did exactly that in 2022.
Exact words · Ethereum's Merge: last proof-of-work block 15,537,393, first proof-of-…33:52 · zh ~35:34
Narrator
When it moved to proof of stake, its miners' machines stopped earning there overnight, and the coins themselves took over the guarding: the more coins you put up, the more say you have.
34:03 · zh ~35:45
Narrator
That can work for a new coin.
34:05 · zh ~35:48
Narrator
But it would change who guards Bitcoin: no longer machines that cost real energy to outvote, but whoever holds the most coins, like the biggest exchanges and funds.
34:16 · zh ~36:00
Narrator
Which leaves doing nothing, and hoping the fees grow into it.
34:21 · zh ~36:05
PBJ
I think Bitcoin will survive if there's sufficient usage and demand, which creates a certain security budget, which just happens to be enough. And so it's not, that's why I'd call it like a flawed design, but I think it'll work out.
Their view · the original at 19:3334:39 · zh ~36:25
Narrator
Even if fees ran forever at their best month on record, January 2018, this gap would open again after 2028.
Our calculation · the data and the math34:48 · zh ~36:34
Matt Crosby
And again, the potential for a 51% attack by a nefarious nation state or something. So I'm not saying that this is definitely going to happen, but I think people arguing about NFTs on Bitcoin, or arguing about whatever it may be, are really missing the larger picture of Bitcoin needing a better mechanism to secure itself decades into the future.
Their view · the original at 26:2835:11 · zh ~36:59
Narrator
The halvings are certain.
35:13 · zh ~37:01
Narrator
The fees are not.
35:19 · zh ~37:08
Narrator
bitcoin price has gone up far more than 2x every 4 years, budget is probably higher than needed Could the price just double at every halving, forever?
Exact words · Adam Back, post on X35:31 · zh ~37:20
Narrator
Seven more doublings, by 2052, and bitcoin would be worth more than everything the world produces in a year today.
Our calculation · the data and the math35:41 · zh ~37:31
Narrator
Price alone can't carry the budget.
35:44 · zh ~37:35
Narrator
That is the plan today.
VI · A Different Answer
35:44 to 52:47 · 221 lines
35:44 to 52:47 · 221 lines
35:50 · zh ~37:42
Narrator
One idea on the board breaks neither promise.
35:56 · zh ~37:49
Narrator
It pays the same miners a second reward, for the same blocks, by a fixed formula, in a separate digital token called NAT.
36:05 · zh ~37:59
Narrator
Since February 2025, every new NAT has gone to Bitcoin's miners, along with each block's reward.
Our calculation · the data and the math36:13 · zh ~38:08
Narrator
Bitcoin's rules don't change.
36:14 · zh ~38:10
Narrator
The 21 million doesn't change.
Narration paraphrases · NAT FAQ (nat-faq), on Bitcoin's consensus rules being untouched; check…36:17 · zh ~38:13
Narrator
Miners run nothing new, and every Bitcoin block pays it.
36:22 · zh ~38:18
Narrator
NAT is worth whatever the market decides.
36:24 · zh ~38:21
Narrator
If they value it, the machines earn more for the same work.
36:28 · zh ~38:25
36:30 · zh ~38:28
Narrator
At the start of this film, that was the danger.
36:33 · zh ~38:31
Narrator
Here, it's the point.
36:35 · zh ~38:33
Narrator
Qubic's pay came with instructions.
36:38 · zh ~38:37
Narrator
NAT's comes with none: by formula, it goes to whoever mines Bitcoin's next block.
36:44 · zh ~38:43
Narrator
If people don't value it, NAT loses its value, and Bitcoin is untouched.
36:49 · zh ~38:49
Narrator
For Bitcoin, that is the whole downside.
36:52 · zh ~38:53
Narrator
There's no ceiling written into it: the more people value NAT, the more it pays.
36:58 · zh ~39:00
Narrator
Closing the gap would take a market many times bigger than it has today.
37:03 · zh ~39:05
Narrator
Today it adds tens of dollars to each block, next to hundreds of thousands in bitcoin.
Our calculation · the data and the math37:09 · zh ~39:12
Narrator
Developers.
37:10 · zh ~39:13
Narrator
Miners.
37:11 · zh ~39:14
Narrator
Investors.
37:12 · zh ~39:15
Narrator
Fund managers.
37:13 · zh ~39:17
Narrator
Economists.
37:14 · zh ~39:18
Narrator
Even central-bank researchers.
37:17 · zh ~39:21
Narrator
Everyone you've heard and read so far sees the same problem.
37:21 · zh ~39:25
Narrator
Almost everyone who looks closely does.
37:24 · zh ~39:29
Narrator
Where NAT comes from matters.
37:26 · zh ~39:31
Narrator
Every Bitcoin block, back to the very first one in January 2009, carries a number called bits, part of how Bitcoin sets its difficulty.
Narration paraphrases · Bitcoin genesis block header (block 0), bits field 0x1d00ffff37:36 · zh ~39:43
Narrator
NAT is that number, read as a token.
37:39 · zh ~39:46
Narrator
Nobody sets how much each block pays: Bitcoin's own difficulty does.
37:45 · zh ~39:53
Narrator
Bitcoin had been writing it all along.
37:47 · zh ~39:55
The Block Runner
Today we're dropping Digital Matter Theory.
Their exact words · who said it and where37:51 · zh ~39:59
The Block Runner
And so that's why we chose the field we did, which is the element, I think is the 11th field, which is bits.
Their view · who said it and where37:57 · zh ~40:07
The Block Runner
And because the number gets smaller, as hash power goes up, the emissions of NAT goes down.
Their exact words · the original at 50:4338:02 · zh ~40:13
The Block Runner
At the time it was just an experiment. It was, there's, there's no association with like security budget issues. It was nothing like that.
Their exact words · the original at 49:0438:11 · zh ~40:22
Narrator
It launched in November 2023 as an open mint.
Narration paraphrases · NATpaper (natgmi.com), launch details: Date November 20, 2023; start b…38:14 · zh ~40:26
Narrator
There was no pre-mine and no share for its makers: the only way to get NAT was to mint it, block by block, like anyone else.
38:23 · zh ~40:36
Narrator
More than twenty thousand people minted it in its first week.
Narration paraphrases · NATpaper (natgmi.com): Participation, 'Over 20,000 people joined, mint…38:26 · zh ~40:40
Narrator
Today more than forty-five thousand addresses hold some, on Bitcoin, Ethereum and BNB Chain.
Our calculation · the data and the math38:33 · zh ~40:48
Narrator
That changed at block eight hundred eighty-five thousand, five hundred eighty-eight, in February 2025.
Our calculation · the data and the math38:41 · zh ~40:56
Narrator
Paying the miners began as a fix: bots were minting every new block.
38:46 · zh ~41:02
Narrator
Its makers say the security case came after.
38:49 · zh ~41:06
Markus Bopp ("Benny")
So it was not an engineered thing. Oh, let's do it like this, like this, and we have a long reaching plan, you know, to help NAT or not. It was simply just stop the bots from minting it.
Their exact words · the original at 17:0439:03 · zh ~41:22
Narrator
The problem it answers is older.
39:06 · zh ~41:26
Narrator
Satoshi wrote it down in 2010.
Narration paraphrases · Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcointalk.org forum post39:10 · zh ~41:30
Narrator
Mining groups take it because it costs them nothing: AntPool, F2Pool, SpiderPool, ViaBTC and Luxor.
Narration paraphrases · NAT adoption ledger: dated adoption per mining pool39:18 · zh ~41:39
Narrator
In August, a proposal called BIP-110 tried a temporary change to Bitcoin's rules, one that would have limited how much non-payment data, like images and tokens, a transaction can carry.
Narration paraphrases · bit.com knowledge hub on BIP-110, with Jameson Lopp's 'A layman's guid…39:31 · zh ~41:54
Narrator
When its vote opened, two and a half percent of miners backed it.
Our calculation · the data and the math39:35 · zh ~41:58
Narrator
It needed fifty-five.
Narration paraphrases · BIP-110 activation threshold, as reported by CoinDesk and Cointelegrap…39:36 · zh ~42:00
Narrator
When its window closed, support fell to zero.
39:40 · zh ~42:04
Narrator
The crypto press covered it for weeks.
39:42 · zh ~42:07
Narrator
NAT is taken by pools that find fifty-seven percent of Bitcoin's blocks, including three that never backed BIP-110.
Our calculation · the data and the math39:50 · zh ~42:16
Narrator
None of those outlets has written a word about it.
39:53 · zh ~42:19
Narrator
Two of them, F2Pool and SpiderPool, pass it on to the miners who work with them.
Narration paraphrases · NAT adoption ledger: downstream distribution (F2Pool help page; KuCoin…39:59 · zh ~42:26
Narrator
That's how NAT reaches miners who never chose it: their pool did.
40:04 · zh ~42:31
Narrator
Most of it stops at the pool.
40:06 · zh ~42:34
Narrator
Only two pass it on.
Narration paraphrases · NAT adoption ledger and the 4 Nov 2026 recheck: no third pool found pa…40:08 · zh ~42:36
Narrator
About half of all the NAT ever credited to miners hasn't been touched, and Foundry alone has over nine trillion sitting unclaimed.
Our calculation · the data and the math40:18 · zh ~42:47
Narrator
Until a pool passes it on or decides to use it as a second subsidy, it stays dormant in its coinbase address.
40:25 · zh ~42:55
Narrator
Chances are, you've never heard of it.
40:28 · zh ~42:58
Narrator
If you have heard of it, it was probably as a joke.
40:31 · zh ~43:02
Narrator
In September 2025, seven months after NAT started paying miners, the creator of Ordinals went through every project built on Bitcoin, on a podcast.
Narration paraphrases · Casey Rodarmor, "Every Bitcoin Metaprotocol & L2", Hell Money Podcast40:42 · zh ~43:14
Narrator
One was DMT, the system NAT is built on: tokens read from each block's own data.
40:49 · zh ~43:21
Casey Rodarmor
Look, I'm going to issue a token, and one unit of that token is going to exist every time there's a 69 inside of a block hash in a Bitcoin block. –Fuck yeah.
Their exact words · the original at 33:4840:59 · zh ~43:32
Erin
I think of all of these, this is like, this one's asking the right questions.
Their view · the original at 35:3441:04 · zh ~43:38
Narrator
No fork.
41:05 · zh ~43:39
Narrator
No new bitcoin.
41:07 · zh ~43:41
Narrator
No one deciding how much each block pays.
41:10 · zh ~43:44
Narrator
And no one made to pay for it.
41:12 · zh ~43:46
Narrator
The future of Bitcoin's security can be opt-in.
41:16 · zh ~43:51
Narrator
So why would anyone buy it?
41:19 · zh ~43:54
Narrator
Start with who needs it.
41:21 · zh ~43:56
Narrator
Everyone who owns bitcoin.
41:22 · zh ~43:59
Narrator
The miners.
41:23 · zh ~44:00
Narrator
The funds and the companies holding billions of it.
41:27 · zh ~44:04
Narrator
Governments that now keep it in reserve.
41:30 · zh ~44:08
Narrator
All of it rests on one thing: the pay that keeps the network safe.
41:34 · zh ~44:14
Narrator
And that pay is cut in half every four years.
Narration paraphrases · Bitcoin protocol: the block subsidy halves every 210,000 blocks (about…41:38 · zh 44:18
Adam Sullivan
The expectation is that when block reward gets cut in half, difficulty drops, or how hard it is to find a block. In this previous halving, difficulty did not really fall off. And so mining revenue did get cut almost nearly in half in April, in a single day.
Their exact words · who said it and where41:53 · zh ~44:34
Narrator
NAT adds to that pay without changing a line of Bitcoin.
41:57 · zh ~44:40
Narrator
No fork, no vote, no one made to pay.
42:00 · zh ~44:44
Narrator
So for anyone holding bitcoin, it isn't a bet on some new coin.
42:04 · zh ~44:49
Narrator
It's a small cost to protect something far bigger that they already own.
42:08 · zh ~44:56
Narrator
And it's a fix they have every reason to tell people about.
42:12 · zh ~45:02
Narrator
That's what gives everyone else a reason to look: a real utility, a story you can explain in one sentence, and buyers with a reason to hold.
42:21 · zh ~45:14
Narrator
Anytime someone asks me why would I buy it, I show them two things.
42:26 · zh ~45:18
Narrator
The gap.
42:27 · zh ~45:20
Narrator
And every other fix.
42:30 · zh ~45:23
Narrator
This is the size of the gap in the Bitcoin security budget.
42:34 · zh ~45:28
Narrator
Take that one-dollar floor.
Narration paraphrases · NAT sizing registry: target_pct 1.0 (Lyn Alden's band 0.5-1.5% of bitc…42:36 · zh ~45:30
42:38 · zh ~45:33
Narrator
The gap, about 20 cents on every hundred dollars of bitcoin, comes to about $3 billion a year.
Our calculation · the data and the math42:46 · zh ~45:42
Narrator
And if fees stay where they are, every halving makes it bigger.
42:50 · zh ~45:48
42:53 · zh ~45:52
42:56 · zh ~45:55
42:59 · zh ~45:58
43:03 · zh ~46:03
Narrator
At today's price, that's more than $15 billion a year.
Our calculation · the data and the math43:09 · zh ~46:10
Narrator
Say you hold a hundred thousand dollars of bitcoin.
43:12 · zh ~46:14
Narrator
The guard is being paid about eight hundred a year to secure it.
Our calculation · the data and the math43:16 · zh ~46:19
43:19 · zh ~46:22
Narrator
What do you think happens when the guard's pay keeps shrinking?
43:23 · zh ~46:27
Narrator
For NAT to pay even today's gap, it would have to be worth more than $50 billion.
Our calculation · the data and the math43:29 · zh ~46:34
43:31 · zh ~46:37
Narrator
Less than Michael Saylor's company holds on its own.
43:35 · zh ~46:41
Narrator
Today it's worth tens of millions.
43:38 · zh ~46:44
Narrator
That isn't a forecast.
43:40 · zh ~46:46
Narrator
It's the size of the job.
43:43 · zh ~46:50
Narrator
Run the sum from the start of this film.
43:46 · zh ~46:53
Narrator
At Saylor's price, the gap in Bitcoin's security budget is over four trillion dollars a year.
Our calculation · the data and the math43:53 · zh ~47:01
Narrator
That's how big this problem is.
43:56 · zh ~47:04
Narrator
NAT aims to fill some of that gap.
43:58 · zh ~47:07
Narrator
Every dollar it adds is a dollar fees don't have to find.
44:03 · zh ~47:12
Narrator
The second thing I show them is every other fix on the table.
44:07 · zh ~47:18
Narrator
New bitcoin forever, a tail emission: the 21 million is gone.
Narration paraphrases · CCAF and Fii, Funding Bitcoin's Future: Paying for Security as the Blo…44:13 · zh ~47:26
Narrator
A charge on coins that sit still, what's called demurrage: every saver pays.
44:19 · zh ~47:34
Narrator
Bigger blocks: Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin SV tried it, and the fees never came.
44:26 · zh ~47:43
Narrator
A new proof of work: the honest guards are fired with the rest.
44:31 · zh ~47:49
Narrator
A government pays: the guards answer to it.
44:34 · zh ~47:53
Narrator
Or wait for fees to carry it.
44:37 · zh ~47:56
Narrator
They'd have to be about 37 times what they are today, and stay there.
Our calculation · the data and the math44:42 · zh ~48:03
44:47 · zh ~48:09
Narrator
And where would that come from?
44:49 · zh ~48:12
Narrator
Blocks are already full, and fees still sit near the minimum.
44:54 · zh ~48:18
Narrator
And if fees did climb that far, Bitcoin would be too expensive for most people to use.
45:00 · zh ~48:26
Narrator
One idea isn't on this board: a second chain that shares Bitcoin's miners.
45:06 · zh ~48:33
Narrator
Namecoin has done it since 2011.
Narration paraphrases · The NAT FAQ comparison table, row 'Namecoin, RSK since 2011' (merged m…45:08 · zh ~48:36
Narrator
Most of Bitcoin's machines already mine one called Rootstock.
45:12 · zh ~48:40
Narrator
Even the University of Cambridge has looked at this.
45:15 · zh ~48:44
Narrator
Its new report says income like that could supplement mining revenue without requiring changes to Bitcoin itself.
Narration paraphrases · CCAF and Fii, Funding Bitcoin's Future: Paying for Security as the Blo…45:22 · zh ~48:52
Narrator
For now, chains like these bring in less than 1%.
Narration paraphrases · CCAF and Fii, Funding Bitcoin's Future: Paying for Security as the Blo…45:26 · zh 48:56
Paul Sztorc
that actually the most of the current L2 stuff is in the wrong direction, and only the stuff that pays the miners has a future.
Their exact words · the original at 17:4645:33 · zh ~49:04
Narrator
But every pool that joins has a second node to run, and one more thing that can break.
45:39 · zh ~49:10
Narrator
The miners it borrows can attack that chain for almost nothing.
45:43 · zh ~49:15
Narrator
Rootstock pays from its own fees, in a coin pegged to bitcoin, so its price can't lift the pay.
45:50 · zh ~49:23
Narrator
And the peg rests on a bridge, held by a small group of signers.
45:55 · zh ~49:29
Narrator
NAT has no second chain.
45:57 · zh ~49:32
Narrator
Miners run nothing new, and its price is the pay rate.
46:02 · zh ~49:37
Narrator
Bitcoin's funds, its miners and the companies with a bitcoin reserve strategy all name the halving as a risk, in their own filings.
Narration paraphrases · The Security Budget Files: every filing that names this risk46:12 · zh ~49:50
Narrator
Every fix on that board needs Bitcoin changed, everyone to agree, or a government to pay.
46:19 · zh ~49:59
Narrator
Buying NAT needs none of that.
46:21 · zh ~50:02
Narrator
Besides hoping for fees, the only one whose size nobody has to set.
46:27 · zh ~50:08
Narrator
Every other fix is capped by a rule or a budget.
46:31 · zh ~50:13
Narrator
NAT's can grow with what people are willing to pay, as large as the gap gets, without ever affecting Bitcoin's core consensus.
46:40 · zh ~50:24
Narrator
Remember the second promise: no security, no value.
46:44 · zh ~50:30
Narrator
Bitcoin's value is only as safe as what pays to guard it.
46:48 · zh ~50:35
Narrator
NAT is one way to pay.
46:51 · zh ~50:38
Narrator
For anyone who holds bitcoin, it's the one thing they can do on their own.
46:56 · zh ~50:44
Narrator
For miners, NAT's price is a pay rate.
46:59 · zh ~50:48
Narrator
Every block they win pays NAT by a fixed formula, so what it's worth is what that block pays.
47:06 · zh ~50:56
Narrator
The formula follows Bitcoin's difficulty, so the amount moves, but gently: by about a hundredth of a percent since March 2025.
Our calculation · the data and the math47:14 · zh ~51:06
Narrator
The halving does it all at once.
47:18 · zh ~51:11
47:22 · zh ~51:15
Narrator
The NAT in every block doesn't.
47:25 · zh ~51:19
Narrator
For a miner, owning it isn't a side bet.
47:28 · zh ~51:23
Narrator
It's the one reward in their income without a cliff in it.
47:32 · zh 51:27
Narrator
This is one real block, mined on the eighth of November.
47:36 · zh 51:31
Narrator
Each cube is a transaction.
47:39 · zh 51:34
47:43 · zh 51:38
Narrator
And on top, NAT.
47:46 · zh 51:41
Narrator
Together, all those transactions paid less than 1% of what the subsidy paid.
Our calculation · the data and the math47:55 · zh 51:50
Narrator
The fees, the new bitcoin and the NAT all go to one address: the miner who found the block.
48:03 · zh ~51:58
The Block Runner
And so the idea here is that with the NAT token being sent to the miners, they'll have at least a second subsidy to sell to continue paying the bills.
Their exact words · the original at 16:4848:13 · zh ~52:09
Narrator
One miner ignored it, until people in its community asked him to take a second look.
48:19 · zh ~52:15
Narrator
Now he's building an app for it: I do not consider NAT a shitcoin.
48:25 · zh ~52:22
Joe Spencer · @CincoDoggos
It is connected to Bitcoin. When a Bitcoin block propagates, the NAT system awards a subsidy.
Their exact words · who said it and where48:33 · zh ~52:31
Joe Spencer · @CincoDoggos
That's the whole point is it's there as a secondary layer. So that way Bitcoin miners do not have to spend their Bitcoin to pay the bills for their mining, right?
Their exact words · who said it and where48:47 · zh ~52:45
Narrator
NAT is Bitcoin's security, tokenized.
48:50 · zh ~52:49
Narrator
Tokenized means there's now a market for Bitcoin's security: the guards' pay is a token anyone can buy and hold.
48:57 · zh ~52:58
Narrator
A donation is gone the day you give it.
49:00 · zh ~53:01
Narrator
NAT, you still own.
49:03 · zh ~53:05
Narrator
Take part in that market, and you're taking part in Bitcoin's security budget.
49:07 · zh ~53:10
Narrator
Every dollar of bitcoin sends less than one cent a year to the miners who guard it.
Our calculation · the data and the math49:13 · zh ~53:16
49:16 · zh ~53:20
Narrator
Both pay the same way: with new coins.
49:19 · zh ~53:23
Narrator
Bitcoin adds less than one percent a year, and halves it.
Our calculation · the data and the math49:24 · zh ~53:30
49:29 · zh ~53:36
Narrator
NAT isn't scarce.
49:30 · zh ~53:38
Narrator
The 21 million is Bitcoin's promise, not NAT's.
Narration paraphrases · NAT facts registry: emission is bits-derived, declines about 1.3% a ye…49:34 · zh ~53:43
Narrator
The new coins are NAT's, and every one goes to whoever mined the block it came from.
49:40 · zh ~53:50
Narrator
Nobody else is issued any.
49:42 · zh ~53:53
Narrator
You don't have to buy from a miner.
49:44 · zh ~53:55
Narrator
Any buyer lifts the price, and the price is what every miner's NAT can sell for.
49:50 · zh ~54:02
Narrator
So when NAT's price goes up, Bitcoin's security budget goes up with it.
49:55 · zh ~54:09
Narrator
That's the answer from the start: what they hold stands on that budget.
50:01 · zh ~54:17
Narrator
People in NAT's community call it a second chance at Bitcoin.
50:06 · zh ~54:23
Narrator
If that means a second chance to get rich, I can't promise that, and nothing here is advice.
50:12 · zh ~54:30
Narrator
The chance I mean is narrower: a second answer to the bet Satoshi made in 2010.
Narration paraphrases · Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcointalk.org forum post50:20 · zh ~54:40
Narrator
It's a bet on coordination, the way Bitcoin once was.
50:23 · zh ~54:45
Narrator
It only works if people choose to buy it and keep it.
50:26 · zh ~54:49
Narrator
Bitcoin's security protects everyone, whether they buy NAT or not.
50:31 · zh ~54:54
Narrator
So why would anyone pay for it?
50:33 · zh ~54:57
Narrator
Nobody buys bitcoin to pay miners, and the miners get paid anyway.
50:37 · zh ~55:02
Narrator
Buying NAT is a seat in the market that sets the guards' second pay.
50:41 · zh ~55:08
Narrator
People need their own reasons to take it.
50:44 · zh ~55:12
Narrator
If they don't, it fails.
50:47 · zh ~55:16
Narrator
And the link runs both ways: if NAT's price falls, so does what it adds.
50:52 · zh ~55:22
Narrator
And NAT lives on Bitcoin's own record.
50:56 · zh ~55:26
Narrator
If Bitcoin breaks, NAT breaks with it.
50:59 · zh ~55:30
Narrator
It's a raise while Bitcoin stands, not a lifeboat if it falls.
51:04 · zh ~55:36
Narrator
Wall Street is turning everything into tradable tokens.
51:08 · zh ~55:40
Narrator
What keeps Bitcoin safe has always had a cost.
51:11 · zh ~55:44
Narrator
On Bitcoin itself, it never had a price.
51:15 · zh ~55:48
Narrator
Now it has a market.
51:17 · zh 55:50
In the film's closing montage
But the size of this market is unknown, even to some of the most hardcore bitcoiners.
51:23 · zh 55:56
In the film's closing montage
We don't know how much we need We don't know if that's 1 billion, 5 billion, 10 billion, or 100 billion.
Exact words · Bitcoin Super-Cycle w/ Dan Held, Bitcoin Fundamentals (BTC016), The In…51:28 · zh 56:01
In the film's closing montage
We don't know. But we really don't know where it is.
51:31 · zh 56:05
In the film's closing montage
No one really knows.
51:33 · zh 56:06
In the film's closing montage
No one knows. No one knows how much is necessary.
51:36 · zh 56:09
In the film's closing montage
And this is ultimately the question no one can really answer.
51:40 · zh 56:13
In the film's closing montage
to $3,000, to $30,000, to $300,000.
Exact words · Michael Saylor on The Iced Coffee Hour (clip: "$300,000 a transaction"…51:42 · zh 56:15
In the film's closing montage
I'd call it like a flawed design, but I think it'll work out.
51:46 · zh 56:19
In the film's closing montage
Nobody knows the number.
51:47 · zh 56:20
In the film's closing montage
So the answer can't be a fix that needs one.
51:53 · zh ~56:27
Narrator
So that's the answer.
51:55 · zh ~56:29
Narrator
It's the only one on the board that keeps Bitcoin both scarce and safe, and the only one the market can pay for, without changing Bitcoin.
52:05 · zh ~56:40
Narrator
In 2010, Satoshi bet that fees would one day pay Bitcoin's guards.
Narration paraphrases · Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcointalk.org forum post52:10 · zh ~56:45
52:13 · zh ~56:48
52:15 · zh ~56:51
Narrator
Check the numbers for yourself.
52:17 · zh ~56:53
Narrator
NAT. Bitcoin's security, tokenized.